J.D. Walton, Zack Bowman and Spencer Paysinger combined to start 22 games for the New York Giants last season. Now, all three are fighting simply to make the Dolphins roster, as are punter Brandon Fields and more than a half dozen other fairly prominent veterans.
With 2 ½ weeks before the roster must be sliced to 53, here’s what we’re hearing on Dolphins veterans at risk:
### Of those three Giants signed in free agency, Paysinger has the best chance to make the team at the moment, with the situation obviously fluid based on preseason performance. There’s some strong sentiment to keep him because of his experience (14 starts in four seasons for the Giants), special teams acumen and Miami’s relative inexperience at linebacker.
Bowman, we’re told, is very much on the bubble. Keeping him likely would mean keeping seven corners, because the front office sees considerable upside in Tony Lippett, Bobby McCain and Will Davis. Bowman, who started five games for the Giants last season, helped his chances by grading out well internally against Chicago.
Both Paysinger and Bowman would earn $745,000 if they stick --- palatable numbers for Miami.
Walton, who started every game at center for the Giants last season, trails Sam Brenner in the battle for the backup center job. At $510,000, Brenner is slightly cheaper than Walton ($750,000).
### Most teams prefer to keep four defensive tackles, though Miami hasn’t made a final decision on that. In that four-tackle scenario, C.J. Mosley and Anthony Johnson would be competing for one spot.
Mosley has been working with Jordan Phillips on the second team, having leapfrogged Johnson, who fell to the third team and then committed three neutral zone infractions against Chicago. But if Johnson outplays Mosley over the next three weeks, Johnson could stick. Johnson, at 22, is 10 years younger than Mosley and cheaper ($510,000 to $970,000).
### The Dolphins view Tennessee rookie Matt Darr as an NFL-quality punter and he has a legitimate shot to beat out Brandon Fields, who fell to 11th in average and 25th in net average last season.
Whereas Darr would make $435,000 this season, Fields – even after taking a pay cut a few months ago --- would earn $1.6 million this year and $3.5 million next (with a $4.3 million 2016 cap hit). Darr averaged 44.3 yards on three punts in the Bears game; Fields averaged 37.3, with a shorter field, but unlike Darr placed all three of his punts inside the Bears’ 20. “I expect [to win the job] because I will earn it,” Fields said Monday.
### Kicker Caleb Sturgis remains the front-runner over strong-legged, unpolished rookie Andrew Franks but is expected to have a short leash if he struggles early in the season. And if Sturgis falters the next three weeks, Miami will consider waiver options.
“The last two years haven’t been good enough,” he said. “I need to be a bigger contributor to this team.”
### Elsewhere: Though there is thought to keeping four running backs instead of three, the Dolphins aren’t sure. Damien Williams and Jay Ajayi are essentially automatic behind Lamar Miller. LaMike James must play a lot better than Thursday to make a case to stick and Mike Gillislee is a long shot…
One among veteran receivers LaRon Byrd, Cobi Hamilton, Matt Hazel and Michael Preston could stick initially only if concerns about DeVante Parker’s health compel Miami to start the season with six receivers instead of five. If Miami keeps five, it’s almost impossible to see any of those aforementioned four making it.
Jeff Linkenbach has the edge over Jacques McClendon for what could be the ninth and final offensive line job, but that’s fluid based on preseason performance….. Josh Freeman and McLeod Bethel Thompson assuredly will be cut before Sept. 7… Resourceful Jordan Kovacs, who has played in 17 games for Miami, remains an underdog; he must clearly outplay rookie Cedric Thompson to have a chance to win the fifth safety job if Miami even keeps five.
CHATTER
### Jordan Phillips’ penetration against Chicago was encouraging, and he seems to have corrected his college shortcoming of taking plays off. “There were too many people saying I was lazy, so I said I’ve got to fix it,” he said.
### Two Dolphins players cut in the past three days were claimed by other AFC East teams: tight end Arthur Lynch by the Jets and offensive tackle Chris Martin by the Patriots.
Marcus Thigpen told me that two Patriots assistants coaches asked him for information on the Dolphins last September after Miami cut him and New England claimed him.