This Marshall presser on NFLN is must see

[Locke]

so really since one of the possible causes is impaired brain chemistry. Brain abnormalities would classify as a mental illness or am I missing something. Also if Im not mistaken arent medications quite commonly prescribed for the depression aspects of it . I know people diagnosed with BPD and I know that various meds have been prescribed such as citalopram and venlaxfaxine. I believe the last one was for anxiety

People with Borderline often also have a corresponding Axis I diagnosis, usually Major Depressive Disorder or Bipolar Disorder. If they are on any medication, it would be for the Axis I that usually accompanies their Borderline, not the Borderline itself. There are quite a few cases of people being diagnosed with only Borderline and not an Axis I to go with it. It is much more rare for a male to be diagnosed Bipolar than it is to have no Axis I diagnosis to go with the Axis II personality disorder, so it wouldn't surprise me.

No one knows what causes Personality Disorders. Brain chemistry is all-encompassing and is like saying that dude broke his leg because something bad happened to him. It is not an Axis I because they have not been able to find an organic reason for it, so your "brain chemistry" claim is completely without merit. More than likely, the personality disorders come from some environmental cues during the client's upbringing, usually how they were raised by the parents. I'm not saying anything like that is the case with Marshall. No one would know that outside of his psychologist. Just throwing out a few examples...

 

[dlockz]

People with Borderline often also have a corresponding Axis I diagnosis, usually Major Depressive Disorder or Bipolar Disorder. If they are on any medication, it would be for the Axis I that usually accompanies their Borderline, not the Borderline itself. There are quite a few cases of people being diagnosed with only Borderline and not an Axis I to go with it. It is much more rare for a male to be diagnosed Bipolar than it is to have no Axis I diagnosis to go with the Axis II personality disorder, so it wouldn't surprise me.

No one knows what causes Personality Disorders. Brain chemistry is all-encompassing and is like saying that dude broke his leg because something bad happened to him. It is not an Axis I because they have not been able to find an organic reason for it, so your "brain chemistry" claim is completely without merit. More than likely, the personality disorders come from some environmental cues during the client's upbringing, usually how they were raised by the parents. I'm not saying anything like that is the case with Marshall. No one would know that outside of his psychologist. Just throwing out a few examples...

well the verbage brain chemistry wasnt my choice of words its actually from a an article by a person in the profession and like I said u cant say its not a mental illness totally because as u said we dont fully understand what causes it. Wouldnt u agree

 

[Locke]

well the verbage brain chemistry wasnt my choice of words its actually from a an article by a person in the profession and like I said u cant say its not a mental illness totally because as u said we dont fully understand what causes it. Wouldnt u agree

An illness is defined as an abnormality within the body, whether that be through injury or invasion by bacteria/virus. What we do know is that personality disorders are not organic. That means it is not related to any physical or physiological issues with the brain. Per the definition of illness, it cannot be considered one. That's why it is not considered an Axis I disorder and that is why those of us in the field don't consider it a mental illness. It is a personality disorder only. That could change in a few years if someone is able to actually locate an organic cause of these personality disorders. Until then, it is an Axis II condition and nothing more...

 

[dlockz]

An illness is defined as an abnormality within the body, whether that be through injury or invasion by bacteria/virus. What we do know is that personality disorders are not organic. That means it is not related to any physical or physiological issues with the brain. Per the definition of illness, it cannot be considered one. That's why it is not considered an Axis I disorder and that is why those of us in the field don't consider it a mental illness. It is a personality disorder only. That could change in a few years if someone is able to actually locate an organic cause of these personality disorders. Until then, it is an Axis II condition and nothing more...

Well as u said it cannot be proven that its not a cause but i can live with your explanation. Like i said this was not my verbage but some from in the profession. The sad fact of the military is we deal with alot of people with disorders daily caused by a very dangerous job esp in my field.

 

[Locke]

Well as u said it cannot be proven that its not a cause but i can live with your explanation. Like i said this was not my verbage but some from in the profession. The sad fact of the military is we deal with alot of people with disorders daily caused by a very dangerous job esp in my field.

I did an internship at the local VA here a few years ago, so I saw up close the issues these soldiers come back with. I wouldn't wish that on anyone. I'm not sure what your role is, but much respect for working and being supportive of these guys. It's by far some of the worst PTSD I've ever seen...

 

[sharp]

Screw Omar.

Omar Sucks?

 

[dlockz]

I did an internship at the local VA here a few years ago, so I saw up close the issues these soldiers come back with. I wouldn't wish that on anyone. I'm not sure what your role is, but much respect for working and being supportive of these guys. It's by far some of the worst PTSD I've ever seen...

Im just an infantry soldier in a leadership role but we are always in contact with people with these problems and working with people to get them help. hell Im not sure I dealt with all the issues of what I have seen first hand.

 

[nyjunc]

I wish Marshall the best of luck, this is more important than football.