Rookie of the Year | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Rookie of the Year

Phin_Phan

Phin_Phan

Practice Squad
Joined
Feb 2, 2005
Messages
722
Reaction score
0
Age
38
Location
Windsor, Ontario
Who do all you guys think will be the rookie of the year this year?? I think Carnell would have been 100% if he wasnt injured a bit this year, and I actually think he still will win it.....Ronnie also is have a good year, but I dont think he'll win it. I also like what Kyle Orton is doing in Chicago.....I know he doesnt have great numbers, but he's finding ways to win games, I also dont think he'll win it, but what do you think.
 
Well, statistically Ronnie should win it. He has about 100 yards more in rushing then Carnell, and they have the EXACT same amount of carries(152). Also, Ronnie has 155 yards receiving and Carnell only has 49. Finally, they both have three touchdowns. Currently I give the edge to Ronnie, afterall he does have much better stats.

His competition for the Offensive ROTY award would be both Orton and Heath Miller. Orton isn't really putting on that great of a show, and other then Miller's six touchdowns, he only has 248 yards receiving.

Ronnie should get it.
 
If Caddy continues to play the way he is...i think he will win it. He got the hype in the beginning after setting the records for most yds in the first 4 games or whatever....

Ronnie Brown could win if he didnt lose carries to Ricky...

If Orton continues to win with the Bears...find it hard not to give it to him either....
 
Caddy will win even though it should go to Ronnie
 
Either Ronnie or Odell Thurman I tought caddy was going to win it but hes beensiconsistent as of late. so I say Ronnie or Odell
 
Nublar7 said:
His competition for the Offensive ROTY award would be both Orton and Heath Miller. Orton isn't really putting on that great of a show, and other then Miller's six touchdowns, he only has 248 yards receiving.

Ronnie should get it.
Click to expand...
Is Heath Miller even a candidate. Sure he has scored a few touchdowns but he is not a real offensive focal point who can blow a game open like the others. I really dont think he should be in the running
 
fin4life35 said:
Either Ronnie or Odell Thurman I tought caddy was going to win it but hes beensiconsistent as of late. so I say Ronnie or Odell
Click to expand...

i think there's offensive and defensive rookies of the year, so they could both win! :D
 
I think if Tampa wins the division Caddy will win the award. If Chicago has 10 or more wins Kyle Orton will be second in line if Caddy does not get it. If Odell Thurman plays the same way he has throughout the year it will be a tight race between him and Ronnie if Tampa and Chicago can not complete what I stated earlier in the post.
 
PassRush said:
Is Heath Miller even a candidate. Sure he has scored a few touchdowns but he is not a real offensive focal point who can blow a game open like the others. I really dont think he should be in the running
Click to expand...
I agree that Heath isn't a focal point, but those six touchdowns are hard to ignore.
 
Phin_Phan said:
Who do all you guys think will be the rookie of the year this year?? I think Carnell would have been 100% if he wasnt injured a bit this year, and I actually think he still will win it.....Ronnie also is have a good year, but I dont think he'll win it. I also like what Kyle Orton is doing in Chicago.....I know he doesnt have great numbers, but he's finding ways to win games, I also dont think he'll win it, but what do you think.
Click to expand...

I think Ronnie has a good shout, considering the poor season the Fins are having. Personally I would vote for Orton though
 
You girls and your homer glasses.

Mod Edit: Take your trolling and personal attacks elsewhere.
 
If Ronnie gains over 1000 yards and continues to carry it at 4.8 yards per carry, I think he'll win it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom