QB -Best and Worst Case Scenerio

[HysterikiLL]

3 years ago, while were at it Brock Berlin was the number 1 rated High School prospect so maybe we should consider him also.

What exactly is your point?? The 12:1 TD: INT Ratio was a mere illustration. If he had, in contrast, a 1:12 ratio, your point would still be as valid.

His measurables are substantially better than Berlins. I think he has better vision -- AFL or no AFL, he took a step sideways rather than backwards and showed that he has an arm, he is accurate, he can move and spot players on the run, has good vision, great rythym and the ability to develop his mechanics to suit the environment he is playing in.

I like McPherson. If he slips to the 4th, I think he'd be of good value whilst through the looking glass, Greene, Orlovsky, Walter -- all projected around that area could be gone.

 

[DonShula84]

Aaron Rodgers
Best case-Tom Brady (Rodgers is a winner folks! This guy seem to know how
to win games)
Worst Case-Tommie Maddux (a guy that has a hard time picking up his team system early in his career/later on becomes a good starting Qb for 2 to 3 years.)

Alex Smith
Best case-Steven Mcnair ( a small college qb whose mobile in the pocket /feels good running a wide open offence /can run the ball but perfer to pass)
Worst case-Andre Ware (all hype very high draft choice /lack of competition in college /a system Qb in college)

Adrian McPherson
Best case -Aaron Brooks (in 2002-2003 season /a qb that can run as will as pass for lots of yards/great arm /mobile qb/as a 2nd or 3rd round draft choice will have a starting position in 2 years)
Worst case-Aaron Brooks (in 2004 season/a athlete Qb /that makes to many mistake as well as bad reads)


C.Fyre
Best case - Chad Penington ( a good completion % but needs talented around to be sucessful/if your team has a great Wideout,and a good rb and Ol Fyre can sucessed)
Worst case-Billy Volec (a career backup that can win you two to three games ,if your starter is injury but never win a start job in Training camp)


On a scale from 1 -10
Who will become a starting QB in within 2year ?AR/AS/CF

Who will become a solid Pro Qb in his carear?AR/AS/CF/Amc

who will become a pro bowl Qb?Aaron Rodger/Alex Smith

Who will become a carear back-up?

Who will become another bust?

looks like no matter who we pick we get a potential pro bowler or a really solid player :shakeno: Worst case scenario would be a complete bust!