Who Would You Rather As A #5 WR?

[postermaster]

*Koren Robinson is out there as a free agent, he puts decent numbers...

*Charles Rogers, I haven't seen too much from him but c'mon, he is a second pick overall, its difficult to see another Ryan Leaf around the league, he has to have something...

*Cliff Russell has done great and is a good WR for a #5 spot...

 

[Rocky Raccoon]

based on pure hype I would say Rogers. A number 2 pic...it's tempting.

 

[Stitches]

I have to go with Rogers on pure talent and potential.

 

[ac_lanham]

Either of the two would be an upgrade over Russell depending on if they want to play on special teams. I can't vote

 

[HybridPHIN 23]

Rogers and Robinson have more potential..... wasted potential that is. I'd like to see us grab one of those guys over Russell myself.

 

[Fresh]

I don't know if my opinion is even allowed, but Charles Rogers would be my pick.

 

[djfresh47]

If Koren Robinson could ever lay off the booze or learn to call a taxi he'd be my choice. Was a pro bowler last year for his special teams work. Actually Cliff Russell would be my last choice but Robinson is out of the league for a year.

 

[postermaster]

Rogers and Robinson have more potential..... wasted potential that is. I'd like to see us grab one of those guys over Russell myself.

But, what about the salary cap?, we could use that money to sign a DB, which is our biggest need...

 

[BrazForPhins]

I don't know if my opinion is even allowed, but Charles Rogers would be my pick.

:sidelol:

 

[LostInPatsLand]

No to Rogers. He's a turd.

If we're simply talking WR, I'd have kept Gibson, but Russell makes sense since we also have to play special teams during football games.

 

[Muck]

I'd rather line up Reverend Jim Ignitowski than Koren Robinson. He's looking at a 1 year suspension anyway.

To be honest, I'm not too high on Rogers either. He seems to have turd written all over him. But I don't know.

 

[Boik14]

Based on production so far in the league its got to be koren robinson. based on the fact koren's out this season and russell was only kept because he, unlike vick and gibson, is not practice squad eligible, its got to be rogers because he represents the kind of upgrade saban was talking about when he said he was looking to improve the depth 1-53 on this team. Rogers still has the ability to turn this around. A change of scenary could definitely help that. Nick also recruited him his final recruiting class at michigan state (prior to LSU job) so i fully expect the move soon.

 

[rafael]

Reality is that Russell is the only one likely to have an effect this year b/c we need the 5th wr to play ST. Having said that I really like Roger's potential and would love to have him sit on the end of the bench for a year.

BTW, "but c'mon, he is a second pick overall", is one of the worst reasons ever to think a player is a good addition. Ryan Leaf was a second overall as well.

 

[Gonzo]

I voted for Koren because I think it's funny that he's an option. :hi5:

 

[Coral Reefer]

I'd rather line up Reverend Jim Ignitowski than Koren Robinson.

:sidelol:

I'll officially open the Jim Ignitowski for 5th WR voting!
Blast from the past!
I loved that character.