Would you do this? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Would you do this?

DaMiAmIDoLpHiNz

Practice Squad
Joined
Aug 24, 2004
Messages
610
Reaction score
4
Location
San Jose, CA
Would you trade Chris Chambers for Reggie Wayne? Serious answers guys i know we are biased and stuff but seriously...Would you like this trade?
 
I wouldn't but that is because we wouldn't be gaining enough value in Wayne to offset the cap hit
 
My first choice would be to team Wayne and Chambers together here in Miami. :wink:

As for who I would rather, I don't know if I could give a real unbiased opinion. Both are outstanding receivers, but I would have to lean to keeping Chambers. I just like what I see from Chambers more. Besides the drop problems he has had, he is one of the top receivers in the league imo.

So, I choose Chambers.
 
No, Wayne still hasnt shown what he will be able to do as a number one receiver when he isnt lined up across from Harrison with Peyton throwing him the ball.
 
Keep Chambers. If you put him in Indy as the second guy he'd have three 1000 yard seasons by now.
 
Personally i just dont see whats so great about him. Hes good but I dont think hes as good as Chambers but honestly I havent really seen him play that much. I think Chambers is better though.
 
No, CC has shown flashes (more lately) of becoming a true #1. Wayne has never been in that position. IMO he also has more physical ability than Wayne.
 
DaMiAmIDoLpHiNz said:
Would you trade Chris Chambers for Reggie Wayne? Serious answers guys i know we are biased and stuff but seriously...Would you like this trade?

Interesting to compare today's answers with what you would have heard 3 wks ago. But I'd say no anyway. CC is great!
 
dolphan north said:
Interesting to compare today's answers with what you would have heard 3 wks ago. But I'd say no anyway. CC is great!

Personally, I was among those criticizing CC and I would have said they same thing 3 weeks ago. I didn't think either player had proven they were a true #1, but that CC had more potential.
 
Back
Top Bottom