The Dolphins went 4-6 against teams that were 8-8 or better in 2008. Skolnick has the team going 4-9 against teams whose 2008 records were 8-8 or better...QED, Ethan thinks the Dolphins have gotten worse.
It is mildly disturbing that the Dolphins only play three teams that had a losing record in 2008. I think those three games will end up wins because I do not think either of the two teams has gotten significantly better (and may have in fact gotten worse). If 2008 is any indication (Dolphins were very good at putting away bad teams), they should be successful in beating bad teams.
In addition, I see the Bucs regressing to a losing team, providing a fourth win. I see the Jets regressing to a losing team, providing a fifth and perhaps a sixth win although I hate predicting a sweep of the Jets when the Dolphins hardly ever sweep the Jets. So I've got 6 losing opponents providing for roughly 5 or perhaps 6 wins. Remember, the Dolphins did not lose to a single sub-.500 opponent in 2008. So going 5-1 against these opponents that I personally believe will be sub-.500, would actually be worse than 2008.
What if you take the Week 17 game aside and figure in a W because the Steelers will in all likelihood be playing their backups by Week 17? I see that as a likelihood, but not an absolute...so what I would want to do with it is stick that game in with the 6 losing opponents and figure that between the 7 opponents, my expected value is 6 wins.
Then you have 9 teams that should be 8-8 or better. If the Dolphins were 4-6 against those teams in 2008, and they've gotten better, should they not go at least 5-4 against those teams? That would give the Dolphins an 11-5 record.
An 11-5 record, built on the following suppositions:
1. The Bills will continue to be a losing team. They were 2-8 in their last 10 games of 2008, they totally destroyed their offensive line, and Terrell Owens can't help them at his age.
2. The Jaguars will continue to be a losing team. Torry Holt can't help at his age and they've got a revamped OL that will take time to come on, a revamped WRs unit, a QB under heavy fire, inconsistent LBs and a coach openly feuding with the best player on the team John Henderson.
3. The Jets will regress to being a losing team. They finished 2008 with a whimper, and they're trying to go with a rookie QB throwing to only one valid WR.
4. The Bucs will regress to being a losing team. Loss of Monty Kiffin, loss of Gruden's offensive schemes, penny pinching front office and undertalented lines on both sides, this could be a horror story by year's end.
5. There is a strong possibility the Steelers have their playoff standing wrapped up by Week 17. If so, they will not risk their starters in a meaningless road game. Miami is good at beating teams they should, and finishing the year strong, so they should beat the Steelers' backups if that is who they play.
6. The other 9 opponents will have a handful of 8-8/9-7/10-6 type teams...they won't all be 12-4 or 13-3 type teams. Teams like the Chargers, Saints, Texans, Colts, Falcons...they could all hover around or just over the .500 mark, IMO.
7. The Dolphins have actually improved and are a better team than in 2008.
If you believe those 7 things, then I think you believe in a 10-6 or 11-5 record. I say this because the Dolphins went 4-6 against teams 8-8 or better in 2008, and went 7-0 against losing teams. I could see the team going 6-1 against "easier" opponents this year, even if they're still better than a year ago, because the "easy" opponents of 2009 should be a little harder than the "easy" opponents of 2008. But they would have to go 5-4 against the 9 non-losers if they want to be considered better than a year ago, IMO. If they do, you've got 11-5. If they go 4-5, you've got 10-6.
I'm going with 10-6 for now...
at Atlanta - W
Indianapolis - L
at San Diego - L
Buffalo - W
New York Jets - W
New Orleans - W
at New York Jets - L
at New England - W
Tampa Bay - W
at Carolina - L
at Buffalo - W
New England - L
at Jacksonville - W
at Tennessee - L
Houston - W
Pittsburgh - W
Total Record: 10-6