Same Spots - who would you have taken?

[Finsup1981]

I wanted Walker so badly but had to take into account the players already on the roster

Walker would start and make Tyrel Dodson slide into his more natural role, passing down sub specialist. Walker would be a 3 down player, taking Dodsons spot on first and 2nd down then sliding to rush the passer/fake the blitz drop in coverage while Dodson falls back into his speciality role of pass defensive coverage specialist

 

[Padfoot]

That's a draft. Might have gone DT or another CB at 116 but that's filling up the score card with talent

Unfortunately I think pass rusher will be a need soon enough. One more season ending injury for either Phillips or Chubb and that's pretty much all she wrote for both of them.

 

[AMakados10]

13. Jihaad Campbell
48. Benjamin Morrison
98. Ty Robinson
116. Jack Sawyer
135. Joshua Farmer
150. Marcus Mbow
155. Miles Frazier
224. Quinn Ewers
231. No clue
253. No clue

Interesting draft philosophy… defense would be thumping!

 

[djphinfan]

Jihad Campbell first and foremost.

Cj west would of been my add to the starting def tackle next to sieler, didnt look at Ersery's tape.

savion williams with the third.

I was just all about finding players that willl be here for the future not just to fill needs.

 

[JamesWsenior]

Jihad Campbell first and foremost.

Cj west would of been my add to the starting def tackle next to sieler, didnt look at Ersery's tape.

savion williams with the third.

I was just all about finding players that willl be here for the future not just to fill needs.

So our top 3 picks won't be here for the future?

 

[dolfan91]

Its been 2 weeks since the draft. And some information about both Trader and Marshall has become available, that gives some insight as to how they became Dolphins.

Trader appears to have a huge fan in Anthony Weaver. It was Weaver who appearently pushed for miami to draft him. Trader seems to have expectations running high, with many in the organization thinking he could be an early contributor.

As for Marshall. The shrine bowl practices seem to have been a deciding factor in Miami's draft decisions. Four of the players drafted, which includes Marshall were participants in the practices and game. He appears to have been on their radar since. Marshall is said to have had an excellent practice week.

In addition to the four players drafted from the shrine bowl, several of Miami's UDFA signees were also present and caught the organization's attention.

 

[stillhardcore]

13) DT Walter Nolen, because I think we drafted too many NT, I’d prefer a penetrating 3-tech and and think Nolen has the highest ceiling…I think Grant can play 3 tech but I’d prefer him at 1 tech to eat up more blockers

37) OG Savaiinaea, last remaining great guard out of the top 7

143) NT Jordan Philips cause we need a true nose and he’s the best of the remaining ones

150) OG Marcus Mbow much better quality depth than Eich/Borom with starter potential

155) CB Zah Frazier, think he has all the tools to be a starting CB and i just like him more than Marshall as a prospect

179) RB Ollie Gordon, think he’s fantastic value and had he come out a year ago he would’ve went late 1st/early 2nd

231) QB Quinn Ewers, again fantastic value see above with Gordon

253) TE Jaylin conyers, I thought he would get drafted for sure and wouldn’t want to risk him as a UDFA which we got lucky with

I like your draft as much as the actual, but I do like the Trader pick in the 5th. Hard tossup, but it can be argued easily Mbow was a bigger position of need. I wanted Nolen too, but I think Grant will be quite serviceable.

 

[SF Dolphin Fan]

Agreed.

Personally the only reason I would have taken Grant over Harmon was because of the medical concern.

But it was like 1A or 1b. I would be happy with either. But it will be interesting to watch their careers

I think as the draft go closer, many of us figured it was down to the four top rated DT'S. That Harmon had an undisclosed injury and there were apparently character concerns with Nolen, might have factored in.

Although, I think Grant is a great fit.

 

[SF Dolphin Fan]

Unfortunately I think pass rusher will be a need soon enough. One more season ending injury for either Phillips or Chubb and that's pretty much all she wrote for both of them.

What to do with Phillips and Chubb will be a decision soon enough. If they both rebound and have big years, do you pay both, one of the two, or neither?

Factoring their injuries, it would have to be a team friendly deal. I think there's a good chance both will be gone. Meaning pass rush could be a huge need in 2026.

 

[allsilverdreams]

What to do with Phillips and Chubb will be a decision soon enough. If they both rebound and have big years, do you pay both, one of the two, or neither?

Factoring their injuries, it would have to be a team friendly deal. I think there's a good chance both will be gone. Meaning pass rush could be a huge need in 2026.

Noooooo .Not this again.

 

[Finsup1981]

PFF 2007 draft redo, interesting to see the variance of rounds these guys are found, also Joe Staley would’ve been incredible and would’ve allowed us to draft Matt Ryan in 2008 since we’d already have a LT and wouldn’t need Jake Long…wonder how that would’ve turned out.

1. OAKLAND RAIDERS: WR CALVIN JOHNSON, GEORGIA TECH (ROUND 1, PICK 2)

Original pick: QB JaMarcus Russell, LSU
The Raiders’ original selection, quarterback JaMarcus Russell, went down as arguably the biggest bust in NFL draft history. He started just 25 games during his three years in the league, with a career 43.5 PFF overall grade.

Adding insult to injury is the fact that the following two players selected, Calvin Johnson and Joe Thomas, were both first-ballot Hall of Famers. The former goes first in this redraft and was one of the most dominant players in the NFL throughout his nine-year career. He earned a 93.0 PFF overall grade and was named a first-team All-Pro three times. Megatron’s 1,964 receiving yards in 2012 still stands as the single-season NFL record.

2. DETROIT LIONS: T JOE THOMAS, WISCONSIN (ROUND 1, PICK 3)

Original pick: WR Calvin Johnson, Georgia Tech
Detroit did well originally to draft Hall-of-Fame wide receiver Calvin Johnson, but they are forced to secure a different inductee in this scenario.

Left tackle Joe Thomas was a first-team All-Pro in six of his 11 NFL seasons. He finished his career with a 95.9 PFF pass-blocking grade while never earning a sub-81.7 mark in that department in a season. He was also an ironman, playing an NFL-record 10,363 career snaps.

3. CLEVELAND BROWNS: CB DARRELLE REVIS, PITTSBURGH (ROUND 1, PICK 14)

Original pick: T Joe Thomas, Wisconsin
The Browns originally went with Joe Thomas, who ended up becoming a franchise legend and future Hall of Famer. He is already off the board, so Cleveland adds another Hall of Famer in Darrelle Revis.

He became one of the best cornerbacks of his generation, with four first-team All-Pro nods and seven Pro Bowls while earning a PFF coverage grade above 80.0 in seven consecutive seasons from 2008 to 2014.

Darrelle Revis' Career PFF Grades


Subscribe to PFF+ to unlock the world's most advanced football database!
4. TAMPA BAY BUCCANEERS: RB ADRIAN PETERSON, OKLAHOMA (ROUND 1, PICK 7)

Original pick: EDGE Gaines Adams, Clemson
The Buccaneers had a young star running back at the time in Cadillac Williams, but he suffered torn patellar tendons in 2007 and 2008 that derailed his career. With the benefit of hindsight and a top-10 running back of all time available in Peterson, Tampa Bay hands this card in.

Peterson was a four-time first-team All-Pro with the Vikings and took home the MVP award in 2012, the last non-quarterback to receive the honor. He earned a 92.7 career PFF rushing grade and ranks in the top five all time in rushing yards (14,918) and rushing touchdowns (120).

5. ARIZONA CARDINALS: G MARSHAL YANDA, IOWA (ROUND 3, PICK 86)

Original pick: T Levi Brown, Penn State
The Cardinals tried to find reinforcements on the right side of their offensive line by selecting Levi Brown, but Marshal Yanda enjoyed a longer and better career.

Playing mostly right guard, but also a significant amount of right tackle, Yanda never earned a PFF overall grade below 80.0 in any of his 13 seasons. He was a crucial part of Baltimore’s Super Bowl 47 run, not allowing a sack in any of the 18 games he played that season.

6. WASHINGTON: LB PATRICK WILLIS, OLE MISS (ROUND 1, PICK 11)

Original pick: S LaRon Landry, LSU
Although original selection LaRon Landry had a solid career overall, it was not that of future Hall of Famer Patrick Willis.

Willis played only eight years in the NFL but earned a PFF overall grade above 87.0 in all but his final campaign — incredible consistency and dominance not often seen at any position. He earned five first-team All-Pro nods and made seven Pro Bowls.

7. MINNESOTA VIKINGS: S ERIC WEDDLE, UTAH (ROUND 2, PICK 37)

Original pick: RB Adrian Peterson, Oklahoma
Without Peterson on the board, the Vikings could draft another perennial Pro Bowl running back in Marshawn Lynch. However, Minnesota instead adds to a safety unit in need of talented youth.

Weddle finished his career as the most valuable player from the 2007 draft class, according to PFF’s Wins Above Replacement metric, and his 94.7 career PFF overall grade is the top mark among safeties since PFF began grading in 2006.

8. ATLANTA FALCONS: RB MARSHAWN LYNCH, CALIFORNIA (ROUND 1, PICK 12)

Original pick: EDGE Jamaal Anderson, Arkansas
With Warrick Dunn entering his age-32 season in 2007, Atlanta needed a workhorse to replace him. Marshawn Lynch was the very definition of that. He rumbled his way to five Pro Bowl appearances and six 1,000-yard rushing seasons.

His performance peaked in Seattle, where he posted a 90.6 PFF rushing grade in both 2013 and 2014. He broke 214 tackles across those two seasons as the Seahawks made two consecutive Super Bowl appearances.

9. MIAMI DOLPHINS: T JOE STALEY, CENTRAL MICHIGAN (ROUND 1, PICK 28)

Original pick: WR Ted Ginn Jr., Ohio State
The Dolphins took a chance on electric return man Ted Ginn Jr. at this spot back in 2007, but we’ll prioritize consistency over flashiness in this redraft.

Staley played 13 years in the NFL, with three second-team All-Pro honors and six Pro Bowls. He logged more than 11,000 career snaps and never recorded a single-season PFF overall grade below 70.0. He graded above 80.0 in nine of his 13 seasons. The stalwart tackle didn't allow more than five sacks in any of his final seven campaigns and finished his career with a 5.5% pressure rate allowed.

10. HOUSTON TEXANS: S REGGIE NELSON, FLORIDA (ROUND 1, PICK 21)

Original pick: DI Amobi Okoye, Louisville
The Texans landed a couple of defensive cornerstones, edge defender Mario Williams and linebacker DeMeco Ryans (now their head coach), in the 2006 NFL Draft. But Houston still fielded the league’s third-lowest-graded group of safeties across the 2007 and 2008 seasons.

Nelson might not be a potential Hall of Famer like the nine players picked above him in this redraft, but he made two Pro Bowls with a solid 75.6 career PFF overall grade.

11. SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS: LB PAUL POSLUSZNY, PENN STATE (ROUND 2, PICK 34)

Original pick: LB Patrick Willis, Ole Miss
Posluszny was nearly a first-rounder in 2007 and becomes one here with the linebacker-needy 49ers on the clock. He spent four solid seasons in Buffalo before heading to Jacksonville, where he turned in a career-high 90.1 PFF overall grade in 2011.

The Penn State product was an all-around playmaker and one of the best tacklers in the NFL. He earned at least a 90.0 PFF tackling grade in every season from 2008 to 2012, ranking among the top seven linebackers each year.

12. BUFFALO BILLS: C RYAN KALIL, USC (ROUND 2, PICK 59)

Original pick: RB Marshawn Lynch, California
Lynch was a good pick at No. 12, both in Buffalo and beyond. But with Lynch off the board, the Bills target the top interior offensive linemen from the 2007 class.

Center Ryan Kalil was a two-time first-team All-Pro and a one-time second-team All-Pro. He also made five Pro Bowls. From 2008 to 2016, his PFF pass-blocking grade never dipped below 76.0 in the seasons when he played most of the year (healthy).

13. ST. LOUIS RAMS: TE GREG OLSEN, MIAMI (FL) (ROUND 1, PICK 31)

Original pick: DI Adam Carriker, Nebraska
From 2007 to 2009, Rams tight ends earned the second-worst PFF receiving grade in the league. Olsen would solve that issue, as his 8,683 career receiving yards are the seventh most all time among tight ends. He is also the fifth-most-valuable tight end, per PFF’s Wins Above Replacement metric, trailing only Travis Kelce, Jason Witten, Rob Gronkowski and Antonio Gates.

14. CAROLINA PANTHERS: EDGE LAMARR WOODLEY, MICHIGAN (ROUND 2, PICK 46)

Original pick: CB Darrelle Revis, Pittsburgh
The Jets originally traded up to No. 14 in the draft to select Hall of Fame cornerback Darrelle Revis. Woodley was a very productive pass rusher during his seven seasons in Pittsburgh, earning an elite 90.2 PFF pass-rush grade while racking up nearly 300 pressures and 68 sacks.

He also showed up when it mattered most, posting an 89.6 PFF overall grade in his postseason career, which included recording multiple sacks in each of the Steelers’ three games en route to their Super Bowl 43 victory.

15. PITTSBURGH STEELERS: G BEN GRUBBS, AUBURN (ROUND 1, PICK 29)

Original pick: LB Lawrence Timmons, Florida State
Grubbs didn’t have a flashy career, but he did make the Pro Bowl twice (2011 and 2013) and logged six seasons in which he played more than 1,000 snaps as a starter. His PFF grades were also very solid throughout his career.

The Auburn product earned a single-season PFF overall grade above 75.0 for five straight seasons with two different teams (Ravens and Saints) from 2009 to 2013. He could have stabilized Pittsburgh's interior offensive line with Alan Faneca playing his last year with the Steelers in 2007.

16. GREEN BAY PACKERS: DI BRANDON MEBANE, CALIFORNIA (ROUND 3, PICK 85)

Original pick: DI Justin Harrell, Tennessee
Harrell didn't pan out for the Packers, playing just 14 games across three seasons. Green Bay instead opts for another defensive tackle in this do-over.

Mebane was a starter for 13 seasons in the NFL and was at his best in 2013 with the Seahawks, placing third among interior defenders with an 88.8 PFF overall grade.

 

[Finsup1981]

17. JACKSONVILLE JAGUARS: EDGE CHARLES JOHNSON, GEORGIA (ROUND 3, PICK 83)

Original pick: EDGE Jarvis Moss, Florida
The Broncos originally moved up four spots on draft night to select edge defender Jarvis Moss. Johnson didn’t get to play much in his rookie season, but he went on to become one of the NFL’s better pass rushers over the next decade.

From 2008 to 2016, Johnson earned an elite 90.2 PFF pass-rush grade. He was a crucial part of the defensive turnaround in Carolina at the time. Though the Panthers lost Super Bowl 50, Johnson earned a 90.2 PFF pass-rush grade and produced a sack against Peyton Manning’s Denver Broncos.

18. CINCINNATI BENGALS: CB LEON HALL, MICHIGAN (ROUND 1, PICK 18)

Original pick: CB Leon Hall, Michigan
Hall enjoyed a solid NFL career — one worthy of a reselection here. He was a second-team All-Pro in 2009 after earning an elite 90.1 PFF coverage grade, grabbing six interceptions and allowing just three touchdowns all year. He also forced 15 incompletions that season. From 2007 to 2015, Hall earned a 91.0 PFF coverage grade.

19. TENNESSEE TITANS: WR DWAYNE BOWE, LSU (ROUND 1, PICK 23)

Original pick: S Michael Griffin, Texas
Griffin was certainly a worthy pick, making two Pro Bowls across his 10-year career. However, the Titans had already invested the No. 3 overall pick in quarterback Vince Young the year before and didn’t surround him with any weapons. From 2006-2010, Tennessee failed to have a receiver even hit 800 yards in a season.

It’s unknown whether Bowe would’ve saved Young from becoming a bust, but he’ll at least give the Titans a legitimate No. 1 option after earning an 87.4 career PFF overall grade across nine seasons.

20. NEW YORK GIANTS: LB LAWRENCE TIMMONS, FLORIDA STATE (ROUND 1, PICK 15)

Original pick: CB Aaron Ross, Texas
The Giants' defensive line and cornerback group were excellent in 2007, and linebacker was their weakest position at the time. Former Steeler Lawrence Timmons would’ve been a nice option to fix that.

Timmons didn’t play much in his rookie season, but from 2008 to 2012, he earned an elite 90.1 PFF overall grade that ranked fourth among qualified linebackers — behind Patrick Willis, Ray Lewis and NaVorro Bowman.

21. DENVER BRONCOS: T JERMON BUSHROD, TOWSON (ROUND 4, PICK 125)

Original pick: S Reggie Nelson, Florida
In the actual 2007 draft, the Jaguars moved down four spots and selected safety Reggie Nelson here. Bushrod outplayed his fourth-round draft slot in his 12-year career, but it took him a bit to get going.

The Towson alumnus didn't make a true impact until an injury to Jammal Brown in 2009 put him in the starting lineup at left tackle, where he was Drew Brees’ blindside protector in the Saints' Super Bowl season. He went on to make two Pro Bowls (2011 and 2012) and didn’t record a single-season PFF overall grade below 70.0 for six straight years from 2010 to 2015.

22. DALLAS COWBOYS: EDGE ANTHONY SPENCER, PURDUE (ROUND 1, PICK 26)

Original pick: QB Brady Quinn, Notre Dame
The Cowboys originally traded this pick to the Browns, who gave up the No. 36 pick and a 2008 first-round pick to select quarterback Brady Quinn. Four picks later, Dallas selected Spencer, whom they acquire again here.

Spencer was consistently one of the more underrated edge defenders in the NFL throughout his eight-year career with the Cowboys. In 2009, he was the most valuable edge in the league, according to PFF’s Wins Above Replacement metric. And during his lone Pro Bowl season in 2012, he finished second in PFF WAR.

23. KANSAS CITY CHIEFS: T DOUG FREE, NORTHERN ILLINOIS (ROUND 4, PICK 122)

Original pick: WR Dwayne Bowe, LSU
Former fourth-round pick Doug Free became a solid player for the Cowboys, starting multiple seasons at left tackle and right tackle. His best work came in 2010, when he led the NFL with a 91.4 PFF run-blocking grade. Free went on to start for the Cowboys through the 2016 season before retiring due to injuries.

24. NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS: RB AHMAD BRADSHAW, MARSHALL (ROUND 7, PICK 250)

Original pick: S Brandon Meriweather, Miami (FL)
Bradshaw was a seventh-round pick in the 2007 NFL Draft and well outplayed that draft slot. He was a two-time Super Bowl champion with the Giants in his nine-year career, and although he topped 1,000 rushing yards in two seasons, he was known for his third-down duties in pass protection and as a pass catcher.

From 2010 to 2014, Bradshaw earned a PFF overall grade above 74.0 in all but one season (missed significant time due to a neck injury).

25. NEW YORK JETS: LB DAVID HARRIS, MICHIGAN (ROUND 2, PICK 47)

Original pick: LB Jon Beason, Miami (FL)
Since we reversed draft day trades, the Jets stick here at No. 25 and miss out on drafting cornerback Darrelle Revis. Instead, New York obtains another one of its long-term starters on defense.

Harris was one of the Jets’ starting linebackers for a decade and was named a second-team All-Pro in 2009 after placing ninth among all linebackers with an 83.7 PFF coverage grade.

26. PHILADELPHIA EAGLES: EDGE BRIAN ROBISON, TEXAS (ROUND 4, PICK 102)

Original pick: EDGE Anthony Spencer, Purdue
Robison was a solid pass rusher who racked up more than 500 quarterback pressures across 11 seasons in Minnesota. While he was never an elite player, he did earn a solid 81.2 PFF pass-rush grade from 2008 to 2012. Meanwhile, the Eagles were coming off a season in which they ranked 17th in PFF pass-rush grade.

27. NEW ORLEANS SAINTS: LB JON BEASON, MIAMI (FL) (ROUND 1, PICK 25)

Original pick: WR Robert Meachem, Tennessee
Beason was originally the No. 25 pick in this draft, and if it weren't for an Achilles injury after his fourth season, he likely would’ve been selected much earlier. He recorded more than 100 tackles in each of his four seasons as Carolina’s middle linebacker, with one first-team All-Pro, one second-team All-Pro and three Pro Bowls.

Beason earned PFF run-defense grades of 75.0 or greater in his first three seasons, but he wasn't the same after his Achilles injury in 2011. Even that short stint of strong play makes this pick worth it for the Saints during their Super Bowl run.

28. NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS: S LARON LANDRY, LSU (ROUND 1, PICK 6)

Original pick: T Joe Staley, Central Michigan
The 49ers originally traded a fourth-round pick and a 2008 first-round pick to move up for Joe Staley, who was a top-10 selection in this redraft. The Patriots, who originally selected a safety at No. 24 in Brandon Meriweather, go with another one here in Landry.

Landry was one of the 10 most valuable safeties in the NFL in each of his first two seasons, per PFF’s Wins Above Replacement metric, and he ranked fourth in 2008 with an 85.2 PFF coverage grade.

29. BALTIMORE RAVENS: G JUSTIN BLALOCK, TEXAS (ROUND 2, PICK 39)

Original pick: G Ben Grubbs, Auburn
The Ravens were fishing for interior offensive line help in this draft, hence the original selection of Ben Grubbs. Former Falcon Justin Blalock is the best option available. After a tough rookie season, Blalock went on to earn PFF grades between 66.0 and 78.0 in each of the next seven seasons. He allowed three sacks or fewer in six of those campaigns.

30. SAN DIEGO CHARGERS: S MICHAEL GRIFFIN, TEXAS (ROUND 1, PICK 19)

Original pick: WR Craig Davis, LSU
Griffin endured a very up-and-down career, but to his credit, he stuck around for 10 years. In his second season, he played more than 1,000 snaps and earned a 74.7 PFF overall grade, only to follow it up with another 1,000-snap season but a 32.6 grade.

Still, he made two Pro Bowls and earned second-team All-Pro honors. His highs warrant a back-end Round 1 selection in this redraft.

31. CHICAGO BEARS: TE BRENT CELEK, CINCINNATI (ROUND 5, PICK 162)

Original pick: TE Greg Olsen, Miami (FL)
Celek might not have had a potential Hall-of-Fame career like Olsen, but he was still one of the better tight ends in the NFL during his 11 years with the Philadelphia Eagles. In 2009, his 968 receiving yards were the fourth most among tight ends and he finished the year as the sixth-most-valuable player at the position, according to PFF’s Wins Above Replacement metric.

32. INDIANAPOLIS COLTS: WR JAMES JONES, SAN JOSE STATE (ROUND 3, PICK 78)

Original pick: WR Anthony Gonzalez, Ohio State
Fresh off a Super Bowl victory over the Bears, the Colts were getting ready for their future at wide receiver with Marvin Harrison entering the twilight of his career. Anthony Gonzalez’s career was cut short due to injury. Instead, we’ll go with James Jones, who was a reliable option for Aaron Rodgers and the Packers in eight of his nine NFL seasons. He led all players in receiving touchdowns in 2012 and posted a career high in receiving yards in his final season in 2015.

 

[derek]

I loved our draft, because it often aligned with what I would have liked to do. That said, I'm susceptible to devaluing players at positions that I don't perceive as needs, and overrating big guys with athleticism, so we'll see how this turns out in a few years.

015. Kenneth Grant. We nailed that one, IMHO.
048. Shavon Revel. Love Jonah for our system, but I would have kept our picks and drafted Revel (obviously without knowing the extent of his medical flags at the time)
097. Charles Grant. He's not Jonah, but I was comfortable waiting for OL.
116. Elic Ayomanor. Gunnar Helm would have been a great fit too, but I do think we won the trade down FWIW.
135. Jordan Phillips. I always wanted them to double down in the trenches, and was a big fan of several DTs. I might have gone Ty Hamilton had we skipped Grant, for sooner impact.
150. Jackson Slater. Anything that puts Eich's roster spot in peril is great.
155. Ollie Gordon. I thought I was alone in like him for the Dolphins, despite not being an obvious fit.
224. Hunter Wohler. I didn't see this dude waiting around until round 7.
231. Quinn Ewers. Hard to argue with the value at that stage.
253. Zy Alexander. Loved getting Conyers as a UDFA, but after drafting Helm, I would have circled back to DB there.

Honourable mentions: Tyler Batty and Jared Ivey.