80 vs 90-00 QB Comparisons | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

80 vs 90-00 QB Comparisons

Dredd1050

Dredd1050

A STRONG MAN SHEDS BLOOD BEFORE TEARS
Joined
Aug 3, 2004
Messages
3,199
Reaction score
10
Age
49
Let's play a game. Do you think these comparisons are fair?

P. Manning = D. Marino

T. Brady = J. Montana

D McNabb = J Elway(pre-SB wins)

Can anyone else make a comparison? Who is the current Troy Aikman?

I used overall skill, playing style, and career so far.
 
Very good comparisons Dom.

Brad Johnson= Brad Johnson

YES, he has been in the league that long!!
 
dominizzo said:
Carson palmer = Dan Fouts

Mike Vick = randall Cunningaham (early days)

Matt Hasselbeck- Phil Simms

Drew Brees= Terry bradshaw
Click to expand...

Bradshaw was not a #s guy he was a winner, Brees so far is the opposite so I don't agree w/ that comparison.
 
Drew Brees = Boomer Esiason (I don't really know if they play similar or not)

Jake Delhomme - Aikmen (maybe?)
 
Stitches said:
Drew Brees = Boomer Esiason (I don't really know if they play similar or not)

Jake Delhomme - Aikmen (maybe?)
Click to expand...

Pennington= Kosar? I'm not too sure Kosar had a stronger arm.

Delhomme is in no way Aikmen. I'm not sure who could be compared to Aikmen in the league right now.
 
Dredd1050 said:
Let's play a game. Do you think these comparisons are fair?

P. Manning = D. Marino

T. Brady = J. Montana

D McNabb = J Elway(pre-SB wins)

Can anyone else make a comparison? Who is the current Troy Aikman?

I used overall skill, playing style, and career so far.
Click to expand...

These are pretty much perfect comparisons! I was even gonna say S McNair = J Elway (before all of Steve's injuries of course, but he's playing well now)
 
dominizzo said:
Carson palmer = Dan Fouts

Mike Vick = randall Cunningaham (early days)

Matt Hasselbeck- Phil Simms

Drew Brees= Terry bradshaw
Click to expand...
This is pretty much right on too! Maybe not Brees and Terry so much, but good comparisons!
 
Matt Leinart - Joe Namath

clear.gif
20041015insidenamathko-1.jpg
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom