Which Qb Coming Off Injury Will Have A Better Season? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Which Qb Coming Off Injury Will Have A Better Season?

Which QB Coming Off Injury Will Have A Better Season?

  • Total voters
    46
  • Poll closed .
Michigan Mike

Michigan Mike

Club Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2004
Messages
1,381
Reaction score
2,202
Location
Saranac, Michigan
Which one will have the best season after their season-ending injuries in 2017?

Personally, I think it will Be Rodgers (because he is Aaron Rodgers and has the longest history of success) but I also think that Tannehill will return to his 2016 form by mid season and will allow the Dolphins to be competitive this year and possibly be in the playoff chase in December.

Deshaun Watson and Carson Wentz will both be solid in their return but they are both relatively unproven over a full season so it is hard to determine if they will pick up where they left off.

Andrew Luck's struggles to come back causes a lot of concern. He just recently started throwing a regulation football and he still hasn't taken a hit in training camp.
 
Of the quarterbacks listed Rodgers is clearly the best talent wise, but Green Bay was really shaky in pass protection last year. And if Adams Cobb or Graham get hurt there’s not many weapons for him.

Wentz has already proven to be an above average passer in the NFL even with the small sample size. Plus he has some serious speed at the receiver position, a pro bowl running back in Ajayi, and (although inconsistent) a playmaking defense that can create turnovers. I think he’ll play a lot of mistake free football, put the ball in the hands of his playmakers and have another MVP caliber season.
 
I didn't even consider Rodgers because that's a given IMO. Out of the other four, I picked Wentz.

He's the best QB out of the other four from what I've seen from them imo. Great supporting cast as well.
 
I went with Wentz. He was on his way to probably winning the MVP last year as a 2nd year player. How often does that happen? After Brady and Brees are gone Went is one of the front runners to be one of the 2-3 best QB's in the NFL and I won't be surprised if he wins the MVP next year.
 
Rodgers will be great, until he gets hurt again trying to carry his team which has been his theme lately.
I expect Watson's league leading, "interceptable passes" to catch up with him as he ticks down a bit.
If Lucks Arm strength is back on par he'll have a good year but his bad team could hold him back.
I think Ryan will pick up where he left off in 16, I hope there's little to no rust as we can't afford it.
I want some sustainability from Wentz before I anoint him. His team was so good they won the Super bowl with the backup QB. Not that hard being the QB of the best TEAM in the league.
 
Is Rodgers oline particularly the tackles gonna stay healthy? Cause that matters for him
 
Rodgers to Graham is going to bananas. Rodgers but that;s a tough list to pick from. I could have selected everyone on it. Good post!
 
Michigan Mike said:
Which one will have the best season after their season-ending injuries in 2017?

Personally, I think it will Be Rodgers (because he is Aaron Rodgers and has the longest history of success) but I also think that Tannehill will return to his 2016 form by mid season and will allow the Dolphins to be competitive this year and possibly be in the playoff chase in December.

Deshaun Watson and Carson Wentz will both be solid in their return but they are both relatively unproven over a full season so it is hard to determine if they will pick up where they left off.

Andrew Luck's struggles to come back causes a lot of concern. He just recently started throwing a regulation football and he still hasn't taken a hit in training camp.
Click to expand...

If 2016 Ryan Tannehill makes your toes tingle, you should really check out 2017 Carson Wentz.
 
Rodgers. Purely from a medical standpoint of a lesser injury to recover from. I would choose Rodgers from a football standpoint also.
 
I’m a well-known supporter of Tannehill, and I can’t imagine any way he finishes higher than third in this.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom