QB's since Marino

[chillwill3000]

In your opinion, of all the guys that have quarterbacked the Phins since Marino retired, who did the best job/worst job?

Jay Fiedler (2000-2004): Went 36-23 as a starter, including 21-10 during the 2000 and 2001 seasons.
Damon Huard (2000): Won his lone start in the 2000 season, replacing an injured Fiedler.
Ray Lucas (2002): Went 2-4 in replacing Fiedler for a stretch of the 2002 campaign.
Brian Griese (2003): 3-2 record in five starts, while Fiedler went 7-4 in the other 11 games.
A.J. Feeley (2004): 3-5 record in eight games as Dolphins finished 4-12 overall.
Sage Rosenfels (2004-2005): Started one game in each of those years, losing both.
Gus Frerotte (2005): Went 9-6 to highlight Nick Saban's first season as Dolphins coach.
Daunte Culpepper (2006): Went 1-3 before Dolphins shut him down for season with knee problems.
Joey Harrington (2006): Replaced Culpepper, going 5-6 in 11 games.
Cleo Lemon (2006): Lost his lone start, the season finale at Indianapolis.
Trent Green (2007):
John Beck(2007):

 

[vere76]

i would of like to to see Gus or Joey last year, both were gamers!we could have 4 or 5 games with either one

 

[Bumpus]

Best: Fiedler

Worst: Lucas

... but, that's starters ...

as for relief: gimme Sage (I'll never forget the comeback vs. Buffalo)

 

[Stitches]

Best was Jay and Gus, and you have to wonder what would have happened if Gus got more oportunity.

Worst was easily Ray Lucas.

 

[DolfanAdam]

Fiedler was definitely the best, Hard to say about the worst because most of these people never got a reasonable chance to prove themselves and/or they were placed in an exceptionally poor situation. From a pure statistics standpoint Trent, Cleo and John, have all probably done the worst as far W-L record but it's also not fair to say that given this years O line, among numerous other things were all well aware of.

 

[retired opfinistic]

QB's since Marino

Oxymoron?

Seriously, as bad a rap as Feidler got (me included) he was the best we've had.