What is Tua's trade value if...

[ChitownPhins28]

Miami wanted Fields or traded for Watson but Houston didnt want Tua in the deal?

Im leaving my opinion/like-dislike of Tua out of my initial post.

From a 'cold, hard facts' analysis, what could Tua fetch?

 

[superphin]

Probably a mid to late 1st round pick...at the very least a 2nd and a 4th.

 

[ChitownPhins28]

BTW, I think it was flagrant BS for Grier to make a declaration that 'Tua is our QB next year'.
If Miami sees a guy they like better, or a trade situation falls into their laps like what the DeShawn Watson situation is, and they move on from Tua then they prove themselves as liars.
"We look at every option available to improve our football team" is how you answer that question.
If we get through FA and the draft and Tua is our QB, then Tua is our QB.
The Dolphins didnt owe Tua a 'pat on the back' that might turn out to be a lie, anyway.

 

[artdnj]

This time of year declarations mean nothing, it’s fluid and I think most know that.

 

[Dolphinitis]

a third would be the most they could get. he has little value after last season.

 

[artdnj]

Nah, more than that

 

[BigNastyFish]

BTW, I think it was flagrant BS for Grier to make a declaration that 'Tua is our QB next year'.
If Miami sees a guy they like better, or a trade situation falls into their laps like what the DeShawn Watson situation is, and they move on from Tua then they prove themselves as liars.
"We look at every option available to improve our football team" is how you answer that question.
If we get through FA and the draft and Tua is our QB, then Tua is our QB.
The Dolphins didnt owe Tua a 'pat on the back' that might turn out to be a lie, anyway.

yikes!

First he said "starter" -- in other words #1 on the roster @QB

Beyond that he never said ANY player (Tua included) has a 100% guaranteed roster spot.

And last -- everyone knows pretty much every player is replaceable at one price or another.

Me personally --- no lies no deceptions. Are you angry?

 

[Avigatorx]

He'd get us a first round pick, maybe more. Most teams will decide we ****ed up his development.

 

[Pitbull13]

a third would be the most they could get. he has little value after last season.

I would agree. 2 might be the highest

 

[hoops]

He'd get us a first round pick, maybe more. Most teams will decide we ****ed up his development.

that and give him a pass for the hip for a year. Probably more the latter than anything

 

[SF Dolphin Fan]

I really don't see how he damaged his draft value.

As a rookie quarterback, he had 11 touchdowns and 5 interceptions, played with third and fourth string receivers down the stretch and had three rookies starting on the offensive line.

He didn't set the NFL on fire, held onto the ball a little too long at times, but did a decent job considering what he had around him.

 

[hoops]

I know one thing I want the Miami gm job if I can keep moving the draft pick qb accountability needle back and keep my job

 

[DannyMcCoy]

Maybe a 2nd

 

[Dolphinitis]

I would agree. 2 might be the highest

who in their right mind would give a first for Tua?
maybe we can send a 3rd or 4th round pick to the Jets for
Darnold so as to provide competition.

 

[BlueFin]

BTW, I think it was flagrant BS for Grier to make a declaration that 'Tua is our QB next year'.
If Miami sees a guy they like better, or a trade situation falls into their laps like what the DeShawn Watson situation is, and they move on from Tua then they prove themselves as liars.
"We look at every option available to improve our football team" is how you answer that question.
If we get through FA and the draft and Tua is our QB, then Tua is our QB.
The Dolphins didnt owe Tua a 'pat on the back' that might turn out to be a lie, anyway.

It’s like Saban...”he will not be the next coach at Alabama”....meaningless!