2015 Video- Who Would You Rather Have: Derek Carr Or Ryan Tannehill?

[DKphin]

 

[BennySwella]

I think Carr is the better pure passer but Tannehill does give him a run for his money in this debate. I think almost all fans who arent Fins fans would pick Carr.

 

[Bruh Man]

Ryan. Anyone who says otherwise has an agenda against our qb. Tannehill will lead the team to the playoffs on his way to the pro bowl this year

 

[SCLSU Mud Dogs]

If Tannehill just had a season like Carr, with a 86 quarterback rating and 6.5 ypa, people would have a ****ing conniption.

 

[superphin]

On a Dolphin message board we all know who's going to win. Give me Carr, I think he has more potential and a higher ceiling as long as injuries don't derail his career. Carr in the next couple of years could be one of the 5 best QB's in the NFL, while I think Tannehill will hover around borderline top 10.

 

[superphin]

If Tannehill just had a season like Carr, with a 86 quarterback rating and 6.5 ypa, people would have a ****ing conniption.

His y/a was 6.8 not 6.5. Which is on par with Tannehill's 1st 3 seasons.

 

[Rick Cartman]

It will be interesting to see who has the better season this year. Tannehill is in his 3rd season with Gase and Carr is working with Gruden.

 

[randomname]

IMO it's a wash so you go with the younger guy (Carr).

 

[Manning]

I think Carr is the most overrated player in fb

 

[superphin]

Ryan. Anyone who says otherwise has an agenda against our qb. Tannehill will lead the team to the playoffs on his way to the pro bowl this year

Anyone who doesn't agree with me is a communist.

 

[ANUFan]

I watch Carr play last season and that probably wasn't the season to watch him. But after all the positive press he was getting i had to see with my own eyes what it was all about.

I was disappointed or rather didn't get it.

What's the big deal with this guy?

 

[NBP81]

Is Carr available?

 

[rent this space]

His y/a was 6.8 not 6.5. Which is on par with Tannehill's 1st 3 seasons.

Tannehill never had a 6.5. He went 6.8, 6.7 and 6.9 in his first 3 seasons

 

[superphin]

Tannehill never had a 6.5. He went 6.8, 6.7 and 6.9 in his first 3 seasons

I'm saying Carr's y/a last year was 6.8 which is on par with Tanne's 1st 3 years. SCLSU had said his y/a was 6.5 I was correcting him.

 

[rent this space]

I'm saying Carr's y/a last year was 6.8 which is on par with Tanne's 1st 3 years. SCLSU had said his y/a was 6.5 I was correcting him.

Ah, I mis-read