Ahmad Brooks or Jason Berryman? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Ahmad Brooks or Jason Berryman?

Which one should we draft?

  • Ahmad Brooks

    Votes: 41 91.1%

  • Jason Berryman

    Votes: 4 8.9%
  • Total voters
    45
  • Poll closed .
We should draft Ahmad Brooks, I think Berryman will be a UDFA. I know what his skills are like I have watched him play. He has talent, but every year he does something stupid. I don't see anyone giving up a pick for him.
 
I'm a homer on Berryman cause I love ISU, but the talent Ahmad Brooks is far greater then Berryman. They both have off the field issues though. I'd take Berryman in the 7th or Brooks in the 4th.
 
Brooks without a doubt. He seems to fit what Saban is trying to do more in terms of his ability to tackle, rush the passer, and play coverage. Ahmad Brooks would have been a first rounder if he stayed in school for this year. I say we give up a fouth for him.
 
Say no to Brooks until at least the 5th round.

Qjason-did you mention ahmad brooks is in the supplemental draft? isnt that guy a flat-out stud from uva, and worth a 2nd rd pick in the supp?
kevin, palm beach gardens., fl 6/01/06
AWe've talked about him. He was very good a couple of years ago. However, knee injuries, weight problems (he was up to 285 pounds about a month ago) and off-field issues (think Ricky) have killed his value. I think he's more along the lines of a 5th rounder. Jason Cole 6/01/06
 
Marino13fanboy1 said:
Say no to Brooks until at least the 5th round.

Qjason-did you mention ahmad brooks is in the supplemental draft? isnt that guy a flat-out stud from uva, and worth a 2nd rd pick in the supp?
kevin, palm beach gardens., fl 6/01/06
AWe've talked about him. He was very good a couple of years ago. However, knee injuries, weight problems (he was up to 285 pounds about a month ago) and off-field issues (think Ricky) have killed his value. I think he's more along the lines of a 5th rounder. Jason Cole 6/01/06
Click to expand...

Why, because Jason Cole said so?
 
i would be very happy to see us drafting brooks, he is a great talented guy and would help us...
 
Brooks for sure. We could use help at the LB position. I don't really think we need anymore D linemen
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom