Do you really think he's played poorly or is it more he hasn't mad an impact on the few chances he's been given? Have we've seen more evidence of poor route running, dropped pass or not knowing his assignment than would be typical for a first or second year player? I haven't seen enough of him to make that call, but I know you watch a lot more tape and break things down. What have you seen him do that's really poor?
I think the team is sold on going into the season with Parker, Stills, Wilson, Amendola and Grant. Not sure they will look at a 6th on the 53-man roster. I think the odds are greatly against Carroo make the roster, but I don't know that we've had enough game tape of him to really say what he's doing well or poorly.
Despite reputations, Leonte Carroo got here as a rookie and did not take things seriously for his entire first year. The team weren't happy with him. He has admitted he did wrong. But in some ways when you do that, the damage is done.
He tried to reinvent himself in his second year. He got opportunities. He was on the field for 101 pass snaps. He produced 69 yards on 12 throws, 7 of them caught. He didn't force a single missed tackle. He got 12 yards after the catch.
We talk a lot about Jakeem Grant. He got LESS of a chance than Leonte Carroo did in 2017. He got only 92 pass snaps. But he turned that into 203 yards on 21 attempts, 13 of them caught. He did it by causing 7 missed tackles, creating 150 yards after the catch.
One of these two took his fate into his own hands and did the work of showing he's worth a lot more attention. The other...just...didn't. You don't get to be a starter in this league because you "deserve" it until you prove absolutely beyond a shadow of a doubt that you don't deserve it anymore. You get opportunities, you run with it. Carroo never did. Not as a rookie, not as a second year, not in preseason.
Even in preseason Leonte Carroo has had 110 pass snaps, only produced 90 yards on 12 attempts, 9 of them catches. Again, not a single missed tackle. About 29 yards after the catch. That's really just not very good.
Again compare to Jakeem Grant, who had 81 pass snaps, producing 303 yards on 22 attempts, 13 of them catches, forcing 2 missed tackles and gaining 129 yards after the catch. All of that is incredible. He went out and seized it. Leonte Carroo has been...just a body out there.