Tua All 22 Vs. Jags | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Tua All 22 Vs. Jags

RobertHorry

RobertHorry

Scout Team
Joined
Apr 26, 2007
Messages
5,035
Reaction score
3,876


I really have nothing to say. Zero separation from our receivers. Mack Hollins looks like he has cement feet running his routes. Waddle runs only short routes, and Wilson's running the wrong route half the time. Jesse Davis or Eich is getting destroyed on the edge every play. And even with all of that, Tua is making extremely quick and decisive reads. Looking through the progressions and still manipulating the safety. I found a few errors. But out of 47 throws and 9 minutes of tape less than 5 mistakes is outstanding. Not running for the first and airmalling the improvised throw, waiting too long to throw the honeypot C2 look with Waddle on the sideline that results in the pick, throwing it to Waddle on double coverage instead of Ford down the post, and missing Geisciki on the quick glance route when he threw it to Gaskins. That's literally all the mistakes I could find. The Seam route to Smythe was Smythe's fault since he was turning the seam into a bender when he probably could have kept it as the seam. Mack Hollins on the deep fade turned it into a post when the safety was on top of it in the middle. Should've kept it to the boundary and it's probably a TD.

The rest of his game was absolutely flawless. And thats with the clowns Godsey dialing up less than 3 deep shots all game.

This video is the sad reality that Tua is surrounded by incompetence. I would love to hear some people who said Tua didn't play excellent actually give legit reasons. But I am sure they won't be able to.
 
I'll be the first to admit that my knowledge of football is as a lifelong fan who has played a bunch of Madden. I've never played football, never coached even a peewee team. But what Tua has shown already should be obvious: he is a cut above anything we've seen here in Miami in 20 years. How on earth do people not get that? Haven't we seen enough sh**y Qb-ing, and elite Qb-ing on opposing sides, to see what we have is nowhere near the former end of the distribution, and flashes regular signals pointing to the latter? And that's before factoring in the dumpster fire at virtually every level of the organization and position groups actually on the field. It's pure madness.
 
RobertHorry said:


I really have nothing to say. Zero separation from our receivers. Mack Hollins looks like he has cement feet running his routes. Waddle runs only short routes, and Wilson's running the wrong route half the time. Jesse Davis or Eich is getting destroyed on the edge every play. And even with all of that, Tua is making extremely quick and decisive reads. Looking through the progressions and still manipulating the safety. I found a few errors. But out of 47 throws and 9 minutes of tape less than 5 mistakes is outstanding. Not running for the first and airmalling the improvised throw, waiting too long to throw the honeypot C2 look with Waddle on the sideline that results in the pick, throwing it to Waddle on double coverage instead of Ford down the post, and missing Geisciki on the quick glance route when he threw it to Gaskins. That's literally all the mistakes I could find. The Seam route to Smythe was Smythe's fault since he was turning the seam into a bender when he probably could have kept it as the seam. Mack Hollins on the deep fade turned it into a post when the safety was on top of it in the middle. Should've kept it to the boundary and it's probably a TD.

The rest of his game was absolutely flawless. And thats with the clowns Godsey dialing up less than 3 deep shots all game.

This video is the sad reality that Tua is surrounded by incompetence. I would love to hear some people who said Tua didn't play excellent actually give legit reasons. But I am sure they won't be able to.
Click to expand...

BOOM!!! Thanks Robert….This is why you DON’T TRADE FOR WATSON. Nice job Brother.

EDIT….After watching the all 22 I actually feel more sorry for Tua than I do for any QB in the last 20 years. That offensive line is a complete disgrace. January 10th this film should be what Ross shows to Grier to explain why he’s firing him.
 
RobertHorry said:


I really have nothing to say. Zero separation from our receivers. Mack Hollins looks like he has cement feet running his routes. Waddle runs only short routes, and Wilson's running the wrong route half the time. Jesse Davis or Eich is getting destroyed on the edge every play. And even with all of that, Tua is making extremely quick and decisive reads. Looking through the progressions and still manipulating the safety. I found a few errors. But out of 47 throws and 9 minutes of tape less than 5 mistakes is outstanding. Not running for the first and airmalling the improvised throw, waiting too long to throw the honeypot C2 look with Waddle on the sideline that results in the pick, throwing it to Waddle on double coverage instead of Ford down the post, and missing Geisciki on the quick glance route when he threw it to Gaskins. That's literally all the mistakes I could find. The Seam route to Smythe was Smythe's fault since he was turning the seam into a bender when he probably could have kept it as the seam. Mack Hollins on the deep fade turned it into a post when the safety was on top of it in the middle. Should've kept it to the boundary and it's probably a TD.

The rest of his game was absolutely flawless. And thats with the clowns Godsey dialing up less than 3 deep shots all game.

This video is the sad reality that Tua is surrounded by incompetence. I would love to hear some people who said Tua didn't play excellent actually give legit reasons. But I am sure they won't be able to.
Click to expand...

You’re missing one key mistake which was probably the difference in the game. In fact it literally was. With 27 seconds left in the first half Holland makes a great play and gets out of bounds at the 45. You have to know as a coach/qb (both flo and tua at fault) that u have 2 to 3 plays to get to about the 35 and then spike the ball. Only other option is to make a throw towards the sideline and get out of bounds. What happens, tua throws a meaningless 7 yard pass in bounds and we waste the opportunity. The teams gotta be smarter than that, and that definitely includes Tua.
 
TannDaMan17 said:
You’re missing one key mistake which was probably the difference in the game. In fact it literally was. With 27 seconds left in the first half Holland makes a great play and gets out of bounds at the 45. You have to know as a coach/qb (both flo and tua at fault) that u have 2 to 3 plays to get to about the 35 and then spike the ball. Only other option is to make a throw towards the sideline and get out of bounds. What happens, tua throws a meaningless 7 yard pass in bounds and we waste the opportunity. The teams gotta be smarter than that, and that definitely includes Tua.
Click to expand...
I blame Brown for that. The defender was inside. He should have ran to the boundary. He turned upfield first and was caught from behind.
 
DOLFAN_51 said:
I blame Brown for that. The defender was inside. He should have ran to the boundary. He turned upfield first and was caught from behind.
Click to expand...
I disagree, Tua gotta make a better decision there and give Sanders a better shot. Poor game/clock management. Flos fault too but what else is new.
 
Tua played very well, it was the best game of his NFL career so far. We need more data points though, 10 games isn’t enough to gauge if he’s our franchise QB or if he isn’t.

The way it should have been done is to evaluate him on the remaining games and make a decision by the end of the season. That way, if we feel like Tua isn’t it, we don’t miss out on potential Elite FA QB’s Rodgers and Wilson.

Watson is a great QB also, but comes with too much baggage and risk.

Unfortunately, the front office and ownership don’t have the patience to wait it out and make an informed decision.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom