32.6 Rating for the Guster... | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

32.6 Rating for the Guster...

Jimmy James said:
If I'm not mistaken, that's .1 better than Feeley was against Pittsburgh last year.
Click to expand...

AJ played in horrible weather. What's Gus's excuse?
 
I'm not making excuses -- I'm putting the number in context. I'll let you partisans play the analysis game.
 
Jimmy James said:
If I'm not mistaken, that's .1 better than Feeley was against Pittsburgh last year.
Click to expand...

Who gives a crap what happened in Pittsburgh last year, AJ has played better every time he has gotten the ball both at the end of last year and in the preseason. Never in his last few preseason or regular season games has he had as horrible of a game has any of Frerotte's last few, and Frerotte has had 3 bad ones.
 
do you guys ever quit? we'll find out who starts in a couple weeks
 
Sirspud said:
Who gives a crap what happened in Pittsburgh last year, AJ has played better every time he has gotten the ball both at the end of last year and in the preseason. Never in his last few preseason or regular season games has he had as horrible of a game has any of Frerotte's last few, and Frerotte has had 3 bad ones.
Click to expand...

I take it you're on AJ's side. I'll give you a hint -- you can make a stronger argument based on the fact nugget I gave you than the one you're making. Good luck with it (and by that, I don't mean I'm on your side -- I honestly think we're in for lackluster QB play either way).
 
Jimmy James said:
If I'm not mistaken, that's .1 better than Feeley was against Pittsburgh last year.
Click to expand...
So AJ Was a little worse in his first start for the Fins in a brand new offense, during a hurricane, against perhaps the best defense in the NFL; compared to Gus , playing in a familiar offense for the third straight year, against an aging Bucs defense in the pre-season. You just made it so much clearer to me, AJ should start the season.
 
Dolfan4life! said:
So AJ Was a little worse in his first start for the Fins in a brand new offense, during a hurricane, against perhaps the best defense in the NFL; compared to Gus , playing in a familiar offense for the third straight year, against an aging Bucs defense in the pre-season. You just made it so much clearer to me, AJ should start the season.
Click to expand...

You didn't mention the fact that the Steelers were a darn good team that went deep in the playoffs, but you otherwise laid out the argument I'd expect the AJ folks to make based on that stat.

The Gus argument would be that AJ had a bad game against the Steelers and Gus did tonight -- so what?

Like I say, I can't get too worked up either way.
 
Jimmy James said:
You didn't mention the fact that the Steelers were a darn good team that went deep in the playoffs, but you otherwise laid out the argument I'd expect the AJ folks to make based on that stat.

The Gus argument would be that AJ had a bad game against the Steelers and Gus did tonight -- so what?

Like I say, I can't get too worked up either way.
Click to expand...

Well, I did say that Pittsburgh had one of the best defenses last year...
 
Jimmy James said:
You didn't mention the fact that the Steelers were a darn good team that went deep in the playoffs, but you otherwise laid out the argument I'd expect the AJ folks to make based on that stat.

The Gus argument would be that AJ had a bad game against the Steelers and Gus did tonight -- so what?

Like I say, I can't get too worked up either way.
Click to expand...

AJ has progressed in his QB play. Gus hasn't, he's a veteran who has been mediocre for years. AJ may continue to be mediocre, which Gus has shown he will be (if not horrible), but there is only one way to find out if he will be good or play at the level he did at times last year.
 
Jimmy James said:
If I'm not mistaken, that's .1 better than Feeley was against Pittsburgh last year.
Click to expand...
JJ, I can't believe you are tossing out statistics from last year, those have no comparsion at all to this year, (I mean, there are no common factors to look at or to compare even scientifically, different coaches for one, and that was a regular season game, and this was after all a Preseason game..)

JJ... :shakeno:

(;) )
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom