State Your Case: Bob Kuechenberg | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

State Your Case: Bob Kuechenberg

Wildbill3

Onion Fetish
Club Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2001
Messages
29,517
Reaction score
3,128
Age
46
Location
Kentucky
[h=1]State Your Case: Bob Kuechenberg[/h]

Photo courtesy of Miami Dolphins
Talk of Fame Network
by Ron Borges
A guy who spent his career opening up holes for others now needs someone to open one up for him. Truth be told, Bob Kuechenberg not only needs it, he deserves it.
You can’t talk to anyone who played on or against the Miami Dolphins of the 1970s who won’t tell you Kuechenberg wasn’t the best offensive lineman on a team that won two Super Bowls, went to three and became the only undefeated team in the modern history of the NFL when Miami went 17-0 in 1972. Yet his old offensive linemates Larry Little and Jim Langer are both in the Hall. So is Bob Griese, the quarterback Kuechenberg protected as if he was his son; Larry Csonka, the fullback he bowled people over for; and Paul Warfield, the wide receiver who got into the Hall in part because Kuechenberg was so adept at keeping Griese upright. They’re in while Kuechenberg has remained out in the snow for 31 years.
One explanation why he was an eight-time finalist but never made it through the door in Canton seems to be that he simply played too long. Langer and Little both retired several years before Kuechenberg, who lasted 14 seasons before hanging it up after starting 15 games in 1983 and making his final Pro Bowl at age 36. Because of that, they became Hall of Fame eligible before he did and were both inducted, meaning if Kuechenberg were added 60% of that Dolphins’ line would be enshrined.
It is the same problem Jerry Kramer and L.C. Greenwood of the Packers’ and Steelers’ dynasties have long faced without gaining induction despite considerable support. It’s not that anyone says there’s a limit to how many enshrines are allowed from any team but it feels, at least in Kuechenberg’s case, that he kept hitting a glass ceiling, a victim, perhaps, of a numbers crunch.
A six-time Pro Bowl performer (one more than LIttle and the same number as Langer), Kuechenberg came to the Dolphins in 1970 by a circuitous route. Drafted in 1969 by the Philadelphia Eagles, who finished 2-12 the previous season, Kuechenberg quit shortly after training camp began but came back only to be cut several weeks later. He was then signed and cut in a week by the Atlanta Falcons before agreeing to play semi-pro ball for the Chicago Owls of the Continental Football League that fall.
Kuechenberg often has said that 1969 season “was for the birds. The Eagles, Falcons and Owls.”
Don Shula signed him the following year and he started five games at left guard for the Dolphins that 1970 season before becoming a full-time starter the following year. The only time he would relinquish that position for the next 13 years was when he was shifted to left tackle in 1978. Kuechenberg made the Pro Bowl that season too, and despite being undersized at 6-2, 253 pounds, remained at left tackle in 1979 before moving back inside and making two more Pro Bowls (1982-83) at left guard before retiring. According to Dolphins’ game books, he was called for holding only 15 times in 196 NFL games. That may not be a record but it’s a sure sign of his dominance.
Asked about who he would give a free pass into the Hall of Fame to if he had the power, Hall of Fame coach Don Shula told Talk of Fame Network, “That’s an easy one for me. I had a guard by the name of Bob Kuechenberg, Kooch was just a great football player. He blocked some pretty good tackles that we played against and did a good job but he’s never gotten that final recognition, which is that Hall of Fame jacket. Some day, I hope I’m around to see him accept.”
Shula, who has more victories than any coach in NFL history, also once said “Bob Kuechenberg did more to help my team win than any player I ever coached.” Considering he coached Johnny Unitas, Dan Marino and Griese that’s saying a mouthful.
A mouthful is often what you got playing against Kuechenberg. He was a hard-nosed, physical player whose approach to the game was best reflected by the fact to play in Super Bowl VIII he had a 10-inch metal rod inserted in his broken forearm. That day he pummeled Vikings’ Hall of Fame defensive end Alan Page with it, the cast around his arm in tatters by the time the game was over. Miami won.
His former offensive line coach that day, Monte Clark, once said of Kuechenberg: “There’s not a tougher guy in America. You have to kill him to beat him. He played in the Super Bowl the year we went 17-0 with a cast on a broken arm. After the game, (the cast) was like pulp because he beat Alan Page in the head with it so many times. Kooch was a great short-yardage blocker. He could take a guy who was about two inches off the ground, get down, dig him out and put him on his back. He was very tenacious. Tough. Great competitor. Never made mistakes.”
Outspoken and some might say grumpy, Kuechenberg has always spoken his mind. When his final year of eligibility as a modern day candidate ended without induction in 2009 he said, “Now you get thrown in the swamp.”
He was referring to the HOF Senior Committee, from where his former teammate Nick Buoniconti emerged in 2001 to win enshrinement. That is now the only opening left for the 67-year-old Kuechenberg and it’s a hole someone else will have to clear out for him.
 
Toughness, longevity, could play any OL position well, and was more technically sound than either Little or Langer.
 
Ask Csonka, Little and Langer whether Kooch should be with them in the Hall of Fame.
 
It's never going to happen. There are offensive lineman from Kooch's era with more impressive credentials that haven't gotten in. Kooch made first-team All Pro once (the AP team is the definitive All-Pro squad.) Leon Gray who played for the Pats and Oilers (but was drafted by the Dolphins) was first-team All-Pro 3 times. Marvin Powell was first-team All-Pro 3 times. George Kunz was first-team All-Pro once, but made more Pro Bowl appearances than Kooch. Dennis Harrah (a University of Miami product) has the exact same credentials as Kooch in terms of All-Pro and Pro Bowl appearances and none of them are in the Hall of Fame and aren't likely to get in. Mick Tingelhof was first-team All-Pro 5 times on those old Vikings teams, not in. Now you could argue that there were so many great offensive linemen in the AFC in the seventies and early-eighties that you must take into account how that might have limited the individual honors Kooch would have earned otherwise.

Guys like Joe DeLamielleure, Larry Little, John Hannah, Jim Langer, Art Shell, Gene Upshaw and Mike Webster were perennial fixtures on the AFC Pro Bowl team, as were the aforementioned Leon Gray, Marvin Powell and George Kunz, there were only so many Pro Bowl and All Pro slots to go around, but the fact is that all of those guys had more than Kooch and some of them like Leon Gray were more talented, but played in obscurity, at least until he was traded to the Luv Ya Blue Oilers. The Hall of Fame is some times maddening. It took Dwight Stephenson many more years than it should have to get into the HoF when he's arguably the greatest player ever at center. Robert Brazile, L.T. before L.T., a guy who made the All-Decade team of the 1970s still isn't in the Hall of Fame. How does a guy voted one of the greatest players of a decade not get into the HoF when lesser talents who played in the same years like Harry Carson, who never made the AP All-Pro team, are in the Hall of Fame?
 
Too tough
Too durable
Too athletic
Too dedicated
Too skilled
Too versatile
Too effective
To be kept out of the Hall of Fame.
 
Love Kooch to death and was a fascinating player for many years. Met him in Miami many years ago long after he retired. He had white hair by then but had 3 beautiful blondes hanging on him. Great guy. I just don't ever see him getting in. Wish it were not true..
 
Yes he absolutely should be....if you are not old enough to remember his play you can't judge.

Leon Gray?...How many Superbowls did he help his team get too? That part of Zach's problem...his teams never accomplished anything of significance.

How many other players were Pro Bowlers at both guard & tackle like Kuech?
 
He should in the HOF. Should be. In that, he's in the same situation as dozens of other deserving players and coaches.

For instance—and this is a much greater injustice because of the influence he had on the game as a whole—Don Coryell is NOT in the HOF.

Don.

****ing.

Coryell.

I'd bet that most of you didn't know that.

Kooch had his years of straight eligibility, and due to whatever negative forces outweighed the clear and obvious positives—resentment of the '72 perfect squad, carried-over resentment by old-school writers whose lives were made hell by Shula's teams over the years, resentment of Shula himself for being graced with coaching Johnny Unitas, Bob Griese and Dan Marino...and who knows what else—he didn't make it in.

The old-schoolers die out, but the young bucks who replace them never saw Kooch play, and he's not even an afterthought to them. No, if Kooch is to make it in he'll have to die close to the vote, which will bring his name (and career) to the forefront. Otherwise, he'll keep getting passed over in favor of other old-timers who have been passed over themselves, but played more visible positions or on more visible teams.

You think if Joe Namath had played for Minnesota, big win or no big win, his career was a tepid mess outside that championship game, and he never sniffs the hall except by paying at the door, like everybody else. And I'm not saying that because he was a Jet and I'm a Dolphins fan.

Another thing: no one likes a bitter old ****. He recently put his politics ahead of a historic team honor, and **** him for doing it. His political beliefs do not supersede anyone else's, and he should have pushed his old Head Coach's wheelchair onto that stage and bent down and whispered, "This is for you, Coach." He should have humbled himself in the presence of the one person in whose presence ALL Americans are expected to humble themselves, and said, "Thank you, Mister President."

He didn't. People do remember that ****.
 
He should in the HOF. Should be. In that, he's in the same situation as dozens of other deserving players and coaches.

For instance—and this is a much greater injustice because of the influence he had on the game as a whole—Don Coryell is NOT in the HOF.

Don.

****ing.

Coryell.

I'd bet that most of you didn't know that.

Kooch had his years of straight eligibility, and due to whatever negative forces outweighed the clear and obvious positives—resentment of the '72 perfect squad, carried-over resentment by old-school writers whose lives were made hell by Shula's teams over the years, resentment of Shula himself for being graced with coaching Johnny Unitas, Bob Griese and Dan Marino...and who knows what else—he didn't make it in.

The old-schoolers die out, but the young bucks who replace them never saw Kooch play, and he's not even an afterthought to them. No, if Kooch is to make it in he'll have to die close to the vote, which will bring his name (and career) to the forefront. Otherwise, he'll keep getting passed over in favor of other old-timers who have been passed over themselves, but played more visible positions or on more visible teams.

You think if Joe Namath had played for Minnesota, big win or no big win, his career was a tepid mess outside that championship game, and he never sniffs the hall except by paying at the door, like everybody else. And I'm not saying that because he was a Jet and I'm a Dolphins fan.

Another thing: no one likes a bitter old ****. He recently put his politics ahead of a historic team honor, and **** him for doing it. His political beliefs do not supersede anyone else's, and he should have pushed his old Head Coach's wheelchair onto that stage and bent down and whispered, "This is for you, Coach." He should have humbled himself in the presence of the one person in whose presence ALL Americans are expected to humble themselves, and said, "Thank you, Mister President."

He didn't. People do remember that ****.


Not in his personality, which is what made him the player he was.
 
Back
Top Bottom