Which Draft Expert? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Which Draft Expert?

BahamaFinFan78

Active Roster
Joined
Jul 18, 2010
Messages
8,010
Reaction score
8,604
There seem to be thousands of them these days. Many of them seem as lost as me and you. Is there any particular one that seems to get more hits than misses on their predictions?
 
There seem to be thousands of them these days. Many of them seem as lost as me and you. Is there any particular one that seems to get more hits than misses on their predictions?

The only one I really like is Daniel Jeremiah...not sure about hits or misses, but has worked as an NFL scout and understand the process and is pretty solid in player evaluations
 
I like Mayor personally but artdnj is something special.
 
What's that 16 year old kid saying? Well he is 18 now, but anyway.
 
The only one I really like is Daniel Jeremiah...not sure about hits or misses, but has worked as an NFL scout and understand the process and is pretty solid in player evaluations

I really like his newer mock Waynes and Perryman... Defense would be completely done. I would be crazy happy if it went down like that.
 
Me, you can see for yourself when I release my mock draft next tuesday
 
none of them...used to think mayock but he changes his board based on what he hears from teams...case in point kevin johnson is now the 2nd rated corner...although that has a lot to do with skeletons in marcus peters closet...doubt it has to do with the ones in jalen collins

wouldnt surprise me at all if going into the draft coverage tomorrow he has kendricks ahead of paul dawson either on his top 100...
 
There seem to be thousands of them these days. Many of them seem as lost as me and you. Is there any particular one that seems to get more hits than misses on their predictions?

Overall among name guys the hated kiper actually is right more often than other known guys.Gosselin and wright are usually pretty good among lesser known
 
none of them...used to think mayock but he changes his board based on what he hears from teams...case in point kevin johnson is now the 2nd rated corner...although that has a lot to do with skeletons in marcus peters closet...doubt it has to do with the ones in jalen collins

wouldnt surprise me at all if going into the draft coverage tomorrow he has kendricks ahead of paul dawson either on his top 100...

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000488358/article/2015-nfl-draft-mike-mayocks-top-100-prospects
 
Daniel Jeremiah is my favorite. He's newer than some of the rest but u usually agree with him.
 
What's that 16 year old kid saying? Well he is 18 now, but anyway.

Yeah, I respected his focus and value system above anybody else I've seen. That's why I posted that Jordan thread, whether I agreed with everything or not. He was lower on Jordan than I was.

That kid used a great blend of early analysis and also projecting to the pros via specific traits and how they translate. I loved that he would do his homework early and not feel a need to change with the wind as the draft approaches. Many of his scouting reports are planted 6 months ahead of time and he never feels compelled to update. Mike Mayock is exactly the opposite, as hoops mentioned. Mayock is mostly a joke these days. He shifts based on what he hears within the league and then phonies up the reasoning as if it's his own doing. Just within the past few days he's moved the order at several positions to fall in line with NFL group think.

Around here I would let Slimm pick. Again, mostly for the same reason, that he gets it out of the way early instead of frantic catch up in the final months and days. That lends itself to clarity, IMO.
 
I usually listen to what Gil Brandt has to say. He's made his mistakes like the rest of them, but he's less wowed by prototypes and more adept at projecting what traits will make a player successful in the pros.

Mayock, as hoops says, just follows the herd now.
 
Matt Waldman and friends and it's not even close. The thing is, since they really do their job well, they don't do mocks or rankings by position. Ok, he did cave in and did a mock, but it's not designed to predict what's going to happen.

http://mattwaldmanrsp.com/
 
Yeah, I respected his focus and value system above anybody else I've seen. That's why I posted that Jordan thread, whether I agreed with everything or not. He was lower on Jordan than I was.

That kid used a great blend of early analysis and also projecting to the pros via specific traits and how they translate. I loved that he would do his homework early and not feel a need to change with the wind as the draft approaches. Many of his scouting reports are planted 6 months ahead of time and he never feels compelled to update. Mike Mayock is exactly the opposite, as hoops mentioned. Mayock is mostly a joke these days. He shifts based on what he hears within the league and then phonies up the reasoning as if it's his own doing. Just within the past few days he's moved the order at several positions to fall in line with NFL group think.

Around here I would let Slimm pick. Again, mostly for the same reason, that he gets it out of the way early instead of frantic catch up in the final months and days. That lends itself to clarity, IMO.

Slimm is an animal. I've already started my pre-season evaluations for 2016, but he's already done. He watches more college football than anyone on the planet.

But like you mentioned, I have my evaluations done for the most part before the bowl season (around Thanksgiving). Daniel Jeremiah talks about getting players in the right neighborhood at that time, not the right home. That's what I try to do. Then between Bowl Season and the Senior Bowl I take a more detailed approach to each individual prospect to get them in the right home. After the Senior Bowl I'm pretty much locked in.

A few examples of a player moving up or down after the Senior Bowl for me would be:

1. Damontre Moore doing horrible at the combine and only performing 13 reps at 225 when Tavon Austin was able to match that. Confirmed reports of poor work ethic. He moved down.
2. Vic Beasley weighed in for scouts in April 2014 at 220 pounds. The first day of the combine he weighed in at 246 then capped it off with 34 reps at 225. He was already a top 12 pick for me but he moved up to the top 8 and the #1 pass rusher.
3. Todd Gurley. 5 team doctors just said that he'll be ready week one. When I released my big board on February 29th, I had Gordon over Gurley for the sake of thinking Gurley would need a redshirt year. Now that I have this information Gurley would move up on my board. But I set it on February 29th.

Those are the only instances I think a player should move much, if any at all on your board after the All-Star games. The truest evaluation comes in the fall.
 
Back
Top Bottom