2024 Draft Grades per Team

[LargoFin]

1
GRADE: EXCEEDED EXPECTATIONS

CINCINNATI BENGALS - 16 POINTS + 5 impact players = 21 SCORE

1. Amarius Mims OT 5
2. Kris Jenkins DT 5
3. Jermaine Burton WR 2
3. McKinnley Jackson DT 0
4. Eric All TE 0
5. Josh Newton CB 0
6. Tanner McLachlan TE 0
6. Cedric Johnson EDGE 1
7. Daijan Anthony S 0
7. Matt Lee C 3


2
GRADE: EXCEEDED EXPECTATIONS

ARIZONA CARDINALS - 14 POINTS + 5 impact players = 19 SCORE
1. Marvin Harrison WR 5
1. Darius Robinson DE 0
2. Max Melton CB 3
3. Trey Benson RB 1
3. Isaiah Adams G 0
3. Tip Reiman TE 0
3. Elijah Jones CB 0
4. Dadrion Taylor Demerson S 2
5. Xavier Thomas EDGE 0
5. Christian Jones OL 3
6. Tejhuan Palmer WR 0
7. Jaden Davis CB 0


3
GRADE: MET EXPECTATIONS

INDIANAPOLIS COLTS - 10 POINTS + 4 impact players = 14 SCORE
1. Laiatu Latu EDGE 3
2. Adonai Mitchell WR 0
3. Matt Goncalves OT 0
4. Tanor Bartolini C 5
5. Anthony Gould WR 0
5. Jaylon Carlies S 1
5. Jaylin Simpson S 0
6. Micah Abraham CB 0
7. Jonah Laulu DT 1


4 (Tied)
GRADE: MET EXPECTATIONS

LOS ANGELES RAMS - 11 POINTS + 3 impact players = 14 SCORE
1. Jared Verse EDGE 5
2. Braden Fiske DT 5
3. Blake Corum RB 0
3. Kamren Kinchens S 0
5. Brennan Jackson EDGE 1
6. Tyler Davis DT 0
6. Joshua Karty K 0
6. Jordan Whittington WR 0
6. Beaux Limmer C 0
7. KT Leveston G 0


4 (Tied)
GRADE: MET EXPECTATIONS

WASHINGTON COMMANDERS - 11 POINTS + 3 players = 14 SCORE
1. Jayden Daniels QB 5
2. Jer'Zahn Newton DT 0
2. Mike Sainstril CB 0
2. Ben Sinnott TE 3
3. Brandon Coleman G 3
3. Luke McCaffrey WR 0
5. Jordan McGee LB 0
5. Dominique Hampton S 0
7. Javontae Jean Baptiste EDGE 0


6
GRADE: MET EXPECTATIONS

PHILADELPHIA EAGLES - 8 POINTS + 5 players = 13 SCORE
1. Quinyon Mitchell CB 3
2. Cooper DeJean DB 1
3. Jalyx Hunt EDGE 1
4. Will Shippley RB 2
5. Ainias Smith WR 0
5. Jeremiah Trotter LB 0
5. Trevor Keegan G 0
6. Johnny Wilson WR 1
6. Dylan McMahon C


7 (Tied)
GRADE: MET EXPECTATIONS

BUFFALO BILLS - 10 POINTS + 3 players = 13 SCORE
2. Keon Coleman WR 0
2. Cole Bishop S 2
3. DeWayne Carter DT 0
4. Ray Davis RB 0
5. Sedrick Van Pran C 0
5. Edefuan Ulofoshio LB 3
5. Javon Salomon EDGE 0
6. Tylan Grable OT 5
6. Daequan Hardy CB 0
7. Travis Clayton OT 0


7 (Tied)
GRADE: MET EXPECTATIONS

NEW YORK GIANTS - 10 POINTS + 3 players = 13 SCORE
1. Malik Nabers WR 5
2. Tyler Nubin S 0
3. Andrew Phillips CB 0
4. Theo Johnson TE 4
5. Tyrone Tracy RB 1
6. Darius Muasau LB 0


7 (Tied)
GRADE: MET EXPECTATIONS

PITTSBURGH STEELERS - 10 POINTS + 3 players = 13 SCORE
1. Troy Fautanu OL 5
2. Zach Frazier C 0
3. Roman Wilson WR 3
3. Payton Wilson LB 2
4. Mason McCormick G 0
6. Logan Lee DT 0
6. Ryan Watts CB 0


10
GRADE: MET EXPECTATIONS

JACKSONVILLE JAGUARS - 8 POINTS + 4 Players = 12 SCORE
1. Brian Thomas WR 1
2. Maason Smith DT 3
3. Jarrian Jones CB 3
4. Javon Foster OT 0
4. Jordan Jefferson DT 0
5. Deantre Prince CB 1
5. Keilan Robinson RB 0
6. Cam Little K 0
7. Myles Cole EDGE


11
GRADE: MET EXPECTATIONS

GREEN BAY PACKERS - 8 POINTS + 3 players = 11 SCORE
1. Jordan Morgan OL 3
2. Edgerrin Cooper LB 0
2. Javon Bullard S 2
3. Marshawn Lloyd RB 0
3. Ty'Ron Hopper LB 0
4. Evan Williams S 0
5. Jacob Monk G 0
5. Kitan Oladapo S 0
6. Travis Glover OT 0
7. Michael Pratt QB 3
7. Kalen King CB 0


12 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

LOS ANGELES CHARGERS - 7 POINTS + 3 players = 10 SCORE
1. Joe Alt OT 5
2. Ladd McConkey WR 0
3. Junior Colson LB 0
4. Justin Egboigbe DT 0
5. Tarheeb Still CB 0
5. Cam Hart CB 1
6. Kimani Vidal RB 0
7. Brenden Rice WR 1
7. Cornelius Johnson WR 0


12 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS - 7 POINTS + 3 points = 10 SCORE
1. Drake Maye QB 0
2. Ja'Lynn Polk WR 0
3. Caedan Wallace G 0
4. Layden Robinson G 0
4. Javon Baker WR 0
6. Marcellas Dial CB 2
6. Joe Milton QB 4
7. Jaheem Bell TE 1


12 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

TAMPA BAY BUCCANEERS - 7 POINTS + 3 players = 10 SCORE

1. Graham Barton OL 4
2. Chris Braswell EDGE 1
3. Tykee Smith S 2
3. Jalen McMIllan WR 0
4. Bucky Irving RB 0
6. Elijah Klein G 0
7. Devin Culp TE 0


15
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

MIAMI DOLPHINS - 8 POINTS + 2 players = 10 SCORE
1. Chop Robinson EDGE 3
2. Patrick Paul OT 0
4. Jaylen Wright RB 5
5. Mohamed Kamara EDGE 0
6. Malik Washington WR 0
6. Patrick McMorris S 0
7. Tahj Washington 0


16
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

SEATTLE SEAHAWKS - 7 POINTS + 2 players = 9 SCORE
1. Byron Murphy DT 0
3. Christian Haynes G 5
4. Tyrice Knight LB 0
4. AJ Barner TE 0
5. Nehemiah Pritchett CB 2
6. Satoa Laumea G 0
6. DJ James CB 0
6. Michael Jerrell OT 0
​

 

[LargoFin]

17 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

CHICAGO BEARS - 6 POINTS + 2 players = 8 SCORE

1. Caleb Williams 5
2. Rome Odunze WR 1
3. Kiran Amegadjie OT 0
4. Tory Taylor CB 0
5. Austin Booker EDGE 0


17 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

NEW YORK JETS - 5 POINTS + 3 players = 8 SCORE

1. Olu Fashanu OT 3
3. Malachi Corley WR 1
4. Braelon Allen RB 0
5. Jordan Travis QB 1
5. Isaiah Davis RB 0
5. Qwan'tez Stiggers CB 0
7. Jaylen Kay S 0


17 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

CAROLINA PANTHERS - 5 POINTS + 3 players - 8 SCORE

1. Xavier Legette WR 0
2. Jonathan Brooks RB 0
3. Trevin Wallace LB 3
4. Ja'Tavion Sanders TE 0
5. Chau Smith Wade CB 0
6. Jaden Crumedy DT 1
7. Michael Barrett LB 1


17 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

MINNESOTA VIKINGS - 6 POINTS + 2 players = 8 SCORE

1. JJ McCarthy QB 1
1. Dallas Turner EDGE 5
4. Khyree Jackson CB 0
6. Walter Rouse OT 0
6. Will Reichard K 0
7. Michael Jurgens C 0
7. Levi Drake Rodriguez G 0


21
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

SAN FRANCISCO 46ERS - 5 POINTS + 2 players = 7 SCORE

1. Ricky Pearsall WR 0
2. Renardo Green CB 0
3. Dominick Puni G 0
4. Malik Mustapha S 0
4. Isaac Guerendo RB 4
4. Jacob Cowing WR 0
6. Jarrett Kingston G 1
7. Tatum Bethune LB 0


22 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

LAS VEGAS RAIDERS - 3 POINTS + 3 players = 6 SCORE

1. Brock Bowers TE 1
2. Jackson Powers Johnson C 0
3. DJ Glaze OT 1
4. Decamarion Richardson CB 1
5. Tommy Eichenberg LB 0
6. Dylan Laube RB 0
7. Trey Taylor S 0
7. MJ Devonshire CB 0


22 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

BALTIMORE RAVENS - 5 POINTS + 1 players = 6 SCORE

1. Nate Wiggins CB 0
2. Roger Rosengarten 5
3. Adisa Isaac EDGE 0
4. Devontez Walker WR 0
4. TJ Tampa DB 0
5. Rasheen Ali RB 0
6. Devin Leary QB 0
7. Nick Samac G 0
7. Sanoussi Kane S 0


22 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

KANSAS CITY CHIEFS - 5 POINTS + 1 player = 6 SCORE

1. Xavier Worthy WR 0
2. Kingsley Suamataia OT 5
4. Jared Wiley TE 0
4. Jaden Hicks CB 0
5. Hunter Nourzad OL 0
6. Kamal Haden CB 0
7. CJ Hanson OL 0


22 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

NEW ORLEANS SAINTS - 5 POINTS + 1 player = 6 SCORE

1. Taliese Fuaga RT 5
2. Kool AId McKinstry CB 0
5. Spencer Rattler QB 0
5. Bub Means WR 0
5. Jaylan Ford LB 0
6. Khristian Boyd DT 0
7. Josiah Ezirim OT 0


22 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

ATLANTA FALCONS - 4 POINTS + 2 players = 6 SCORE

1. Michael Penix Jr. QB 0
2. Ruke Orhorhoro DT 3
3. Bralen Trice EDGE 0
4. Brandon Dorlus DT 0
5. JD Bertand ILB 0
6. Jase McClellan RB 0
6. Casey Washington WR 0
7. Zion Logue DT 1


22 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

DALLAS COWBOYS - 4 POINTS + 2 players = 6 SCORE

1. Tyler Guyton OT 3
2. Marshawn Kneeland EDGE 0
3. Cooper Beebe G 0
3. Marist Liafau LB 0
5. Caelan Carson CB 0
6. Ryan Fluornoy WR 1
7. Nathan Thomas OT 0
7. Justin Rogers DT 0


22 (Tied)
GRADE: BELOW EXPECTATIONS

DENVER BRONCOS - 4 POINTS + 2 players = 6 SCORE

1. Bo Nix QB 3
3. Jonah Ellis EDGE 0
4. Troy Franklin WR 1
5. Kris Abrams Draine CB 0
5. Audric Estime RB 0
7. Devaughn Vele WR 0
7. Nick Gargiulo G 0


29
GRADE: DUMPSTER FIRE

TENNESSEE TITANS - 3 POINTS + 1 players = 4 SCORE

1. JC Latham OT 0
2. Te'Vondre Sweat DT 3
4. Cedric Gray LB 0
5. Jarvis Brownlee CB 0
6. Jha'Quan Jackson WR 0
7. James Williams S 0
7. Jaylen Harrell EDGE 0


30 (Tied)
GRADE: DUMPSTER FIRE

CLEVELAND BROWNS - 0 POINTS

2. Mike Hall DT 0
3. Zak Zinter G 0
5. Jamari Thrash WR 0
6. Nathaniel Watson LB 0
7. Myles Harden CB 0
7. Jowon Briggs DT 0


30 (Tied)
GRADE: DUMPSTER FIRE

DETROIT LIONS - 0 POINTS

1. Terrion Arnold CB 0
2. Ennis Rakestraw CB 0
4. Giovanni Manu OT 0
4. Sione Vaki S 0
6. Mekhi Wingo DT 0
6. Christian Mahagony G 0


30 (Tied)
GRADE: DUMPSTER FIRE

HOUSTON TEXANS - 0 POINTS

2. Kamari Lassiter CB 0
2. Blake Fisher OT 0
3. Calen Bullock S 0
4. Cade Stover LB 0
6. Jamal Hill LB 0
6. Jawhar Jordan RB 0
7. Solomon Byrd EDGE 0
7. Marcus Harris DT 0
7. LaDarius Henderson G 0​

 

[jimthefin]

Surprised to see Detroit so low.

I don't go to the lengths Largo has with a point system and taking more than a few minutes to decide but with a cursory look at all 32 teams I did not see too many terrible efforts.

I also did not see too many great hauls.

Chicago obviously truly changes the course of the team with Williams/Odunze early but beyond that I did not see any incredible drafts.


And this is not directed at Largo or anyone else but I don't think you can really rank or grade drafts until the guys play for a few years.

Now you can try to rank how well you think they used their draft capital and if they "played" the draft game well but no onw knows who is going to out perform or under perform and we won't for a while.

That being said I appreciate all the work that went into this, nice Job Largo!

 

[jimthefin]

But I am with you on Cincy, the first 2 picks at least.

That is what I wanted the Fins 2 round haul to be.

 

[Kebo]

Browns draft was bad, but they got my boy Myles Harden in the 7th round.

I hated the Bo Nix pick so Denver gets a D from me.

Jets, Titans, and Lions sucked.

Falcons draft wasn’t good, but I do like Penix.

 

[tay0365]

If there is one thing history has told us, nobody really knows who had a good draft, and who had a bad draft, only that some had a popular draft, and some were not as popular.

In a few years, come back to this draft, and then actually talk who had a good draft, and whose draft was very forgettable.

If Chop and/or Kamara, turns out to be a quality pass-rusher, Paul a starting L-tackle that gets the job done, Wright a weapon at RB, and one of the two Washingtons find a roster spot or better, does anyone really care what people originally thought of the 2024 picks?

 

[SF Dolphin Fan]

Middle of the pack sounds about right for Miami. That could obviously change if Robinson and Paul come close to their ceiling.