Tua or Mac Jones? | Page 16 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Tua or Mac Jones?

Which one?

  • Tua

    Votes: 76 67.3%

  • Mac

    Votes: 37 32.7%
  • Total voters
    113
FinfanInBuffalo said:
I’m saying that people exaggerate what other QBs are capable of behind the worst OL. Go back and watch
Mahomes in the SB. No protection, no creation. And that is the point.
Click to expand...

So you’re someone that can’t debate or intake real life information. I’ve already proven it to you guys Tua doesn’t face the most pressure or get blitzed the least. Enjoy your fairy tale
 
Neither QB is capable of ever winning anything significant. They’re both bridge QBs that you should have a 21-22 year old first round QB sitting behind. And not sitting for long at that.

Pointless argument.
 
QB Ranking, 2025 week 11

SUPER ELITE
1. Lamar Jackson, 31.98

ELITE
2. Matthew Stafford, 29.05

GOOD
3. Josh Allen, 26.61
4. Jared Goff, 26.09
5. Patrick Mahomes, 25.75
6. Jalen Hurts, 25.54
7. Sam Darnold, 24.71
8. Drake Maye, 24.59

DECENT
9. Jaxson Dart, 23.98
10. Daniel Jones, 23.79
11. Jacoby Brissett, 23.11
12. Dak Prescott, 23.03
13. Justin Herbert, 22.07
14. Baker Mayfield, 21.87
15. Caleb Williams, 21.57
16. Jordan Love, 21.54
17. Bo Nix, 20.57
18. Mac Jones, 20.81

NOT GOOD ENOUGH
19. Jayden Daniels, 19.96
20. Aaron Rodgers, 19.75
21. Marcus Mariota, 19.51
22. Joe Flacco, 18.38
23. CJ Stroud, 17.95

GARBAGE
24. Michael Penix, 16.91
25. Trevor Lawrence, 16.69
26. Kyler Murray, 16.64
27. Tua Tagovailoa, 16.30
28. Justin Fields, 15.72
29. Russell Wilson, 15.52
30. Spencer Rattler, 14.74
31. Carson Wentz, 14.69
32. Bryce Young, 14.19
33. Dillon Gabriel, 14.12
34. JJ McCarthy, 13.95
35. Tyler Shough, 13.81
36. Tyler Huntley, 13.35
37. Geno Smith, 13.18
38. Tyrod Taylor, 12.33
39. Joe Burrow, 11.16

DUMPSTER FIRE
40. Cam Ward, 8.62
41. Cooper Rush, 2.50


TUA history:
2020: Garbage, 16.78
2021: Not good enough, 18.44
2022: Good, 24.78
2023: Decent, 21.41
2024: Decent, 21.68
 
Last edited:
QB Ranking, 2025 week 12

ELITE
1. Josh Allen, 28.76
2. Matthew Stafford, 28.09

GOOD
3. Dak Prescott, 24.56
4. Patrick Mahomes, 24.53
5. Jacoby Brissett, 24.47
6. Drake Maye, 24.38
7. Jared Goff, 24.38

DECENT
8. Lamar Jackson, 24.00
8. Jalen Hurts, 24.00
8. Jaxson Dart, 23.98
11. Daniel Jones, 23.79
12. Sam Darnold, 21.89
13. Bo Nix, 21.83
14. Baker Mayfield, 21.62
15. Jordan Love, 21.44
16. Mac Jones, 20.81
17. Justin Herbert, 20.38
18. Caleb Williams, 20.27

NOT GOOD ENOUGH
19. Jayden Daniels, 19.96
19. Aaron Rodgers, 19.96
21. Marcus Mariota, 18.99
22. CJ Stroud, 17.95
23. Joe Flacco, 17.65

GARBAGE
24. Trevor Lawrence, 16.90
25. Kyler Murray, 16.64
26. Michael Penix, 16.57
27. Bryce Young, 16.36
28. Justin Fields, 16.25
29. Tua Tagovailoa, 15.64
30. Spencer Rattler, 14.74
31. Carson Wentz, 14.69
32. Brock Purdy, 13.86
33. Tyler Shough, 13.81
34. Geno Smith, 13.13
35. JJ McCarthy, 12.81
36. Dillon Gabriel, 12.76
37. Joe Burrow, 11.16

DUMPSTER FIRE
38. Cam Ward, 9.24
 
Neither look for another QB in 2026 to compete with Ewers. Then draft a QB in round 1 in 2027, if no QB steps up in 2026.
 
joenhre said:
Neither look for another QB in 2026 to compete with Ewers. Then draft a QB in round 1 in 2027, if no QB steps up in 2026.
Click to expand...

Though Tua this year is inconsistent, and scary on each pass, Jones is more unreliable then Tua...I understand we are in a mirage fot a possible playoff spot, but why Jones still is the backup, I don't understand.

I don't know what they see in practice, but no way Jones is looking sharper then Ewers, and I can't believe that with the way Tua is playing, Ewers could not be brought in, and show what he has to offer.
 
QB Ranking, 2025 week 13

ELITE
1. Matthew Stafford, 27.56

GOOD
2. Josh Allen, 25.62
3. Dak Prescott 25.30
4. Jalen Hurts 24.60
5. Patrick Mahomes 24.46
6. Jared Goff 24.13

DECENT
7. Daniel Jones, 23.53
8. Jacoby Brissett, 23.46
9. Drake Maye 23.28
10. Jaxson Dart, 22.92
11. Jordan Love 21.83
12. Mac Jones 20.81
13. Sam Darnold 20.62
14. Lamar Jackson 20.44
15. Bo Nix 20.38
16. Justin Herbert 20.21
17. Brock Purdy 20.08

NOT GOOD ENOUGH
19. Jayden Daniels, 19.96
20. Caleb Williams 19.94
21. Baker Mayfield 19.63
22. Jameis Winston 19.20
23. Marcus Mariota, 18.99
24. Aaron Rodgers 18.75
25. Mason Rudolph 17.86
26. Trevor Lawrence 17.74
27. CJ Stroud 17.01

GARBAGE
28. Bryce Young 16.99
29. Joe Flacco 16.96
30. Kyler Murray 16.64
31. Joe Burrow 16.61
32. Michael Penix 16.57
33. Justin Fields 16.25 JETS WEEK
34. Spencer Rattler 14.74
35. Carson Wentz 14.69
36. Tyrod Taylor 14.64 JETS WEEK
37. Tua Tagovailoa 14.56
38. Geno Smith 14.21
39. Tyler Shough 13.58
40. Dillon Gabriel 12.76
41. JJ McCarthy 10.50
42. Cam Ward 10.12

DUMPSTER FIRE
43. Shedeur Sanders 9.68


TUA history:
2020: Garbage, 16.78
2021: Not good enough, 18.44
2022: Good, 24.78
2023: Decent, 21.41
2024: Decent, 21.68
 
Last edited:
Miami is a playoff team with a better QB. That's the position that needs attention, TT is holding this team back with all of his limitations.
 
dolphinkee said:
Miami is a playoff team with a better QB. That's the position that needs attention, TT is holding this team back with all of his limitations.
Click to expand...
Agree but a few other pieces are missing
-Decent owner who actually cares
-Capable HC who can actually motivate Men
-Great asst coaches
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom