THIS is the BigNastyFish type post I am completely on board with!
Look, some positions are simply more valuable than others. Everyone knows a QB is far more valuable than a G, and a CB1 is far more valuable than a DT. Just how it is. When you get a top shelf CB, yes, he is going to get paid, and teams that keep them tend to do well, and teams that let them get away tend to regret it. We can't dictate the contract terms, and if he is outside of the realm of reasonable … we have to cut our losses like
@BigNastyFish suggested.
But, the Seahawks found a way to pay Richard Sherman, and they continued to have a dominant defense. The Jet's lost Revis … and never were the same again. Even the Carolina Panthers let a decent CB defect and never were the same defense. Yes, it's painful … but a 1st rounder isn't going to be enough for a guy who is already an elite CB1. Most never pan out, the few that do … you can't let slip through your hands.
But everyone has a price.
We loved Jarvis Landry, but he proved to be too expensive, and we made the right decision letting him go. In this case, if we let X go we will get a 1st rounder+ at a time when we need draft picks and have a terrible void at CB1 in a year we're tanking. It makes sense.
Honestly, it's a good problem to have right now. Still, if we can re-sign him, we should … because when we finish tanking and build the 2020 season, X is an irreplaceable asset upon which to build that defense. Coach Flores is a defensive coach … he understands how hard they are to find. Look at Belichick, even he traded with Buffalo in the division to get a CB1, and he benched a CB1 in the playoffs because he wouldn't re-sign .. and it probably cost him the Super Bowl honestly. And, think of how Belichick recruited Revis. Belichick knows the value of a CB1 … and I'm sure Coach Flores does too. Those guys are rare, and you need one. No, it's not a QB, but it is a precious resource.