Who would you rather want? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Who would you rather want?

DOL-FAN92

Practice Squad
Joined
Jan 22, 2008
Messages
223
Reaction score
0
Location
Orlando,Florida
Should we trade for either:

A- Chad Johnson of the Bengals

B- Roy Williams of the Lions

C- Javon Walker of the Broncos

D- Draft a WR

E- We are fine the way we are

F- I like KFC

G- Other WR
 
out of those roy williams. but there are others id rather have.
 
A. Chad Johnson he is a really talented player i would love for him to come to miami
 
Roy Williams, think he'd have a chip on his shoulder since Det. did nothing but draft WR the last couple of years after he was drafted. Kinda of a show of disrepect when you consider the other needs that they really needed.
 
Roy Williams is the best one on that list. But that just means it will take more to get him.
 
I think R. Williams would fit in Miami the best..he hasnt had a Palmer throwing tho him most of his career, he is more gifted IMO...Id be willing to part with the Chambers 2nd rounder then we have upgraded a position that is in need of one.....

Booker is history(thanks for nothin) Hagan is a backup..we need a Roy Williams type IMO
 
i would like to have johnson but he can big a headache with his big mouth and the way the league is headed he may be a bigger headache, and walker is useless, so id have to go with williams
 
I would swap 1st rounders with detroit and take williams off their hands in a heart beat. Plus there is a lot of talk here in detroit of the lions trading Roy and going more to a run oriented attack style.
 
I would prefer chad, but you can't really go wrong with roy. either player would greatly help our offense.
 
I choose D. With a receiver class that's as deep as the 2008 class, I would much rather draft a guy or two, coach them up, and be able to call them one of our own from Day One. It's all about the Draft!
 
I choose D. With a receiver class that's as deep as the 2008 class, I would much rather draft a guy or two, coach them up, and be able to call them one of our own from Day One. It's all about the Draft!

we have that in ginn
 
A. hmmmmm.... a tempting choice having oucho cinco around the fins. I like Roy but if I had a choice between the two I would choose the more talented CJ.
 
A. hmmmmm.... a tempting choice having oucho cinco around the fins. I like Roy but if I had a choice between the two I would choose the more talented CJ.


Have to disagree he is more talented, I think he's just in a better situation
 
We are not in position to trade draft picks for veteran players. We need to rebuild with youth. But at WR, I wouldn't spend a high draft pick on one, this year. If we are to develop a young QB, he needs weapons now, just some guys who are capable of getting open. And rookie WR generally have a hard time contributing. It's just too much for them to learn, from technique to reading defenses so that they can run option routes. That said, I would like to see us sign two of the following free agent WR.

Bryant Johnson, 27 years old, 6'3, 215 lbs. He's been a solid #3 guy, but has been stuck behind Fitzgerald and Boldin. He would jump at a chance to start for someone.

Andre Davis, 29 years, 6'1, 195 lbs, came on late in the season, and is explosive on kick returns.

Ernest Wilford, 29 years old, 6'4, 218 lbs, had a solid ending to the year, including a good game against the Pats in the playoffs.

Justin Gage, 27 years old, 6'4, 212 lbs, another guy who really came on in the 2nd half of the season.

Of those 4, I'd be really happy if we got Johnson and Gage. It shouldn't break the bank to sign either one. There are also some other guys with potential available, like Drew Carter, DJ Hackett, and Devery Henderson. I know that none of these guys are big name players, and none are star caliber. But, this year, after the Chambers trade, we had no legitimate starting caliber players at WR. Most of these free agent guys have been solid #3 type guys with the potential to be #2 guys. For right now, I'd rather see us address our needs on defense, the o-line, and at TE through the early part of the draft. And I think we could land a couple of solid WR with potential in free agency.
 
Back
Top Bottom