Peter Kiper Live at the 2008 Draft | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Peter Kiper Live at the 2008 Draft

schisno

2008 Miami Dolphins GM
Joined
Mar 10, 2005
Messages
682
Reaction score
0
Age
42
Hello once again,

This is Peter "Fish and" Kiper. I'm here live at the FHNFL 2008 Draft brought to you by FHSI-Sports Network, I will be here giving you a pick by pick selection for the first round and if I can get a new contract before the round is up I may stick around for the second.

There has been a dramatic change in the draft as Oakland traded away Adrian Peterson and Devin Hester to acquire Wes Welker, the #1 Overall selection and several other picks.

How will this play out? Does this mean Adrian Peterson will rush for 3000 Yards as part of that explosive New England offense? Time will tell if Peterson's trip from Minnesota through Oakland to New England will mirror that of Randy Moss.

Oakland is on the clock and it looks like they have made their selection...
 
OAKLAND selects RB DARREN MCFADDEN, Arkansas

As expected Darren McFadden goes first overall, except it isn't to the newly revamped Patriots offense but to the lowly Oakland Raiders who gave up a franchise running back to draft... a franchise running back.
It goes without saying that this was a puzzling move, then again not too many around the league truly understands how Al Davis' mind works.
The head scratcher is how much was given up to draft Darren McFadden who many have called this years Adrian Peterson with his breakaway speed and game changing ability. He's increased his production over his three years at college, and brings the ability to throw the football like he did at Arkansas under a special package, he also has soft hands and will play a part in the passing game. This may take some time to fathom but I'm sure the fans in Oakland are rejoicing after trading away not only AD but the best return man in the NFL in Devin Hester.

Plus
- Otherworldy speed
- Elusive with great agility
- Best feet in the draft for a running back
- Game Changing Ability
- Superb vision

Minus
- Off-field issues (Maternity suit, Nightclub fight)
- Not as strong as Adrian Peterson
- Maturity

It's really hard to knock the best running back in the draft as the number one selection. This upcoming season will tell if McFadden can hit the lofty expectations of having an Adrian Peterson type season, because this will be one of the picks that will be looked on as Oakland passed on helping their defensive line which was in dire need of help from either Glen Dorsey, Chris Long or Sedrick Ellis. For now I will have to give the Oakland Raiders a A- for this selection for giving up so much, even prior to the Adrian Peterson trades. They could have stayed at number four, and dropped back to draft either Stewart or Mendenhall, while filling more needs in the first round.

Selection Grade: A-/B+
 
BROWNS select QB MATT RYAN, Boston College

This was a toss up between Matt Ryan and Chris Long. Instead of waiting for the top ranked quarterback to slide, Cleveland took no chances and selected
Ryan with the second overall.

After trading away two solid prospects in Derek Anderson and Brady Quinn this offseason, the Browns made up for destroying one of their strengths with the selection of a possible franchise quarterback with the Boston College product.

Plus
- Tough and strong
- Prototypical size
- Has great touch and timing on his throws
- Good mechanics
- Great leader
- Intangibles

Minus
- Accuracy is a concern with number of interception
- Broken foot as a junior may cause durability concerns
- Trouble with deep throws
- Not too mobile.

There isn't a true lock for any quarterback in this class to be the next great franchise quarterback but Matt Ryan has a cool demeanor and is fearless in the pocket. He performed exceptionally well his senior year with average talent around him.

Should make an impact with the weapons surrounding him in Cleveland. Will perform as a rookie during his first year as a starter but if he keeps his interceptions down and work on his accuracy the Browns may rebound after taking a step back this year.
Selection Grade: A
 
RAMS select DE CHRIS LONG, Virginia

The first two selections were filled with offensive players and Chris Long is taken off the board by St Louis who would have easily taken Dorsey if Long had been taken in the first two.

Another first overall talent, Chris Long has the ability to stand up and fluidity to play the outside linebacker position, but will see most of his time at Defensive end beside Adam Carriker. This is a great pick by St Louis, who took my top rated defensive player.

Plus
- Non-stop motor
- Ability to stand up
- Fluid body movement
- Aggressive, hard hitter
- Great instincts
- Natural leader on defense
- NFL Hall of Fame pedigree

Minus
- Timed speed is average
- May struggle against tackles at the next level on the edge
- Quickness leaves something to be desired

St Louis takes a step forward building their defensive line, and could use Chris Long at the OLB position. He should be very productive starting as a rookie along side Adam Carriker.

May not be a hall of famer like his father, but with his motor he will be a solid and productive pro.

Selection Grade: A+
 
VIKINGS select DT GLEN DORSEY, LSU

A natural selection for the Vikings who are left with Kevin Williams and Fred Evans as their only DTs on the roster. Though they could use help at DE due to some of the troubles there, this was a more pressing need.

Glen Dorsey is the most decorated player on the defensive line coming out of college, but a big knock on him is his durability. He has bad legs struggling with a leg injury in 2006, and knee injury in 2007. Whether he makes it through a whole season is a question left to be answered.

Plus
- Non-stop motor
- Plays through injuries
- Quick and closes in quickly on target
- Strong and powerful
- Great penetration, and will wreck havoc in the backfield
- Can play either three point or nose tackle in the 4-3

Minus
- Height and bulk are average
- Durability (Issues with legs/knees)

The only real choice for Minnesota, a possible number one choice but slipped after the college season ended. Glen Dorsey has some health concerns but adds youth and solidifies the middle for the Vikings.

Selection Grade: A
 
CHIEFS select OT JAKE LONG, Michigan

The top five take shape as expected with the Chiefs selecting the top offensive tackle in the draft with the other Long, Jake. Their Offensive line is in shambles and they showed they need to rebuild after last season.

Jake Long isn't the franchise left tackle they are looking for but will man the right for years to come. There are better athletes at the tackle position in the draft, but Jake Long is the most polished leaving less room for growth.

Plus
- Tall with room to bulk up
- Very long arms
- Dominant run blocking
- Powerful on initial contact
- Smart and very aware

Minus
- Has a tough time with secondary rush
- Not much room to grow
- Not suited for the left side

Quarterback is another issue for the Chiefs who could have gone after either Brohm or Long's team mate Chad Henne. Long is the most polished prospect at offensive tackle, but the Chiefs may have been better off drafting Ryan Clady of Boise State who is more athletic and a higher ceiling.

The Chiefs make a solid pick, with a solid if unspectacular tackle who will man their right side, but leave Kansas looking for a true left tackle.

Selection Grade: B+
 
BROWNS select DE VERNON GHOLSTON, Ohio State

The second selection in the top ten lands Cleveland the best pure pass rusher, and athletic freaks of the draft in the Ohio State product. This was a weak part of the Cleveland Browns last season who struggled with the pass rush and forcing quarterbacks.

Rumors are that it was originally suppose to be Chris Long going number two to the Browns but now that Gholston is down with the Brown he brings a high end motor and freakish athletic ability that immediately upgrades a defensive line starring Shaun Smith, Orpheus Roye. If the Browns keep a 3-4 scheme Gholston may be used at the OLB position and situational rusher at defensive end.

Plus
- Amazing athletic specimen
- Strong pass rusher
- Big muscular build
- Ability to close in
- Great tackler
- Intangibles

Minus
- Consistency
- Possible case of being a better athlete than football player
- Durability issues

Chris Long is considered a better prospect at the OLB position for a 3-4 scheme, but Vernon Gholston is a freakishly athletic player who could wreck havoc as a pass rusher at the next level. Certainly would have gone prior to this pick if the Browns had selected Chris Long.

Whether he becomes a Shawn Merriman at the next level remains to be seen, but will likely be on par with DeMarcus Ware. He is big and strong and his body shows it, this was an excellent pick to help a poor pass rush for the Browns last season. Very strong pick.

Selection Grade: A+
 
SEAHAWKS select RB RASHARD MENDENHALL, Illinois

To say that running back was a need for Seattle was an understatement. They traded away the face of their franchise, who was on the downside of his career anyways.

Ron Dayne is a classic underachiver who has shown flashes with the Texans and Maurice Morris is better as a backup and situational back so this was a need. It was doubtful Mendenhall would have made it past either the Texans or Panthers, so the Seahawks made a great value pick at number seven after a last minute trade with Miami.

Plus
- Fresh legs, not a lot of mileage
- Factor in the passing game as a pass catcher
- Great size and bulk
- Stephen Davis style power runner, will pick up extra yards
- Good vision

Minus
- Not too elusive
- Was only the feature back for one year
- Ball security issues

The Seahawks could have waited to see if either Jonathan Stweart or Mendenhall would drop to them but with several other teams looking for a running back ahead of them they made the smart choice of giving up two third rounders to get a capable starter.

May not have some of the ability that Shaun Alexander had during his prime, but Mendenhall is very durable and can carry the load. Being the go to guy for only one year may raise questions about his productivity at the pro level but he'll prove to be the second best back in the draft. Great move by Seattle.

Selection Grade: A
 
FALCONS select DT SEDRICK ELLIS, USC

I know Sedrick Ellis is the second best DT on the board for a lot of people but I have written down as the third or fourth best behind Kentwan Balmer and flip flopping with Pat Sims of Auburn.

Defensive Tackle wasn't a desperate need for the Falcons because they still have Rod Coleman and Trey Lewis, but I full expected a top ranked cornerback here because the depth behind Fernando Bryant and Dominque Foxworth is lacking.
Ellis doesn't really have great size for the next level, but some have him being a very good three-technique.

Plus
- Quick first step
- Good leverage
- Uses his hands well
- Hard worker

Minus
- Height leaves something to be desired.
- Will have trouble against massive offensive lineman
- Not a fit for every team, scheme specific player

He was a very good player at the college level, but his size could hold him back in the pro game. He does have a strong work ethic that could make Sedrick Ellis a solid tackle.

I just feel after trading away DeAngelo Hall, the Falcons needed to go with a corner for depth and to eventually replace either Bryant or Foxworth. Trading back was an option, but the Falcons stayed pat and hopefully picked a smaller defensive tackle that can fit their scheme.

Selection Grade: B
 
PACKERS select LB KEITH RIVERS, USC

Back to back Trojans. Sounds like a night at the USC dorms, but in all seriousness this is a great selection by the Packers who now have a lineup of AJ Hawk, Nick Barnett and Keith Rivers.

He is a quick linebacker with great athletic ability. He should fit the scheme in Green Bay very well. They'll love his ability to hit and lay it in to opponents, as well as being able to drop back into coverage. Non-stop motor and will make plays from sideline to sideline.

Plus
- Athletic
- Good coverage skills
- Hard hitting
- Quickness and agility
- Makes plays sideline to sideline
- Non-Stop Motor

Minus
- Needs to bulk up
- Hard hitter who will go for the big hit and not wrap up
- Trouble shedding blockers at the next level

Keith Rivers is a great player and the top linebacker in the draft, but there is one glaring need the Packers needed to fill. With the lost of Bret Favre to retirement, Green Bay is left with Brian Griese as their starter, scary thought.

Not picking again until the fifth round doesn't endear the Packer's management to their fanbase. Brian Brohm continues his free fall. Maybe the Packers will move up to draft one of the second tier quarterbacks in the draft like Chad Henne or Joe Flacco.
Rivers is a good pick, but it would have been better served to select a quarterback. Maybe the Packers can select a project like Josh Johnson or Kyle Wright in the backend of the draft.

Selection Grade: B-
 
SAINTS select OT RYAN CLADY, Boise State

The most athletic offensive tackle in the draft, Clady has great size and excellent footwork. He is projected to be a very good left tackle in the NFL but right now is better served playing behind a veteran or starting on the right.

Offers good pass protection, but will have to work on his run blocking. Not necessarily a need, but the Saints are a team who could afford to splurge on this selection seeing as other positions can be filled with better value later.

Plus
- Very good size
- Big frame, can bulk up
- Nimble feet, nice footwork
- Great balance
- Good pass protection
- Cool under pressure

Minus
- Will have to get stronger
- Must work on run blocking
- Needs better leverage

With the selection of Clady one of the veteran lineman may find themselves off the Saints in 2008. Ryan Clady will more than likely start whether it is on the left side or right side will depend on the confident the Saints staff have with this selection.

I had Rodgers-Cromartie going to the Saints to be groomed to take over for Mike McKenzie when he finally decides to hang it up, but I can't argue the selection here. An easy A for the Saints by nabbing the best Left tackle prospect in the draft.

Selection Grade: A
 
TEXANS select RB JONATHAN STEWART, Oregon

The Texans either love saving money on their first round selection or believe Stewart will be available for the preseason, but the toe injury should have posted some concerns. Jonathan Stewart is a great choice at this pick if he were one hundred percent healthy, but just having surgery and the indefinite time he'll be out makes this an iffy selection.

He is bigger than Mendenhall and projected to being a better pro because of his size, power and better pass catching ability but the toe really downsizes this pick.

Plus
- Big, good bulk and very strong
- Pass catching skills
- Very hard runner
- Great vision
- Ability to return kicks
- Change of direction

Minus
- Nagging minor injuries
- Durability issues
- Just had surgery
- Not as explosive

The Texans added a big power back in the offseason with Chris Brown, but he has his durablility issues. So adding a second running back with injury problems might be a mistake. He has the added bonus of being a return man but Houston already had that option with Mewelde Moore.

They traded away a stud WR in Andre Johnson, so they would have been better served replacing him but will now go with the duo of Berrian and Clayton both of whom are not a true number one.

Also like the Packers should have addressed the quarterback position, but they are in better shape with Kevin Kolb than the Packers are with Brian Griese.

Another area that has been a problem for the franchise during its existence is the Offensive Line, which could have been filled by Jeff Otah. However the Boselli curse strikes again and everyone in Houston is holding their breath Stewart pans out.

Selection Grade: B
 
While the Broncos are on the clock I managed to catch up to the Houston Texans GM who was recently celebrating with his scouting staff on their selection. Let's take you to our interview now...

You and I don't agree on your selection of Jonathan Stewart because of his obvious health concerns and the fact I disliked the idea of trading Andre Johnson, how do you defend that deal and using the eleventh selection to draft Jonathan Stewart?

Well, I think you graded it a B Peter, so to say we completely disagree would be incorrect. Last year, he was 100% healthy until the toe injury. And, it's an injury, it's not a degenerative condiiton. It's something that with surgery will heal and he'll be 100% again in time. He elected to have the surgery now rather than miss training camp and games. We applaud him for that, and we'll stand by him as he rehabs. When I look at Jonathan run, he reminds me of Ricky Williams.

As for the Andre Johnson trade. That trade along with the Matt Schaub trade were designed to leverage us versus what we accomplished in free agency to be better in the short and more importantly long run. We signed Bernard Berrian to be our #1 receiver. You complement him on the other side with Michael Clayton. Now that you have him outside of Tampa and the mess they have had at quarterback the last few years, you'll see him return to the numbers he once posted his rookie season. We also have Jacoby Jones, with the one year of experience, he'll be ready to step in as our third receiver and perhaps push Clayton for playing time in our two wide sets.

So, we obviously felt we could move Andre and get the highest possible compensation for him, which we did in acquiring not just the 11th overall but also two third round picks and a sixth. We ended up using those two thirds to acquire Kevin Kolb, which in my opinion is an absolute steal.

With the selection of Jonathan Stewart, we feel we have greatly improved our offense and the ability to win football games. You can't win late in the season unless you can run the football.


So far after eleven picks who do you think has had the best draft thus far?

You mean outside of the Texans? That's tough. I actually question a lot of the selections ahead of us. Sure, they've drafted players with tremendous ability. But when you look at their overall plan, I can't help but think many of the GM's are out of touch with what their team should be doing. I mean at 1, you had the Raiders, after acquiring AP, they turn around and trade him for the first overall, and then select Dmac. Then they say he's available for trade too. At 2 you have Matt Ryan taken by the Browns who desperately needed a qb, yet why were they put into this position to begin with when they started off with Anderson and Quinn? You know, that's the one thing I wanted to stay away from. Trading away a player, like an Andre Johnson, then selecting his replacement in the draft with our 11th pick. Just didn't make any sense at all. Again, I think we've done a tremendous job of maneuvering ourselves into being a much better football team. Have you seen our defense yet? And we're not done. Anyway, I think the Chiefs and Saints have done well in selecting their LT's at the positions they were drafting. Two teams that IMO have done the best so far, outside of us of course!

What do you feel was a stretch or didn't really fit a team as a selection?

Well see my answer above I suppose. But to add to that since you asked... I think the Rams taking Chris Long, when they took Carriker last year is a bit puzzling. They should have taken a LT or DT. Maybe they are switching to a 3-4. The Vikings had perhaps the best run defense in the NFL, and they trade away an important piece, yet select his replacement in Glenn Dorsey. They leveraged themselves into replacing him with their top five selection. I'm sure they could have gone many different ways. Who is playing receiver for them? Again, this is the team that traded away AP originally....

Hopefully we can talk to you again when the eighteenth pick rolls around. Good luck on your next selection.

Look forward to it.
 
BRONCOS select OT JEFF OTAH, Pittsburgh

It was shocking to see Matt Lepsis retire this offseason, leaving a bit of a hole in the offensive line. The Denver Broncos had been pretty silent this offseason but they have several strengths like their receiving corp.

Meanwhile their defense struggled most of last season, and they couldn't find the pass rush they were looking for. However for the good of the team they selected Jeff Otah who is a great value at this pick, and has the most upside out of all the tackles in the draft.

Plus
- Great size and massive frame
- Good feet, very light on them
- Mobile
- Ability to recover after being beat
- Upside

Minus
- Raw, still learning
- Questionable work ethic
- Will get beat by quicker defensive ends
- Needs to better his conditioning

This was a pick the Broncos had to make. Jeff Otah is a mauler and tough tackle, but he is a project and would be best served learning behind an experience veteran until he is ready.

Defense could have used a pass rusher but they already spent a first rounder on Jarvis Moss last year. Not much more to say about this pick other than solid, with a lot of potential to be a dominating Left Tackle.

Selection Grade: A
 
PANTHERS select DE PHILLIP MERLING, Clemson

Phillip Merling could have gone in the top ten as the best pure Defensive end at the pro level. However just recently had surgery for a hernia.

This wasn't a pressing need for the Panthers as they already have Charles Johnson and Julius Pepper, but with Peppers out last year Johnson may have proved not to be good enough without a superstar on the otherside of him.

Plus
- Nasty demeanor
- Solid, reliable tackler with good technique
- Has good chase speed
- Variety of pass rushing moves
- Strong enough to take on multiple blockers
- Good awareness and instincts

Minus
- Not an elite athlete
- Timed speed is average
- Doesn't have the explosiveness like other DEs
- Labelled as a tweener

It was too early to reach for one of the other offensive tackles, which is a need with Travelle Wharton leaving via free agency. also Dan Connor isn't worth a pick this high, even if Dan Morgan is a concussion away from leaving football.

They should have really took a corner since their starters are Williams James and Samari Rolle, they had their pick of any of the top five cornerbacks, but instead draft a player who is worth a top ten pick but not really a need.

It's a good pick but I'm not really as excited as I should be. Most will agree Leodis McKelvin or Mike Jenkins would have fit the Panthers better at this selection.

Selection Grade: B+
 
Back
Top Bottom