Trade-up With Sf?

[SF Dolphin Fan]

Maybe I'm being an optimist, but all these posts about trading Stills and Quinn got me thinking.

The 49ers need pass rushers and wide receivers. Why not trade Stills, Quinn, pick #13 and next year's 2nd rounder for SF's #2 overall. The Dolphins could then get Haskins and solve the quarterback position.

Stills is young, talented and was criminally underutilized by Miami last year. He's a good player. Quinn struggled, but Miami's run defense didn't help. He's only a few years removed from a 20-sack season.

SF would be passing on Nick Bosa, but the 13th overall could net them a good player.

Would the Dolphins have to give up more, or would that be in the ballpark?

 

[Hargitt01]

I'd rather have Bosa at #2 over Haskins

 

[SF Dolphin Fan]

I'd rather have Bosa at #2 over Haskins

SF will probably pounce on Bosa. The only concern with him is coming off an injury.

 

[phinfan40353]

Bosa is over hyped.

Give me Josh Allen instead. Complete package, proven in SEC and versatile.

Bosa has not been steadily improving. He is a name pick.

 

[LargoFin]

I'd rather have Bosa at #2 over Haskins

Sure you would, just like Sashi and Hue, rather have an irrelevant Myles Garrett over Mahomes. Brilliant!
You'd fit nicely in the Dolphins organization.

 

[Phindog]

Trade down in 2019 shore up the Lines, trade up 2020 to get our QB.

 

[mrbunglez]

I honestly want them to trade down into the 20s and pick up more draft picks for this or next years draft. This draft is deep on the defense side of the ball that they’d still get a quality player late 1st round.

 

[maralieus]

Bosa is over hyped.

Give me Josh Allen instead. Complete package, proven in SEC and versatile.

Bosa has not been steadily improving. He is a name pick.

He was hurt all year. You’re wrong. He’s better than his brother and his brother is dominant. Also the sec has been garbage. It’s bama, Georgia and garbage.

 

[Swollcolb]

Your way off on value to trade up 11 spots. Last year Jets traded 3 2nds to move up like 3 spots to draft a QB. Quinn has no or extremely low trade value or he would have been dealt already, and stills maybe is equivalent to 4-5th round compensation. We’d have to offer our first and next years first and most likely stills and a late round pick to even get them talking

 

[Coach_Rob]

Trade down in 2019 shore up the Lines, trade up 2020 to get our QB.

for who? I hope all the tua fans are ready for disappointment.

 

[Mach2]

No. No. A thousand times no.

No early round QB this year, and a million times no, trading up for one.

 

[Phindog]

for who? I hope all the tua fans are ready for disappointment.

I never said Tua, you did.

We're just getting over the Tannehill haters when Ryan's soon to be gone and now we're starting Tua hating so soon?

It could be Tua, it could be Fromm, maybe our staff likes Herbert. It really depends how they play in their 3rd season and if they come out.

Trade up for one of the best of the 4 QB's available that's in reach for us and what fits the mold of what Miami is doing.

This year linemen, next year QB.

 

[hoops]

Offers not even remotely realistic separate from everything else

 

[SF Dolphin Fan]

Your way off on value to trade up 11 spots. Last year Jets traded 3 2nds to move up like 3 spots to draft a QB. Quinn has no or extremely low trade value or he would have been dealt already, and stills maybe is equivalent to 4-5th round compensation. We’d have to offer our first and next years first and most likely stills and a late round pick to even get them talking

Wasn't sure on value. I do think SF would be interested in Stills. Not sure on Quinn.

 

[SF Dolphin Fan]

Offers not even remotely realistic separate from everything else

What do you think it would take? I realize Miami isn't in the best position at #13. Raiders, Denver and NYG are all in better positions. But maybe including players and draft picks could get it done.