Which would you prefer? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Which would you prefer?

M

MiaFins31

Active Roster
Joined
Jan 4, 2021
Messages
2,770
Reaction score
4,750
Age
35
Location
South Carolina
Scenario 1:
#3 Penei Sewell OT/Oregon
#18 Terrance Marshall WR/LSU
#36 Creed Humphrey C/Oklahoma
#50 JeVonte Williams TB/UNC

Scenario 2:
#3 DeVonta Smith WR/Alabama
#18 Zaven Collins LB/Tulsa
#36 Jaelan Phillip's EDGE/Miami
#50 Amon-Ra St Brown WR/USC

Scenario 3:
#3 JaMarr Chase WR/LSU
#18 Travis Etienne TB/Clemson
#36 Carlos Basham EDGE/Wake Forest
#50 Landon Dickerson C/Alabama

Scenario 4:
#3 Micah Parsons LB/Penn St
#18 Najee Harris TB/Alabama
#36 RonDale Moore WR/Purdue
#50 Alex Leatherwood OT/Alabama

Which scenario do you prefer for our Miami Dolphins?
 
For me, no to a first round RB, so that eliminates 3 and 4.
Isn't 36 a little high for Basham?
I think I would go with 2. But I want to trade Humphrey for Phillips. Then Jevonte for Amon Ra.
So Smith, Collins, Humphrey, Jevaonte W.
Am I allowed to mix and match?
 
1 first choice
4 second choice
3 third choice
2 fourth choice
 
Bopkin02 said:
For me, no to a first round RB, so that eliminates 3 and 4.
Isn't 36 a little high for Basham?
I think I would go with 2. But I want to trade Humphrey for Phillips. Then Jevonte for Amon Ra.
So Smith, Collins, Humphrey, Jevaonte W.
Am I allowed to mix and match?
Click to expand...
Absolutely you can mix and match. I've gotten a pretty good idea of who people like on here and that's why I mixed the players the way I did bc obviously we all have our preference for our first 4 picks so I done it like that to see who people really truly valued the most. I thought it was an interesting question.
 
I see what you did there and that is difficult as it’s hard to go all that wrong. I wish I could mix and match but since that isn’t possible in this game I suppose I would go with scenario 1.
 
arge13 said:
Smith
Collins
Humphrey
J. Williams
Click to expand...
That's about as good as it gets.

I like Marshall, in scenario #2, but Smith is the exact type of receiver Miami needs.

That draft won't set up the offense pretty well.
 
None of the above.

I’d take scenario #2 but change out Collins and Phillips. With likely an OL and RB. Depends upon who was actually still on the board.

But no chance I’m taking that LB with one of the 1st round picks.

Scenario #1 would be ok. But I’d like it better with Smith as the top pick over Sewell.
 
Scenario #2 for me but I would take JeVonte Williams at #50 instead
 
With those options, this order.

1 Strongest overall team opens up the entire offense.
2 Because I love Collins and I wouldn’t hate Gaskins at Rb with those Wrs
4 I like the attitude these players play with
3 More finesse skill players. Drops them down for me.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom