50 Greatest Dolphins of All Time | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

50 Greatest Dolphins of All Time

Hey Ted,thanks for posting that...i personally think that Zach should've been ranked higher than JT on that list,but it is what it is i guess...
 
phinfan33 said:
Hey Ted,thanks for posting that...i personally think that Zach should've been ranked higher than JT on that list,but it is what it is i guess...
Click to expand...
I agree. JT was a reach at his spot. I thought Zach should have been in the top 5.

Although not a player, I am pretty surprised that Shula was not ranked.
 
Manny doesn't deserve this....I was saying his name for like 18 picks in a row...and yeah I am personally repulsed at the thought of what JT must have done to be rated so high on somebody's list. Zach is gotta be #3 to a lot of fans of football players.
 
I have many problems with the order of this list but I'll only mention one. Lamar Smith at 49 with Ricky Williams at 50? Really Lamar Smith? I can't see him even being on the list outside of that monster playoff game he had against Indy. He only had 1139 yds and 14 TD that year. Ricky won the frigging rushing title for us.
 
TheDon74 said:
I have many problems with the order of this list but I'll only mention one. Lamar Smith at 49 with Ricky Williams at 50? Really Lamar Smith? I can't see him even being on the list outside of that monster playoff game he had against Indy. He only had 1139 yds and 14 TD that year. Ricky won the frigging rushing title for us.
Click to expand...


and carried the ball like 800 times between two seasons along with what? maybe another 100 catches between 2002 and 2003. And you know he never ran outta bounds. He probably got hit over 1000 times between those two season but was only tackled like 100. He rarely got tackled it was more of him running a guy over and the leg got tangled.

Ricky really should be top 30.


And WTFFFFFF Where is T-Buccccccccck. He wa better than madison i feel.

But maybe its just me and because its more fun to say T-Bucccccccck than madison
 
wow ricky at 50 is a surprise.! when ronnie browns career is over has to be placed top 25 atleast
 
Considering both JT and Zach are HOF caliber players I have no problem with JT's ranking. But I would have put Zach right behind him. As for Ricky yes he should be higher, and I believe after this year Ronnie should be on the list already.
 
WestCoastPhins said:
Considering both JT and Zach are HOF caliber players I have no problem with JT's ranking. But I would have put Zach right behind him. As for Ricky yes he should be higher, and I believe after this year Ronnie should be on the list already.
Click to expand...


This is a very flawed yet fun list.
 
CHAD4MVP said:
wow ricky at 50 is a surprise.! when ronnie browns career is over has to be placed top 25 atleast
Click to expand...

I think Ronnie should have been on the list already. I mean Mandich but, not Ronnie?

I understand that we won some SBs back then. But, it seems like some of the older players got on like Mandich where some of the newer guys should have been like Ronnie. And I agree on Smith. Lamar Smith but, no Ronnie?

I also think Richmond Webb should have been higher. I think he, Little and Stephenson were the three best Dolphin OL ever. Langer and Kooch were in the next tier IMO.

But, overall it was a pretty good list.
 
DanMarino is #1? WTF!!!!!!!?!!!!!!!!:couch3:
 
I know I said I would only mention the Lamar Smith over Ricky Williams thing but.....
As someone already mentioned where is Madison and T-Buck also Louis Oliver and Troy Vincent or even Pete Stoyanovich? As far as Lamar Smith I could see putting Kareem Abdul on the list before him and that's not to say he should be on the list either but yeah Ronnie should be on. And if they are gonna have a spot for players that played great for a short period of time how about Irvin Fryer? He averaged over a 1,000yds receiving all three years with us and was Dan's favorite target as he was breaking all the records, hell that's more impressive then Lamar Smiths one year here.
Oh yeah another one year wonder that deserved to be on before Lamar Smith would be Adewale Ogunleye he won the sack title while he was here!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm glad Ricky found his way on the list.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom