Prisco Awards | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Prisco Awards

BAMAPHIN 22

FinHeaven Elite
Joined
Jul 30, 2004
Messages
19,666
Reaction score
47
Location
Huntsville, AL
MVP

1. Peyton Manning, QB, Indianapolis. I had to think long and hard about this one, but Manning wins in a photo finish over Chad Pennington. Both are deserving, but Manning had to overcome two knee surgeries, injuries to a raft of teammates and a brutal schedule to get where he is. And where he is on a nine-game roll and in the playoffs -- again. I know Miami wouldn't be where it is without Pennington, but Manning gets the edge because of everything he had to get through to make it this far.
2. Chad Pennington, QB, Miami.
3. Adrian Peterson, RB, Minnesota.

Coach of the Year

1. Mike Smith, Atlanta. How can you not like what happened in Atlanta? Smith was a virtual unknown who took over a wreck of a ballclub and reassembled it in a heartbeat. No Michael Vick? No problem. He had Matt Ryan and Michael Turner, and together they accomplished the improbable: They have the Falcons in the playoffs a year after they fell apart. Yeah, I know, this award could've gone to Tony Sparano, too, but because I don't believe in ties, I closed my eyes and picked. Congratulations, Mike. You drew the long straw.
2. Tony Sparano, Miami.
3. John Harbaugh, Baltimore.

Executive of the Year

1. Bill Parcells, executive vice president of football operations, Miami. While I don't believe in ties, I do believe in splitting the vote. So with Atlanta's Smith winning Coach of the Year, Parcells takes the Executive of the Year for raising the Titanic. A year ago, the Dolphins were 1-15 -- now, they're the AFC East champion. I don't care how they got there. They won it, and that's all that matters. Parcells reshuffled the roster, then had the good sense to sign Chad Pennington as his quarterback. Brilliant.
2. Tom Dimitroff, GM, Atlanta.
3. Marty Hurney, GM, Carolina.

http://www.sportsline.com/nfl/story/11212411
 
I was a bit upset with Mike Smith getting coach of the year. Tony Sparano better get the award or I'm going to be pissed.
 
Not THAT much love, Aqua. Picking anyone other than SPARANO as Coach Of The Year, and PENNINGTON as MVP, reeks of bias and/or gross stupidity. Someone should remind the idiots of the world that only MIAMI was 1-15 last sesaon. That way, both SPARANO and PENNINGTON's accomplishments can be put in their proper perspective.

As to PRISCO, he's just a "rehasher" now. He hasn't had an original thought about football in at least a decade. He "has newspapers to sell", and for him, THAT is "job one".

I have an award for PRISCO: "Putz Of The Year".
 
i rlly dont see where peyton manning had to overcome a brutal schedule, can someone help me out? he got to play the jags twice, lions,packers, vikings,bears,bengals, browns, chargers. those r 9 very winnable games in which they lost 3 of them, and they had to play balt who we also played, houston twice, we played them once, they had new england, we got them twice, and then they had tenn twice, one of them being the last game where they didnt have anyone playing,and pitt. overall i dont think they came close to a brutal schedule like prisco said, so if he wants to say peyton deserves mvp fine, but dnt say bc of a brutal schedule.
 
Yay, another thread where people are going to pile on a journalist for not picking all Miami candidates :/
 
I think we should be happy that a consistent Dolphin hater has the Phins in the top 2 for each of these major categories!

When our enemies are forced to bow their heads in defeat, we have won!
 
MVP
2. Chad Penninton

Comeback Player
2. Chad Penninton

Best Offseason Pickup
2. Chad Penninton

Chad Pennington - always the brides made, never the bride :lol:
 
All the Manning for MVP talk is silly. The guy has better talent around him than almost any other QB in the league.

Manning MVP is stupid talk, kinda like Favre in the pro bowl. Why are sports journalists so boring and predictable?
 
All the Manning for MVP talk is silly. The guy has better talent around him than almost any other QB in the league.

Manning MVP is stupid talk, kinda like Favre in the pro bowl. Why are sports journalists so boring and predictable?

Unlike Favre, Manning carried his team and battled adversity.
 
MVP
2. Chad Penninton

Comeback Player
2. Chad Penninton

Best Offseason Pickup
2. Chad Penninton

Chad Pennington - always the brides made, never the bride :lol:

he may have to pry it out of Michael Turner's hands...
 
Back
Top Bottom