SI Grades on Miami’s 2025 Draft Picks | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

SI Grades on Miami’s 2025 Draft Picks

C grade is not neutral. C grade means met expectations.
Media in Miami is an embarrassment.
There is no neutral when you are grading. There is F for failed, D for below expectations, C for met expectations, B for exceeded expectations, and A for far exceeded expectations.

1767806136387.png
 
FINFANFOREVER1972 said:
I would not call it solid...I would call it mediocre...which is the type of team we have now
Click to expand...
less than mediocre. need to weight the grades by draft position. for example, jordan phillips is a B+ because he was a good result for a 5th rounder. if they took him with the first pick, probably a C grade, give or take if you follow my point. jonah should actually be an F - -, considering we traded up for him and gave up a much needed draft pick too. we missed on warren and grey zabel. anyway the total grade should be biased towards the results of the first two picks. it is nice that we got players out of the later picks, but they all project to be average, and not difference makers, and are mostly at lower value positions. wildcard is ewers, if we were to hit on a real QB down there, then heck, dumb luck, but that would make the draft A+. high value position. but as things stand now, i average it all out on a weighted basis, D+ draft. less than mediocre. i do not care about picking up rotational non difference makers late in the draft at low value positions. this is subject to change, but this is how it looks as of now to me. grier could not be fired fast enough.
 
MARINO1384 said:
Was a solid draft just not the home run Miami needed.
Click to expand...
Right. Picking at 13, Miami had a chance for an elite player. Grant wasn't necessarily a disappointment, and finished strong. But again the Dolphins missed on a difference maker. Warren in this case.

Overall, some nice complementary pieces mostly. Phillips was a real find, and maybe Ewers proves to be better than a backup?
 
SF Dolphin Fan said:
Right. Picking at 13, Miami had a chance for an elite player. Grant wasn't necessarily a disappointment, and finished strong. But again the Dolphins missed on a difference maker. Warren in this case.

Overall, some nice complementary pieces mostly. Phillips was a real find, and maybe Ewers proves to be better than a backup?
Click to expand...

Did they though? Greg dulcich outperformed Tyler Warren since he appeared in his first game in Miami in the last 9 games of the season. I know Jones went down but he started to trail off before the injury as teams saw more tape and learned how to stop him. His team also lost 7 straight so not sure how that classifies as “difference maker”.

Class isn’t looking that great, haven’t followed everyone but just looking up some of the guys taken after Grant and nobody stands out although haven’t followed too much.

Personally I thought for sure it was going to be Jalon Walker when he fell but even he only finished with 5.5 sacks though his off grade pretty solid.

Overall though draft looks pretty meh compared to how it was touted, only first year but haven’t for what was said to be a very rich class overall it seems a little underwhelming this far
 
LargoFin said:
C grade is not neutral. C grade means met expectations.
Media in Miami is an embarrassment.
There is no neutral when you are grading. There is F for failed, D for below expectations, C for met expectations, B for exceeded expectations, and A for far exceeded expectations.

View attachment 200869
Click to expand...
"C grade means met expectations" = In LOSER organization/schools/etc = Miami Dolphins regime
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom