As I said elsewhere, what makes the 49ers tick right now is…McCaffrey and Kittle.
Look at recent 49ers drafts. They had more success with late-round picks than early-round picks (sounds very familiar to a Dolphins fan).
2021 - Trey Lance, Trey Sermon in the first three rounds.
2022 - Drake Jackson, Tyrion Davis-Price in the first three rounds.
2023 - Ji’Ayir Brown, Jake Moody, Cameron Latu in the third round.
2024 - Ricky Pearsall, Renardo Green, Dominick Puni in the first three rounds. Decent, but not earth-shattering.
2025 - Mykel Williams, Alfred Collins, Nick Martin in the first three rounds. Ehhh.
All told, that’s not a ton of production from 5 seasons of early-round picks. Forget the Trey Lance trade and bust? Nah, why forget that? That’s an all-time miss that doesn’t get discussed because Purdy arrived as Mr. Irrelevant.
Does that sum up my view well enough for you? Their offensive line is currently in shambles. They blew the Aiyuk deal. They’ve plugged in some decent backups to keep the defense afloat, but the defense isn’t necessary playing well currently. Etc, etc.