Never Imagined Roster Decisions This Tough | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Never Imagined Roster Decisions This Tough

Sirspud

Pro Bowler
Club Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2004
Messages
21,860
Reaction score
14,854
Age
39
Location
Haines City, Fl
So many guys not named Preston Williams came ready to play this preseason fighting for a spot.
QB - you won't keep Skylar if you waive him
RB - Mostert and Edmonds would be locks now, and after them the only power back is Michel, but he simply did nothing with his carries this preseason and didn't show any burst or exceptional power, yet he's an experienced runner. But Gaskin played so well taking those holes and using good burst, even if he'll never take one to the house, Ahmed really plays well in the passing game and has that speed that you look for, and if White doesn't at least make a practice squad somewhere, because a guy who can keep balance like him can play in the NFL even without great speed.
WR- Preston gone, we know Hill, Waddle, Wilson, are there, and EZ as a 4th round pick would have had to blow it which he didn't. Cracraft didn't show great hands at times but his route running is fantastic- that's a great asset to have in this league, and plenty of guys have carved out long careers with that skills. Sherfield did well too, and from what I understand he's a good ST player. I don't know where Bowden fits, not sure he's a running back or a wide receiver, but he's a good football player that has elusiveness even without great explosiveness.

There's way more than these positions, but I'm not as up on the story of all the competitors - but I use the top as an example because you'd like to keep more than the usual at maybe all these positions, and what will happen up top will have a cascading on spot availability with the rest of the roster. It could have an effect on whether Gesicki is kept or traded.

We may be a team that's still hamstrung by the offensive line. We may have our top defenders struggle against the better teams in this league, and who knows how this team will actually end up. But it's really fun watching the way this team is playing in the preseason and seeing guys competing to be Dolphins delivering NFL capable football up and down the roster. It speaks well to what the culture is like right now.

RIP Jason Jenkins- just heard and so horrible
 
The cuts will come down to how they practice and how they prepare. one or two good or bad plays in the preseason game are really an advertisement to other teams once they are cut.
 
This is the first time in two decades that the Dolphins have as much talent as they have throughout their roster. Obviously some position groups are stronger than other position groups but some very good players are going to end up being waived to get down to the final 53.
 
So many guys not named Preston Williams came ready to play this preseason fighting for a spot.
QB - you won't keep Skylar if you waive him
RB - Mostert and Edmonds would be locks now, and after them the only power back is Michel, but he simply did nothing with his carries this preseason and didn't show any burst or exceptional power, yet he's an experienced runner. But Gaskin played so well taking those holes and using good burst, even if he'll never take one to the house, Ahmed really plays well in the passing game and has that speed that you look for, and if White doesn't at least make a practice squad somewhere, because a guy who can keep balance like him can play in the NFL even without great speed.
WR- Preston gone, we know Hill, Waddle, Wilson, are there, and EZ as a 4th round pick would have had to blow it which he didn't. Cracraft didn't show great hands at times but his route running is fantastic- that's a great asset to have in this league, and plenty of guys have carved out long careers with that skills. Sherfield did well too, and from what I understand he's a good ST player. I don't know where Bowden fits, not sure he's a running back or a wide receiver, but he's a good football player that has elusiveness even without great explosiveness.

There's way more than these positions, but I'm not as up on the story of all the competitors - but I use the top as an example because you'd like to keep more than the usual at maybe all these positions, and what will happen up top will have a cascading on spot availability with the rest of the roster. It could have an effect on whether Gesicki is kept or traded.

We may be a team that's still hamstrung by the offensive line. We may have our top defenders struggle against the better teams in this league, and who knows how this team will actually end up. But it's really fun watching the way this team is playing in the preseason and seeing guys competing to be Dolphins delivering NFL capable football up and down the roster. It speaks well to what the culture is like right now.

RIP Jason Jenkins- just heard and so horrible
McD said it's not tough for him. The best 53 make the team. So, I wouldn't be surprised if that's 6 or maybe even 7 wrs.
 
Plus a FB (#30) is making the final 53 who hasn't played a down this PS.....I assume that Coach knows what he wants the final 53 to look like.........
 
I call bullshit on that, if McDaniel cuts Tua, you would not be good on that
He is referring to a decision MCDaniel has to make concerning the third string QB on a roster loaded with talent. Personally I would rather they keep a player who can help them in the games than a third string QB who will likely be inactive all season.

I doubt any team would claim him and put him on their 53 man roster. So I think they should waive him and resign him to the PS once he clears waivers. Yet that opinion is not shared my some posters on here and I can respect that.
 
My guess:

RB- Edmunds, Mostert, Gaskin, Ahmed and Michel with the FB

WR- Hill, Waddle, Wilson, Exukanma, Cracroft. IF 6 I think Bowden is the best talent.
 
He is referring to a decision MCDaniel has to make concerning the third string QB on a roster loaded with talent. Personally I would rather they keep a player who can help them in the games than a third string QB who will likely be inactive all season.

I doubt any team would claim him and put him on their 53 man roster. So I think they should waive him and resign him to the PS once he clears waivers. Yet that opinion is not shared my some posters on here and I can respect that.

I am with ya 100%
 
Sinnet was poached off the PS last year and Thompson is a far better prospect. Some noticed him even before the draft, as I once posted. If we invest in him and he develops we can reap a high draft pick down the line. If not us, someone else will. He will not clear waivers. I say keep him.
 
Back
Top Bottom