Top Ten QBs in NFL today | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Top Ten QBs in NFL today

There's no question Brady is #1 when he's healthy, it's not even close.
 
Oh its def close. But he's right brady is the best. Very close like he said though.
 
Brady is injured....how can he be in this category at all when he is gimpy?
I would still put Peyton Manning ahead of him slightly...here is my top ten:

1. P. Manning
2. T. Brady
3. Roethlisberger
4. Favre
5. Brees
6. E. Manning
7. K. Warner
8. C. Palmer
9. Pennington
10. Romo

(Matt Ryan, J. Cutler....still too early to tell).
 
Yup Brady is definitely no. 1 when hes healthy. Unfortunately, hes not:lol:

heres my top 10 for this season only

1. Peyton Manning
2. Drew Brees
3. Tony Romo
4. Kurt Warner
5. Philip Rivers
6. Eli Manning
7. Jay Cutler
8. Aaron Rodgers
9. Matt Ryan
10. Chad Pennington

I think i forgot somebody.. hmmm:rolleyes2:
 
Roman529 said:
Carson Palmer when he is healthy? :err:
Click to expand...
No, my list is based on their performance this year thats why i didn't include palmer as well as tom brady.


edited: but there's no doubt Carson Palmer is one of the elite QBs in NFL today.. too bad their defense sux.
 
when tom brady gets too old, will he still be the best qb when he is young? the fact is he is injured and should not be on any best qb list this year!!
 
If anyone wants to put Matt Ryan on this list for the 2008 season then you have to put him behind Kerry Collins because they are both game manager type QB s this seaon and Kerry's team has won more games.
 
Eternity123 said:
No, my list is based on their performance this year thats why i didn't include palmer as well as tom brady.


edited: but there's no doubt Carson Palmer is one of the elite QBs in NFL today.. too bad their defense sux.
Click to expand...
You must be a USC fan.
 
Brett Favre is not 7th. He's not currently better than Cutler, or Rivers IMO.

I'd rank him inside the top 10 however, probably 10th.

Brees ahead of Romo. I think i'd put Cutler ahead of Romo too.
 
1. Peyton M.
2. Kurt W.
3. Eli M.
4. Brett F.
5. Drew B.
6. Phillip R.
7. Chad P.
8. Tony R.
9. Jay C.
10. Jason C.

I think Jason Campbell is going to become an elite QB, he showing signs of it this season.
 
DOLFAN_51 said:
If anyone wants to put Matt Ryan on this list for the 2008 season then you have to put him behind Kerry Collins because they are both game manager type QB s this seaon and Kerry's team has won more games.
Click to expand...

If you think Ryan is a game manager type QB then you either have never watched him play or you dont understand the game at all. Ryan is a playmaker and an excellent game manager.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom