Skeptic's view of Roster... | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Skeptic's view of Roster...

L

Lee2000

FinHeaven VIP
Joined
May 1, 2002
Messages
2,790
Reaction score
25
Age
61
The Skeptic's view of the roster as follows...
1. Berlin is signed to the practice squad; Feeley remains #2.
2. Ricky Williams will be a Dolphin all year.
3. Maurice Mann and Josh Davis will be signed to the practice squad.
4. Zgonina will make the team over Josh Shaw.
5. Edwards and Howard will be on the roster at cb, with no other major additions.
6. Miami will get no trade value for anyone on the roster at present.
7. Dolphin interior offensive line will struggle all season, regardless of recent additions (ie. Middleton)
8. Travis Daniels will get a rude introduction to the league.
9. Donald Lee will make the final roster.
10. Moore will make the final roster at lb.

With all that said, I am not a skeptic and I expect some of these statements to be proven wrong.

Lee2000

Lee2000
 
I agree to all but 3. I think Mann will make the final roster over Derrius Thompson (cut). I also think Bryan Gilmore will be sent to the practice squad.
 
I have watched special teams quite a bit and Gilmore will make the roster

HysterikiLL said:
I agree to all but 3. I think Mann will make the final roster over Derrius Thompson (cut). I also think Bryan Gilmore will be sent to the practice squad.
Click to expand...

Gilmore has shown he will be a reliable receiver and most of all, a competent special teamer. That is why he will make the roster. I do not think he is eligible for the practice squad.

Lee2000
 
i think gilmore will be the 4th receiver behind chambers, booker and boston...
 
Lee2000 said:
The Skeptic's view of the roster as follows...
1. Berlin is signed to the practice squad; Feeley remains #2.
2. Ricky Williams will be a Dolphin all year.
3. Maurice Mann and Josh Davis will be signed to the practice squad.
4. Zgonina will make the team over Josh Shaw.
5. Edwards and Howard will be on the roster at cb, with no other major additions.
6. Miami will get no trade value for anyone on the roster at present.
7. Dolphin interior offensive line will struggle all season, regardless of recent additions (ie. Middleton)
8. Travis Daniels will get a rude introduction to the league.
9. Donald Lee will make the final roster.
10. Moore will make the final roster at lb.

With all that said, I am not a skeptic and I expect some of these statements to be proven wrong.

Lee2000

Lee2000
Click to expand...


You are not a skeptic or anti-skeptic...you just like to stir things up...I think you are a masked Jills fan....
 
Lee2000 said:
The Skeptic's view of the roster as follows...
1. Berlin is signed to the practice squad; Feeley remains #2.
2. Ricky Williams will be a Dolphin all year.
3. Maurice Mann and Josh Davis will be signed to the practice squad.
4. Zgonina will make the team over Josh Shaw.
5. Edwards and Howard will be on the roster at cb, with no other major additions.
6. Miami will get no trade value for anyone on the roster at present.
7. Dolphin interior offensive line will struggle all season, regardless of recent additions (ie. Middleton)
8. Travis Daniels will get a rude introduction to the league.
9. Donald Lee will make the final roster.
10. Moore will make the final roster at lb.

With all that said, I am not a skeptic and I expect some of these statements to be proven wrong.

Lee2000

Lee2000
Click to expand...

1. Agree.
2. Agree
3. Mann makes the team, Thompson gets cut or traded (Philly?) Davis maybe makes practice squad.
4. Shaw and Zgonina make the team. You think they cut Shaw, you're insane.
5. :shakeno:
6. Maybe. I dont have a crystal ball.
7. I've seen improvement. Where have you been? I disagree.
8. What rookie doesn't go through growing pains? I think he'll give just as good as he receives.
9. Not so sure. He's talented but just needs to get his head out of his arse. Diamond is ahead of him right now.
10. :roflmao:
 
With the Shaw/Zgonia statement, I must remind you that Zgonia is 35 yrs old while Shaw is 25 yrs old and that could figure into the equation!
 
Lee2000 said:
The Skeptic's view of the roster as follows...
1. Berlin is signed to the practice squad; Feeley remains #2.
2. Ricky Williams will be a Dolphin all year.
3. Maurice Mann and Josh Davis will be signed to the practice squad.
4. Zgonina will make the team over Josh Shaw.
5. Edwards and Howard will be on the roster at cb, with no other major additions.
6. Miami will get no trade value for anyone on the roster at present.
7. Dolphin interior offensive line will struggle all season, regardless of recent additions (ie. Middleton)
8. Travis Daniels will get a rude introduction to the league.
9. Donald Lee will make the final roster.
10. Moore will make the final roster at lb.
Click to expand...
1. agree
2. agree
3. agree
4. maybe.. Shaw is bigger and Saban is more familiar with him.
5. agree.
6. agree(ish), we could get something for lamar gordon.
7. disagree.. james, hadnot and middleton are big enough to survive.
8. agree.. most rookies do.
9. maybe.. diamond has impressed.
10. agree.
 
So the title to the thread is you're a skeptic, yet you point out at the end that you aren't one. Hmmmmm :eek:
 
Lee2000 said:
The Skeptic's view of the roster as follows...
1. Berlin is signed to the practice squad; Feeley remains #2.
2. Ricky Williams will be a Dolphin all year.
3. Maurice Mann and Josh Davis will be signed to the practice squad.
4. Zgonina will make the team over Josh Shaw.
5. Edwards and Howard will be on the roster at cb, with no other major additions.
6. Miami will get no trade value for anyone on the roster at present.
7. Dolphin interior offensive line will struggle all season, regardless of recent additions (ie. Middleton)
8. Travis Daniels will get a rude introduction to the league.
9. Donald Lee will make the final roster.
10. Moore will make the final roster at lb.

With all that said, I am not a skeptic and I expect some of these statements to be proven wrong.

Lee2000

Lee2000
Click to expand...

1. Agree.
2. Agree.
3. Agree. I think Gilmore is on the roster behind Chambers, Boston, and Booker and ahead of Welker. Could possibly keep six WRs by keeping Welker as special teamer and Thompson as 4th or 5th WR.
4. I'm not so sure. Shaw has been pretty good in the preseason IMO. I would not be suprised at all to see Zgonina cut in favor of Shaw (or some other DL).
5. Sad, but I agree. Right now they're the best alternatives IMO. Maybe we can pick up a roster cut player that can compete or is better than they are.
6. I'm not so sure on this one either. I think Thomspon and Gordon have some trade value, albeit not great value.
7. Somewhat agree. I think we'll be better than last year, but there will be times that we struggle.
8. Somewhat disagree. I think he have a learning curve. But, I think he will show some real nice play and may surprise people.
9. I sure hope not. Diamond has shown much more than Lee has. Although, Lee is more of a blocker than Diamond, and Diamond is more of an H-Back.
10. I like Moore, but it's very hard to judge how he will play in this defense since he has yet to get on the field.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom