Draft Winds: Four defensive prospects for Dolphins
OLB Shea McClellin, Boise State
Quick Take:
• Versatile linebacker prospect that lined up in multiple DL and LB positions
• Played in a blitz-heavy, diverse scheme and developed a feel for blitzing gaps
• Non-elite 1st step but build up speed on 2nd & 3rd steps help him execute array of moves
• Smart player that keeps his eye on the ball and has a feel for passing lanes in coverage
• Not quite Jarret Johnson physical, but a physical player that could play like a Connor Barwin
Last week, Richard gave you a great run down on a Boise State player that is probably more of a pure pass rusher in Tyrone Crawford. I consider Crawford to be more of a linear player that will lock down a certain position in the NFL and work at mastering the nuances of that position. This week I wanted to take a look at Crawford’s Boise State teammate, Shea McClellin. He is more of a versatile, multiple guy that you will start to hear a little more about as he climbs the Draft boards leading up to the Draft, much as Koa Misi did a few years ago. I put together one Universal Draft video of McClellin’s 2011 game against San Diego State, and have also linked a video put together by DraftBreakdown of his 2011 game against Nevada.
[video=youtube;urQbtllglpA]http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=urQbtllglpA[/video]
[video=youtube;F0vM9k9bnsk]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F0vM9k9bnsk&feature=player_embedded[/video]
Some players are just fun to watch. You sit down to watch a tape and they do things that make you remember why you became a football fan in the first place. Shea McClellin is that kind of player. He plays in a scheme that really lets him mix things up and use his versatility to make plays in different ways. He will have his hand in the dirt, rushing from a wide alignment or a tight alignment, stunting or engaging an outside rush, or he’ll line up as an up player in positions more familiar to a 3-4 outside linebacker. He also lines up at positions that more closely approximate a weak side linebacker in a 4-3. He will often blitz the interior from an up linebacker position.
The important thing in evaluating a player like this is to separate the scheme from the player. The scheme is fun, multiple, diverse, unpredictable, and really puts the player in position to make plays a number of different ways. But how much of what the player is doing is because of that player’s own unique skills as a football player? Could other, less talented players play this position and make the same plays? This is really important to keep in mind because some guys, like a Quinton Coples or Courtney Upshaw as examples, are not creations of scheme to the same extent as guys like Shea McClellin and Bruce Irvin. The latter two will often have the advantage of really wide splits, streamlined responsibilities, schematic unpredictability, etc.
All that said, I think Shea McClellin may be a special player regardless of scheme. He’s a genuinely big player at 6’3” and 263 lbs, and he moves around a lot better than he has a right to at that size. He ran an unofficial 4.62 in the 40 yard dash at the NFL Scouting Combine, which I confirmed on a re-timing via video software. He had a 9’10” broad jump. He has genuine movement skills at his size. As an example, Koa Misi had better explosive metrics but he was 12 lbs lighter and ran over a tenth slower.
McClellin does not have an elite first step but he builds up a tremendous amount of speed in his second and third steps, which help him to execute pass rush moves on offensive tackles. He has a good spin, and most importantly he has the flexibility and lateral strength to dip under the offensive tackle’s pads at the top of the rush. This is not a necessary trait in a pass rusher, but it sure is nice to have because that lateral strength shows up in other ways and helps guys make all kinds of ‘motor’ plays. His back pedal and ability to get back into coverage really stand out. He is a fluid, though not necessarily explosive mover. He is a smart and instinctive pass rusher that will develop a feel for blitzing, moving before the snap to cause confusion, and ducking through the softest gaps in order to get maximum pressure. In other words, he is a true linebacker. There is an athletic quality to his play that is hard to put your finger on, and is best exemplified by the cliché coaches’ command: “Be an athlete.”
He reminds me of a cross between Paul Kruger and Jarret Johnson, both of whom play for the Baltimore Ravens. He does not have Johnson’s pure vicious physicality but I would say he is more physical than Kruger and, like Kruger, he has movement and pass rush skills that Johnson never possessed. Another guy to compare him with would be Connor Barwin, who made a name for himself this year in replacement of Mario Williams on the Houston Texans defense. Barwin is a little more explosive.
The problem for the Miami Dolphins, is picking McClellin would be very much a Koa Misi do-over. They are similar kinds of players that would play in similar schemes. That makes McClellin not as valuable to the Miami Dolphins until we get on into the meat of the Draft a little bit. Since he will probably go higher than that, I do not think McClellin is destined to end up a Miami Dolphin.
You may be wondering, why run him down like this if I do not think he ends up a Dolphin? It is because the fit with the scheme the Dolphins ran under Mike Nolan is so natural, and there is a strong possibility that he becomes a hot name in the coming weeks that you hear several dratniks talking about as ‘rising’ up the boards.