ranking #84 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

ranking #84

A

alan huber

Starter
Joined
Mar 11, 2006
Messages
406
Reaction score
1
Location
mexico city
how would you rank chambers with the other great recivers in hte league TODAY ,.

1-moss
2-holt
3-chad johnson
4-owens
5-smith
6-chambers :dolphins:
7-javon walker
8-santana moss
9-andre johnson
10-galloway
 
alan huber said:
how would you rank chambers with the other great recivers in hte league TODAY ,.

1-moss
2-holt
3-chad johnson
4-owens
5-smith
6-chambers :dolphins:
7-javon walker
8-santana moss
9-andre johnson
10-galloway
Click to expand...



you can´put other recivers , you dont have to work with this guys
 
Well, he is definately top 10 now in my eyes..
 
Where's Marvin Harrison? :lol:


I'd put it like this, right now:

1. T. Owens
2. S. Smith
3. C. Johnson
4. M. Harrison
5. T. Holt
6. R. Moss
7. S. Moss
8-11. (tie): C. Chambers/A. Boldin/L. Fitzgerald/H. Ward
12-15. (tie): J. Walker/D. Jackson/R. Wayne/J. Galloway

So, I'd say, at best, you could argue Chambers is #8, but for sure top 10-11.
 
randy moss
owens
johnson
harrison
smith
holt
ward
santana
boldin
fitzgerald
chambers
 
alan huber said:
how would you rank chambers with the other great recivers in hte league TODAY ,.

1-moss
2-holt
3-chad johnson
4-owens
5-smith
6-chambers :dolphins:
7-javon walker
8-santana moss
9-andre johnson
10-galloway
Click to expand...


Sorry Chambers cant crack the top 6 IMO....
these are pretty much the top 6 WRs. im sure others have a different #1 wr.
I think Chambers needs to have another season like last to be considered top 8
Top Tier
1. Steve Smith
2. Torry Holt
3. Marvin Harrison
4. Chad Johnson
5. Terrell Owens
6. Randy Moss

Next Group
Larry Fitzgerald
Chris Chambers
Anquan Boldin
Santana Moss
Plaxico Burress
Hines Ward
Reggie Wayne
Javon Walker
 
1. Terrel Owens (what he does on field unmatched)
2. Steve Smith (if had size of TO, then he would be the best)
3. Chad Johnson (A young TO)
4. Chris Chambers (Outstandin speed,Great leaping ability)
5. Torry Holt (consistent year after year)
6. Marvin Harrison (a down year last year, but still super)
7. Randy Moss (If the guy had any heart..he could rule NFL..but he doesn't)

quick list..I could have forgotten someone

Anquan boldin,fitzgerald..(not enough playing time yet)
 
vmarcilfan75 said:
Sorry Chambers cant crack the top 6 IMO....
these are pretty much the top 6 WRs. im sure others have a different #1 wr.
I think Chambers needs to have another season like last to be considered top 8
Top Tier
1. Steve Smith
2. Torry Holt
3. Marvin Harrison
4. Chad Johnson
5. Terrell Owens
6. Randy Moss

Next Group
Larry Fitzgerald
Chris Chambers
Anquan Boldin
Santana Moss
Plaxico Burress
Hines Ward
Reggie Wayne
Javon Walker
Click to expand...




plaxic ,, im not sure his top 20!!
 
Tbone13tx said:
1. Terrel Owens (what he does on field unmatched)
2. Steve Smith (if had size of TO, then he would be the best)
3. Chad Johnson (A young TO)
4. Chris Chambers (Outstandin speed,Great leaping ability)
5. Torry Holt (consistent year after year)
6. Marvin Harrison (a down year last year, but still super)
7. Randy Moss (If the guy had any heart..he could rule NFL..but he doesn't)

quick list..I could have forgotten someone

Anquan boldin,fitzgerald..(not enough playing time yet)
Click to expand...

Your nuts if you dont put Boldin up there yet.. he is unreal... and Hines Ward has to be a top 7 guy.... 4th is a bit homerish for chambers... there is so many talented recievers
 
vmarcilfan75 said:
Sorry Chambers cant crack the top 6 IMO....
these are pretty much the top 6 WRs. im sure others have a different #1 wr.
I think Chambers needs to have another season like last to be considered top 8
Top Tier
1. Steve Smith
2. Torry Holt
3. Marvin Harrison
4. Chad Johnson
5. Terrell Owens
6. Randy Moss

Next Group
Larry Fitzgerald
Chris Chambers
Anquan Boldin
Santana Moss
Plaxico Burress
Hines Ward
Reggie Wayne
Javon Walker
Click to expand...

I agree with your top group, but the 2nd group there I've got ranked completely differently.

There was an interesting article I read this week on #84. I coudn't find it now.

It compared most of the top WR's statistically, and even with his breakout year he still didn't catch over 60% of the balls thrown his way.

Hines does, that was the guy's standard for defining TRUE top tier WR's, catching at least 60% of the balls thrown their way...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom