Real Problem With The Offense | Page 3 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Real Problem With The Offense

Does Gase make mistakes in play calls? Absolutely....

But his starting QB has missed 23 games over his tenure here. He has had the unfortunate pleasure of having Matt Moore, Jay Culter, and Brock O as QBs for those 23 games.
the problem is that adam gase has final say over the 53 man roster. so the unfortunate pleasures are of his own accord.
 
Gase is 100% responsible for marginalizing the offense’s more dynamic or explosive players. We have one big-bodied WR on the team, and Gase chooses to scratch him when he’s healthy. And then our smurf WRs get jammed and abused right out of the game.

We have a RB who can break the big one at any point and is a solid threat on the passing game. Yet Gase prefers the plodding 35-year old. And today, he preferred the rookie in the wildcat.

It’s like he prefers to call plays with one hand tied behind his back.

And it’s not like these are the only examples. This guy preferred Arian Foster, for chrissakes.

I mean, c’mon, 20 carries for 53 yards from Frank Gore??
 
Does Gase make mistakes in play calls? Absolutely....

But his starting QB has missed 23 games over his tenure here. He has had the unfortunate pleasure of having Matt Moore, Jay Culter, and Brock O as QBs for those 23 games. He is 10-13 in those games. Go check most franchises record with their starting QB goes down. It aint good. With an average as can be QB in Ryan Tannehill he is 11-7.

Gase calls his games based on many things, his opponent, his personnel, etc.

You see, when you have a patchwork offensive line, a QB that can't throw past 5 yards, a defense playing well at home against a rookie QB, you call the game exactly the way he did. Extremely safe, don't make mistakes, and hope one of those short passes someone makes a play. He is not perfect by any means, but for anyone to destroy Gase for calling nothing but 5 yard passes with what we have right now, needs to brush up on their football knowledge.


Then what justifies Gase decision to entrust his offense to a guy who can not hit a man more than 5 yards downfield? What is Brock Whatwheiler doing in Miami? After Gase losing his Starting QB a season and a half coming into 2018, what part of Gase brain thought it smart to even end up with a turd like BO to begin with?

The oline is another story, but same wrongful thinking. Decisions made in April-May matter in October-December.

Your "knowledge" in no way, in year 3, can explain away Gase results at this point. If your honest.
 
the problem is that adam gase has final say over the 53 man roster. so the unfortunate pleasures are of his own accord.
Show me the teams that could lose their starting QB, pro bowl guard, center, and two of their top 3 wideouts, and their pro bowl caliber LT and RT during the game and still be efficient offensively. No one, regardless of how good they are at evaluating talent, is going to have the proper depth for that.
 
Show me the teams that could lose their starting QB, pro bowl guard, center, and two of their top 3 wideouts, and their pro bowl caliber LT and RT during the game and still be efficient offensively. No one, regardless of how good they are at evaluating talent, is going to have the proper depth for that.

of course. and if ryan tannehill started today and the result were the same, those would be the excuses.
 
Then what justifies Gase decision to entrust his offense to a guy who can not hit a man more than 5 yards downfield? What is Brock Whatwheiler doing in Miami? After Gase losing his Starting QB a season and a half coming into 2018, what part of Gase brain thought it smart to even end up with a turd like BO to begin with?

The oline is another story, but same wrongful thinking. Decisions made in April-May matter in October-December.

Your "knowledge" in no way, in year 3, can explain away Gase results at this point. If your honest.
What back up QB would you have brought in? The idea that there are a bunch of good back ups is completely false. There are 15-18 good NFL QBs in the entire world. The rest aren't good. To find a back up that can play at a decent level is insanely insanely hard.
 
Gase might be part of the problem but he's not the only problem. Brock has done ok for a back up QB but he's part of the problem too. We're getting nothing from Gesicki and O'Leary's having to stay in to block cause our O-line is not very good. We have more than just one problem.
 
Did anyone complaining actually watch the game? Holding stalls drive, offensive PI stalls drive, drake missed block on 3rd and short sack stalls drive, 3-1 Swiss cheese OLine gets no push Gore stopped for a loss stalls drive, Oswilder overthrows Amendola for a sure TD stalls drive, oswilder misses DVP wide open for a first and throws behind him stalls drive. I mean I used to complain about Gase and the horizontal offense a lot and snear at those comments he said where one guy misses an assignment or another guy doesn’t do what he is supposed to but I’ve been watching very closely and the fact of the matter is 8-10 times Gase calls the right play, the players on the other hand don’t execute the play and take negatives, plays, penalty’s or simply miss assignments for negative plays or sacks. The bad O is on the players and Gase needs to get a better OLine and Tannahill back quick.
Gase handpicked these players to run his offense. If they can’t execute then yes it’s his fault. Get better at identifying players than can run your offense.
 
What back up QB would you have brought in? The idea that there are a bunch of good back ups is completely false. There are 15-18 good NFL QBs in the entire world. The rest aren't good. To find a back up that can play at a decent level is insanely insanely hard.


I'd rather have had a QB with a better arm and had to learn on the go as opposed to Brock who "knows" the offense but can't execute about 75% of it.

This offense should be running the ball 40 times a game, no exaggeration, split between the three backs. This offense is that bad and the defense is worse.
 
Gase handpicked these players to run his offense. If they can’t execute then yes it’s his fault. Get better at identifying players than can run your offense.
"his guys" are all hurt. The problem is adjusting to what you have, he isn't doing it.
 
We are talking about depth and final say of roster being the problem, and you run out a Ryan Tannehill reference? got it...i assume you admitted you were wrong with that response.

you listed ryan as a gase excuse as if he's a difference maker.
 
Then what justifies Gase decision to entrust his offense to a guy who can not hit a man more than 5 yards downfield? What is Brock Whatwheiler doing in Miami? After Gase losing his Starting QB a season and a half coming into 2018, what part of Gase brain thought it smart to even end up with a turd like BO to begin with?

The oline is another story, but same wrongful thinking. Decisions made in April-May matter in October-December.

Your "knowledge" in no way, in year 3, can explain away Gase results at this point. If your honest.
For real, no one forced Gase to go out and get Cutler. What was he thinking when he got Osweiler? That he’d never have to use him?
 
Back
Top Bottom