Top 3 rookies QB's | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Top 3 rookies QB's

V

vega51

Active Roster
Joined
Jan 29, 2012
Messages
673
Reaction score
583
Burrow- Quaterback rating 89.8 and QBR 57.9
Tua- Quaterback rating 99.4 and QBR 64.00
Herbert- Quaterback rating 94.2 and QBR 65.1

Why everybody are taking great things about Burrow and Herbert and so many people dishing Tua when our QB is having a better year than those 2?

I think the 3 QB's are having great years, but Tua is having the best out of the 3.
 
Because Tuas games are scripted and have minimal to low risk. Burrow and Herbert they cut the cord on early and let them play all out.

Tua has been rolled out over time and they are progressing him as they believe he should be brought along slowly. We have the team around him, so far this is working.
 
Get your popcorn ready. I bet we open up the playbook for Tua this week. We'll need to run it back if they hang 21 on us in the first half.
 
TKAllDay said:
Because Tuas games are scripted and have minimal to low risk. Burrow and Herbert they cut the cord on early and let them play all out.

Tua has been rolled out over time and they are progressing him as they believe he should be brought along slowly. We have the team around him, so far this is working.
Click to expand...
You can go with what Flores said on saying that it was gailey's idea to go no huddle to speed the last game up. Not disagreeing with you but I guarantee the no huddle as well as to throw in the ball over 40 times wasn't in the game plan. And like dolphinteeth said I think that the playbook just continues to open more and more for Tua.
 
danstilldaman said:
You can go with what Flores said on saying that it was gailey's idea to go no huddle to speed the last game up. Not disagreeing with you but I guarantee the no huddle as well as to throw in the ball over 40 times wasn't in the game plan. And like dolphinteeth said I think that the playbook just continues to open more and more for Tua.
Click to expand...
Totally agree brotha
 
It's even more impressive b/c Tua had not played football in so long. Reasonably you'd expect him to show quite a bit of rust. I also think there has been an adjustment for Tua b/c his receivers have not been good at getting separation. In college receivers in general get more separation. It's more about throwing to the open guy. Burrow's and Herbert's get more separation so it's more like college. Tua is having to adjust to throwing into much smaller windows. I believe he will b/c his ball placement and accuracy is so good, but it's still an adjustment.

For me Tua and Burrow have showed much of what they showed in college in terms of traits. The surprise for me is Herbert b/c he was not as good against pressure in college as he's been in the pros. I had all three as worthy of first round picks, but it's rare to see all three play so well right out of the gate.
 
Burrow and Herbert are surrounded with weapons......Tua is not! In fact Tua has one of the weakest combos in the league.
 
Finsup4ever said:
Burrow and Herbert are surrounded with weapons......Tua is not! In fact Tua has one of the weakest combos in the league.
Click to expand...
Not so sure Burrow is. His OL is brutal. But the fact is that Burrow is throwing the ball a lot while the Bengals are down and he's throwing against prevent. There is reason his QBR is last of the three.
 
Brumdog45 said:
Not so sure Burrow is. His OL is brutal. But the fact is that Burrow is throwing the ball a lot while the Bengals are down and he's throwing against prevent. There is reason his QBR is last of the three.
Click to expand...

His line isn't good, but I said surrounded by weapons. When you have AJ Green, Tyler Boyd, and Tee Higgins as receivers with Joe Mixon and Giovanny Bernard as running backs who can both also catch it well from the backfield, you have a good set of weapons.
 
Brumdog45 said:
Not so sure Burrow is. His OL is brutal. But the fact is that Burrow is throwing the ball a lot while the Bengals are down and he's throwing against prevent. There is reason his QBR is last of the three.
Click to expand...
The Bungles line is awful... we all saw that on Sunday.

Expect them to be major players both in FA and on draft day with any and all available linemen.
 
Finsup4ever said:
His line isn't good, but I said surrounded by weapons. When you have AJ Green, Tyler Boyd, and Tee Higgins as receivers with Joe Mixon and Giovanny Bernard as running backs who can both also catch it well from the backfield, you have a good set of weapons.
Click to expand...
This is what we would have had if Grier/Flores would have listened to those at FinHeaven who wanted us to take WRs and RBs last year.

We would have been able to watch our QB get killed, even though he had 'weapons'.

This is EXACTLY why you go trench first.
 
Feverdream said:
This is what we would have had if Grier/Flores would have listened to those at FinHeaven who wanted us to take WRs and RBs last year.

We would have been able to watch our QB get killed, even though he had 'weapons'.

This is EXACTLY why you go trench first.
Click to expand...
Totally agree. I was just stating that Burrow and Herbert have the weapons. I am very happy with what is happening in Miami.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom