This Rookie QB class comparison.. | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

This Rookie QB class comparison..

Gonzofinfan

Gonzofinfan

Super Donator
Joined
Aug 13, 2011
Messages
972
Reaction score
978
Location
Orlando,FL
I have to say this rookie QB class appears that all 3 of the top QB prospects are looking like future stars, Maybe Jordan Love will too but I have to say this seems to me that it may be the strongest QB class I can Remember.. I mean the closest i can think of is the year that had Rothelisberger, Eli, RIvers but i'd argue this class seems to be off to a better start then even they started out with.

Is this the best since 83?
 
People and Media members alike seem to be forgetting one BIG difference between the 3 Teams these stars play for.

Burrows in Cincy might be the worst because Cincy has a OC for a HC and their team is old. I don’t see Cincy being a good team for years and that’s not good for Burrow.

Tua in Miami was situation where The Team had the Capital to start a building process as Tua arrived. Coach Flores Continues to impress not just fans but Media as well. As far as the Talent Immediately surrounding Tua, it could be better. Gaskin is Ok and outside of Parker there’s a drop. Williams isn’t too bad.

Herbert in LA was a dream come true for Herbert. That team Had a Playoff ready roster which is why they wanted Brady. The guy is surrounded by top Talent to throw to. Not saying Herbert hasn’t shown out cause he has but there’s a reason why they’ve only won one with a better roster than the other 2 teams
 
It's still really early. Don't forget that 2012 also looked like an all-time class with Andrew Luck, Robert Griffin III and Russell Wilson. Luck was the generational talent, RGIII was ROY and Wilson won the Super Bowl in his second year.

Incidentally, I just happened to see a segment on GMFB yesterday about who you would take for one big game right now and who you would take for the next 10 years among Tua, Burrow and Herbert:

 
Bartowboy said:
People and Media members alike seem to be forgetting one BIG difference between the 3 Teams these stars play for.

Burrows in Cincy might be the worst because Cincy has a OC for a HC and their team is old. I don’t see Cincy being a good team for years and that’s not good for Burrow.

Tua in Miami was situation where The Team had the Capital to start a building process as Tua arrived. Coach Flores Continues to impress not just fans but Media as well. As far as the Talent Immediately surrounding Tua, it could be better. Gaskin is Ok and outside of Parker there’s a drop. Williams isn’t too bad.

Herbert in LA was a dream come true for Herbert. That team Had a Playoff ready roster which is why they wanted Brady. The guy is surrounded by top Talent to throw to. Not saying Herbert hasn’t shown out cause he has but there’s a reason why they’ve only won one with a better roster than the other 2 teams
Click to expand...
Chargers is not a championship roster, and the field goal kicker cost Them at least two games.
 
Bartowboy said:
People and Media members alike seem to be forgetting one BIG difference between the 3 Teams these stars play for.

Burrows in Cincy might be the worst because Cincy has a OC for a HC and their team is old. I don’t see Cincy being a good team for years and that’s not good for Burrow.

Tua in Miami was situation where The Team had the Capital to start a building process as Tua arrived. Coach Flores Continues to impress not just fans but Media as well. As far as the Talent Immediately surrounding Tua, it could be better. Gaskin is Ok and outside of Parker there’s a drop. Williams isn’t too bad.

Herbert in LA was a dream come true for Herbert. That team Had a Playoff ready roster which is why they wanted Brady. The guy is surrounded by top Talent to throw to. Not saying Herbert hasn’t shown out cause he has but there’s a reason why they’ve only won one with a better roster than the other 2 teams
Click to expand...
That's a good point, never really thought of it that way.

Just proves these 3 QBs are good enough to make their teams better...and that is needed!
 
I’m not knocking anyone but I am so perplexed as to why people attach an “S” to Burrow’s last name and call him Joe Burrows. Like it’s not a knock on anyone it’s just a mental human thing I have heard it or read it countless times.

it’s like calling Tom Brady Tom Bradys or Herbert Justin Herberts haha
 
It still super early in the process. As we see sometimes rookies are a flash in the pan and fade out quickly. The signs are encouraging for each team to be quite honest. Plus there seems to be some real issues on defense league wide. It will be interesting to see what happens ro these guys after teams have a year to study them. The NFL needed a big qb class to push out the average and older ones and they may finally be getting that group they needed.
 
Gonzofinfan said:
I have to say this rookie QB class appears that all 3 of the top QB prospects are looking like future stars, Maybe Jordan Love will too but I have to say this seems to me that it may be the strongest QB class I can Remember.. I mean the closest i can think of is the year that had Rothelisberger, Eli, RIvers but i'd argue this class seems to be off to a better start then even they started out with.

Is this the best since 83?
Click to expand...
Easy now......the 83 class had 3 that are in the HOF plus another guy went to the SB. This class is looking good so far but they have a long way to go.
 
Looks like a very good class. Love burrow and Tua. Herbert is surprisingly good right now but we’ll see if he can keep it up in skeptical
 
HCE said:
It's still really early. Don't forget that 2012 also looked like an all-time class with Andrew Luck, Robert Griffin III and Russell Wilson. Luck was the generational talent, RGIII was ROY and Wilson won the Super Bowl in his second year.

Incidentally, I just happened to see a segment on GMFB yesterday about who you would take for one big game right now and who you would take for the next 10 years among Tua, Burrow and Herbert:

Click to expand...

Yea but RG3 was a flash in the pan. Who is the flash in the pan out of this group. Money on Herbert
 
Hey it’s j off the man who was missing
 
BlueFin said:
Chargers is not a championship roster, and the field goal kicker cost Them at least two games.
Click to expand...
I didn’t say Championship, I said Playoff ready. Look back at the past years, the Chargers had Playoff teams and barely missed the playoffs on a few. Keenan Allen, Mike Williams and Hunter Henry are mainly why Herbert has had the type of success your seeing him have early on. The Bengals and Dolphins don’t come close to what the Chargers has waiting for Herbert.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom