Seth McKinney | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Seth McKinney

Silverphin

Silverphin

Chairman of the 'Owned! Awards' Commitee
Joined
Jul 4, 2005
Messages
6,420
Reaction score
0
Age
36
Location
Lauderdale Lakes, FL
Say what you want, but he did damn good this season. Is there anybody who would like him to stay? Seriously... I would understand if he constantly got owned by D-Linemen. But he held his own.
 
Silverphin said:
Say what you want, but he did damn good this season. Is there anybody who would like him to stay? Seriously... I would understand if he constantly got owned by D-Linemen. But he held his own.
Click to expand...


Most improved lineman this year for sure. I won't be disappointed if he stays or if he goes.
 
He is a free agent this year. Yes i have to say that he did a good job at the center position, but I like Hadnot there a lot more. I believe we would be looking for a road grader rg in free agency and keep Hadnot at center. If he wants to come back as a back up..sure McKinney would be ok.
 
He's still below average in my opinion. Hadnot played better, and he's not even our full time starter when McKinney is healthy....

I say dump McKinney, and keep Hadnot at C....

PHINZ RULE!!!!
 
Sign LeCharles Bentley.

Of course, he'll probably get franchised.
 
I think if McKinney is willing to return at a backup/situational type role, Saban brings him back. He offers a stable backup solution at C, and possibly a challeng for Hadnot to earn the starting C position.
 
He is the sort of player Charley Casserley in Houston gives a 5 year 25 million dollar contract to (think Wade, Greenwood). I think Seth will want to hit the market to see if he can get such an offer. Whilst Seth had a much better year, I dont see us offering him a contract anywhere near what he might get from an OL starved team on the open market.

The Texans might be his choice spot actually, he is from there and I think his brother is already on the team (they could slide Steve to guard and have them play next to each other).
 
I think we need a big upgrade to the center position, Seth had an OK season,but OK won't cut it at this level!! I won't even notice if he leaves. I know this is to give props to Seth, but I would rather give my props to other players. Like Chris Chambers, Travis Daniels, Y.Bell...and so on. If you want to know what kind of impact Seth had on the fins and the league try to trade him and see what interest he draws. My guess, 0 interest.
 
we could also draft a center - mangold, eslinger, degory may all be there in the second or third. i see mangold going in the first round in a lot of mock drafts i've seen, eslinger in the second, degory and ryan cook in the third. does anyone have a good feel for any of these guys?
 
Eslinger had the best college career, but may not be big enough to fit our system. I like him a lot though.

Mangold has a ton of upside and teams like his tenacity.

Degory has improved his technique a lot the last few years. He has the size we want in our OL, I don't see him there in the second though.
 
I'd keep him for vet minimum pay as a backup. Don't see him as being a starter even on an O'line challenged team.
 
BLITZKRIEG said:
He's still below average in my opinion. Hadnot played better, and he's not even our full time starter when McKinney is healthy....

I say dump McKinney, and keep Hadnot at C....

PHINZ RULE!!!!
Click to expand...

Yes I like this move. It is good that McKinney did well this season but we want our O-line to be consistant and dominate and McKinney can not reach that level IMO.
 
I wouldnt mind having him back, but nothing more than a backup at C and both guard positions.
 
Silverphin said:
Say what you want, but he did damn good this season. Is there anybody who would like him to stay? Seriously... I would understand if he constantly got owned by D-Linemen. But he held his own.
Click to expand...

I'd like to see him as a solid backup, but would like to upgrade the position in the offseason.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom