As a Jets fan I would rather have Scott over Lewis. Ray Lewis is getting old and isnt what he once was. Plus he's not going to have Scott, Suggs, Ngata, and Reed with him in New York. It's going to be on him more and at age 33 can he really handle all of that?
I mean he does have some good players with the Jets on Defense (Rhodes, Revis, Harris, Jenkins, Pace) but there going to be learning Rex Ryans system and are not as familiar with it as the guys in Baltimore would be.
Scott is younger and the star power of Ray Lewis and huge expectations with him wouldnt be there. He would in my opinion be able to blend in better.
However one of the good things about adding a guy like Ray Lewis would be the leadership and fire he brings. I didnt really see that on the Jets defense this year. Plus he would also be able to help the other players learn what Ryan wants to do on Defense and make that transistion easier.
In the end though I doubt Lewis leaves Baltimore.