No the diff is AJ supporters realize he may not be the guy, we just see teh skills and hope he matures and becomes good. The detractors feel like he suks so there should be no more talk and we should go out and get a qb. They will be more than happy to lose badly the next 5 games to say "See I am right, now where are the fins asking me to be GM"? That is the impression given.
Sooooo if you draft a qb in 05 and he suks, would you be so quick to dispose of him? they are either great from the 1st snap or they should be cut? If a rookie behind a decent o-line gets more than one season, why shouldnt a guy with 5 career nfl starts behind one of teh worst lines in history get that same luxury? Oh wait I know, AJ wasnt the guy they weren thinking of when we were pursuing a qb last offseason, so he cant be any good.