Rank Them?? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Rank Them??

D

DolfanISS

Perennial All-Pro
Joined
Aug 5, 2002
Messages
19,140
Reaction score
9,359
Age
49
Location
Bellingham, MA
just want to see what the consensus is. Rank Cutler, Brock and Moore, who’s the best in the bunch and who’s the worst?

1
2
3
 
I think we need to see more from Brock to judge it...

but Cutler was washed up.... 3

Moore gave us good, and bad ..... 2

Brock will get my #1 for now because of the circumstances surrounding the win, and the game he played.
 
Geez it’s not like I want to sign any of them I just wanted to know who folks thought was the best. 2017 Cutler/Moore or Brock. We’ve seen all 3 win games just trying to gauge where folks see them. If it’s so irrelevant don’t reply.
 
Three very different QBs when they came to us I think. Cutler was done, had his odd moments but largely wasted $10 million. Moore was a career backup, did well in patches but never going to be the #1 guy, having him mentoring Tannehill probably had a big part in Tannehill lack of development, think he took some bad traits from Matt. Brock is only 27 and has been a starter before, had a horrible couple of years prior to joining us but the Texans obviously saw something in him to give him a huge wad of cash, there may be potential there, too early to say after one start.
 
As a Dolphin.
Moore
Oz
Cutler
And that's because Cutler was horrible.
 
DolfanISS said:
just want to see what the consensus is. Rank Cutler, Brock and Moore, who’s the best in the bunch and who’s the worst?

1
2
3
Click to expand...

Right now?

Brock... he just played very well , against a good opponent and won a game.

Moore and Cutler are washed up!
 
Yeah I agree on Cutler, he wasn’t good here at all. Obviously best career of the 3 but never a world beater. Moore was a relief warrior but not great as a starter. He had some good games over the years thats for sure. He may have the most 3+ TD pass games of all our QB’s in very limited action. Just because of familiarity I’d probably feel best if he was still here. If Brock can sustain the level he played at Sunday it will be him. I agree with what somebody else said. I don’t care if there are more INT’s as long as there are more points.

My guess is Tanny gives this a go at some point. We’ll see what happens.
 
Not sure if we're looking at entire career or just their time as a Fin but for me:
1. Moore
2. Osweiler
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.Cutler
 
Can we see more than ONE game from Brock before we start ranking him?

Thanks
 
I’m sorry I started this thread. I didn’t realize so many would not want to risk putting their football knowledge on the line by answering this question.

Maybe I should have just said who would you rather have Cutler Moore or Brock. Then it’s all opinion and it’s obviously Brock because we already know what the other 2 brought to the table in Miami and we hope Brock brings more.
 
1. moore he win some big game for us. help make playoff 2016
2. cutler at end of his career.
3. oz ????
 
I like Brock more as a backup than as a starter. I think Cutler would be #1 of those three, though. He might have actually been a pretty good quarterback in the right situation. Strange how he could be dominate one game and be terrible the next. He was nearly perfect in the win over NE last year. One of the oddest qb's ever because there was no denying his talent when he was on.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom