What are thoughts on this trade?

[Big Free]

Reynoldo Hill for Trent Green? This way we keep our pick and the Chiefs get a replacement for Sammy Knight.

 

[MelbournePhin]

rather keep a contributor than a 7th or 6th rounder

 

[Marc790]

rather keep a contributor than a 7th or 6th rounder

Yeah, let's throw it Zach Thomas and Jason Taylor while at it, too, so we can free up cap room for Trent Green. Brilliant idea!

 

[chillwill3000]

I think , no

Reynoldo Hill for Trent Green? This way we keep our pick and the Chiefs get a replacement for Sammy Knight.

 

[LarryFinFan]

A seventh or sixth rounder is all he is worth anyway, so take the proven commodity in Hill and give them the 6th or 7th unproven guy...

 

[PerfectFinz72]

I think we have a couple 6th and 7th rounders....I'd say just part with one of them.

 

[Ohio Fanatic]

Not a good idea.

 

[phinsfan1221]

trade tillman the dolphins just signed him

 

[finserg]

no way

 

[HybridPHIN 23]

Hill is now locked in as our FS with Allen being moved to corner....
He earned it last year anyway.. lets not sacrifice the future to fill a gap for a year.

 

[Geforce]

I don't care if KC finds a replacement for Sammy Knight. Renaldo Hill was our most consistent DB last season. He's not spectacular but he is dependable.

 

[Static387]

I'd prefer to have Hill & Bell as our safties.

 

[SamTodd]

I hope randy just stands his ground on a 7th. if we don't strike the deal then waht? cheifs release him? win- win. also we're most likely not going to resign donnie jones, so essentially if we do get green for the 7th its like trading a punter for a stopgap former probowl QB. Randy is doing a great job.