McKinney has problems with line calls, this is why he couldnt beat out Ruddy. If he has this under control he could be a decent starter, if he falters then St. Clair could be forced into that position negating our most versatile back up. We will be fine on the left side and actually be able to run to that side again Smith and James will anchor this line for years. On the right side Carey will be good but will falter and make rookie mistakes, the RG spot worries me. If the reports on Nails are true about him having his weight under control and being fully recovered from the 2002 injury I really think we should give him a shot. If nothing more than a training camp contract, if he is back to 2002 form he gets a contract if not he is cut with no loss to us. BUT if he is back to 2002 form how good does our OL look with he and James at G, Smith and Carey at T, and McKinney or St. Clair at C.