fitzgerald top 5? | Page 3 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

fitzgerald top 5?

fitzgerald top 5 wr?

  • Total voters
    42
For Fitzgerald, Steve Smith, or Santana Moss to be considered a top 5 WR they have to do it for more than one year, & Steve Smith agrees.
 
SMadison29 said:
For Fitzgerald, Steve Smith, or Santana Moss to be considered a top 5 WR they have to do it for more than one year, & Steve Smith agrees.
Click to expand...
fitzgerald was good last year, too. and smith was good in '03
 
No he is not a Top 5. Not sure he is even a top 10. All these guys are better IMO.... (not in any order)

Moss
Owens
Johnson
Harrison
Holt
Smith
Ward
 
Firesole said:
He's not even #1 on his team.

In order to be top five you actually have to better than one of these guys:

Steve Smith
Randy Moss
Terrel Owens
Chad Johnson
Marvin Harrison


I think he and his teammate Anquan are tied for #6 personally.
Click to expand...

Personally those are bad choices. Steve Smith has had only one good recieving season and this season. Then you lose all your credibility by not putting Torry Holt in your top 5.
 
kastofsna120 said:
fitzgerald was good last year, too. and smith was good in '03
Click to expand...

Fitzgerald was decent last year & Smith had a good year in 03, but neither was great, that's what we're talking about when comparing them to the likes of Moss, Owens, Harrison, Holt, & Chad Johnson. Smith said so during an interview on NFL Live tonight. He said give him one more year to prove himself & I agree.
 
To all the people saying Smith wasn't good last year and other years, it's because in his rookie year, he only started 1 game, and last year he only played in 1.
 
Larry Fitzgerald is bad-***....Im wearing his jersey as we speak...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom