Would Waddle have won the Heisman is Smith was injuried instead of him. | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Would Waddle have won the Heisman is Smith was injuried instead of him.

Vol&dolfan

Starter
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Messages
1,582
Reaction score
242
Age
44
Location
Oak Ridge, TN
I'm trying to sell my self to the Waddle pick. I was pretty sure that after Pitt's was taking by the falcons that Waddle was the pick ever said soo during the draft after the Pitt's pick. I would have taken Sewell or Smith. Now I trying to sell myself to Waddle. And No i don't think he was a bad pick just would have taken the other two ahead of him. But back to the ? Would Waddle have won the Heisman if Smith would have went down instead of him?
Here's the stats for both when Waddle Went down. Would have made this a pole But I'm near the bottom of my wild turkey bottle and couldn't figure out how.

D. Smith rec-38 yards-483 TD's-4

J. Waddle rec-25 Yards-557 TD's-4
 

artdnj

Time is Now
Club Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2004
Messages
6,657
Reaction score
4,352
D Smith is a class act as is Waddle. Both balled out although Waddle was on fire pre injury.
 

Joe Dolfan

Club Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2005
Messages
4,613
Reaction score
4,453
Age
49
Location
Santa Cruz, CA
Yea So we F'd up passing on D. Smith. Cause he done something Waddle couldn't have done.
That's why I gave you that answer. I think it's what you wanted to hear.

That's flawed thinking though. First of all, no one knows who would've won, and it doesn't matter anyway.

How many Heisman winners amount to anything in the NFL?

Edit: Or rather, how many are the best in the NFL? How many are drafted the same year as another player at the same position that ends up having a better career?
 

Vol&dolfan

Starter
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Messages
1,582
Reaction score
242
Age
44
Location
Oak Ridge, TN
That's why I gave you that answer. I think it's what you wanted to hear.

That's flawed thinking though. First of all, no one knows who would've won, and it doesn't matter anyway.

How many Heisman winners amount to anything in the NFL?

Edit: Or rather, how many are the best in the NFL? How many are drafted the same year as another player at the same position that ends up having a better career?
No really that's not want I want to hear. But now D. Smith and J. Waddle are always gonna be compared to each other is that far NO! J. waddle coming in to a team that has 2 50/50 catchers Parker and Williams, The speeder's Fuller and LOL i Can't believe I saying this but he replaces The Dream Grant.
How much u want to bet that D. Smith puts up better numbers?
 
Last edited:

FINOMINAL

Scout Team
Joined
Apr 30, 2007
Messages
2,004
Reaction score
1,033
Dude, watch the highlights and just know that cat is a Miami Dolphin. Maybe rewatch some of our other deep threat guys from last year. Was there a highlight? I don't remember one.
 
Top Bottom