AJ..the right choice......

[16wins4fins]

once konrad gets back we must utalize him on passing downs,keep gordon and konrad on the field to block the d men who push threw our porise o line at least konrad and gordon give a.j a few more seconds.i blame dave for not doing this in the first place .one more loss to pitt and wanny is gone

 

[Emskirch]

You're truly hilarious. In case you didn't notice, I was under attack by 3 other blinded homers, much like you. Your selective quotes don't mean anything. When was that said? After they drafted him? And what reflects more his opinion on him than trading him away. If he was that valuble they woulda kept him.

You are so far off, blinded homer? No, I am not.

What I am though is someone who has reserved himself that this season is shot. So, give the kid a chance.

Your right, all qb's (Farve) who are valuable stay with a team no matter what. The quote was after he won his 4th straight game with the Eagles. Now, where is your quote from Andy Reid saying he is nothing more then a 3rd string QB?

Where is your quote again? Oh yea, you pulled it out of your arse.

I have no problem having a logical conversation. But don't bring your two cents and put it into someone elses mouth, and then cry and belittle a post that actually proves you wrong and then say your being side swipped by homers.

Dude, your argument is weak.

 

[PhinBeck]

Wow. Apparently your points have no validity, since you feel the need to call me an idiot and a front runner. I sit in section 448 win or lose, so don't call me no front runner you punk.You can't handle the truth, since you watch the games with no objectivity. The fact that you say Feeley should be the man even if he throws 4 picks, just shows that your hate for Jay will let you put up with this sorry pick throwing machine. So next time debate me, argue whatever but don't call me an idiot. And if you want to call me an idiiot, come to section 448 and do it, not on a message board.

See if he continously throws 4 ints then no he shouldnt just get a free ride. But the MAJOR disgreement I have is that Jay has had 4 years, he still makes the same mistakes AJ does. Diff? Jay has been sarting for 4 years and has not gotten past the inconsistencies and bad decisions. Yep AJ is mnaking bad decisions, and yep that gotta change, but he is inexperienced and needs to play and learn to determine his ability. AJ is the typical young qb that relies on his arm and tries to gun the ball in. Palmer threw a couple passes last nite That should have been picked. Palmer is going to be good, but all young qbs make mistakes. Palmer has an established line and rb to help take pressure off him. That is huge to a young qb. Yes Palmer is a "pedigree" qb and has potentially greater upside, but point is even great young qbs make mistakes, and Plmer made mistakes having more help than AJ did.

I am not trying to change your mind, I am trying to get you to see the diff. You bash AJ and say it is objective, well sorry opinions are all subjective, if you have an interest in it, it is subjective. Objectivity reuires distance from the subject, you cannot have feelings in the matter.

Notice not one time did I say AJ in FACT was the answer and will be the answer. I said I believe he has what it takes and playing is teh only way to find out. Yes I have said Feeley would be good and will succeed, because I believe he will, but I dont know, not anymore than you know he wont.

 

[Lawrence]

You are so far off, blinded homer? No, I am not.

What I am though is someone who has reserved himself that this season is shot. So, give the kid a chance.

Your right, all qb's (Farve) who are valuable stay with a team no matter what. The quote was after he won his 4th straight game with the Eagles. Now, where is your quote from Andy Reid saying he is nothing more then a 3rd string QB?

Where is your quote again? Oh yea, you pulled it out of your arse.

I have no problem having a logical conversation. But don't bring your two cents and put it into someone elses mouth, and then cry and belittle a post that actually proves you wrong and then say your being side swipped by homers.

Dude, your argument is weak.

Andy Reid did more than say he's nothing more than a 3rd stringer: He left him at 3rd string even after he 1 four games. Your argument is weak; much like that surfer-girls pick throwing right arm.

 

[Krie30511]

You're truly hilarious. In case you didn't notice, I was under attack by 3 other blinded homers, much like you. Your selective quotes don't mean anything. When was that said? After they drafted him? And what reflects more his opinion on him than trading him away. If he was that valuble they woulda kept him.

I wouldn't call myself blinded considering I Tivoed the game last night and for the fun of it broke down the game and looked at different plays over and over to see what went wrong.... I was bored so I paid very close attention....and if you weren't so adiment about your biased opinon you would stop and look AND SEE that Feely was not the reason for that loss... You cannot put that on his shoulders... when you go back and look at the game play by play you see what he was trying to do....but he could not because of our o-line... He is also young in this system there were a couple of missed communications.....but I'll tell you what he's got the poise & the arm to do this job right for us.... so don't sit there and call me "blinded" when you yourself have not sat back and looked at the reality of this game. You yourself are blinded if you didn't see the potential in AJ... he will be a good QB but considering the circumstances there is not much he can do to help what is going on around him.... lets just say HE DID HIS JOB.....

 

[Emskirch]

Andy Reid did more than say he's nothing more than a 3rd stringer: He left him at 3rd string even after he 1 four games. Your argument is weak; much like that surfer-girls pick throwing right arm.

Can I get any quotes? Any links?

How can my arguement be weak when I am just looking for something with substance, not what Lawrence says?

I guess we can go in circles because you can't produce anything which is fine. Good luck with your up beat attitude!

 

[PhinBeck]

I'm not trying to fight with any Dolfan either. I'm just tired of being called an idiot or a fake fan, simply because I have an opinion and reasons to back them up.

i dont think you are a fake fan. The fact you spend as much time as you do shows me. I do believe you are misguided as to teh qb. I am not enamored by AJ, I believ he young with some potential and he should play to be able to grow and learn. Jay has peaked, he has no more upside, AJ does. The way this season is shaping up, why is it not beneficial to play the young kid and get him experience? yes I like AJ better, he has a better arm and seems to have the intellect, that is what needs to be seen, but sitting on the bench wont help.

 

[Lawrence]

Can I get any quotes? Any links?

How can my arguement be weak when I am just looking for something with substance, not what Lawrence says?

I guess we can go in circles because you can't produce anything which is fine. Good luck with your up beat attitude!

Quote? He Didn't move him to #2 even after he won 4 games. That's not confidence.

 

[Jethatr]

We can go back and forth with why he never made it past 3rd string, but if we did that, we might miss the next pick for a td he's gonna throw.

:roflmao: :roflmao: :roflmao: :roflmao: :roflmao: :roflmao:

 

[Lawrence]

i dont think you are a fake fan. The fact you spend as much time as you do shows me. I do believe you are misguided as to teh qb. I am not enamored by AJ, I believ he young with some potential and he should play to be able to grow and learn. Jay has peaked, he has no more upside, AJ does. The way this season is shaping up, why is it not beneficial to play the young kid and get him experience? yes I like AJ better, he has a better arm and seems to have the intellect, that is what needs to be seen, but sitting on the bench wont help.

Well I appreciate you're understanding of my opinion. I cannot fault you for thinking A.J. should be the starter, I can only respectfully disagree.

 

[BassFin]

Krie30511 & Emskirch, Lawrence is and always has been the biggest Fiedler apologist on this board. You'll only get more and more frustrated arguing with him.

Lawrence, you calling these guys "blinded homers" and such is just the pot calling the ketlle black.

 

[Emskirch]

Quote? He Didn't move him to #2 even after he won 4 games. That's not confidence.

You know what, your right, AJ should just sit. Don't worry about the OLine they are fine, bring Jay back, and sign him long term.

 

[Emskirch]

Well I appreciate you're understanding of my opinion. I cannot fault you for thinking A.J. should be the starter, I can only respectfully disagree.

Who should be the starter then?

 

[Lawrence]

You know what, your right, AJ should just sit. Don't worry about the OLine they are fine, bring Jay back, and sign him long term.

No, No, No, you are right!! Let's keep trading away our future for 3rd string clipboard holders. Great idea!! And by the way, I didn'y say anything about the o-line.

 

[Lawrence]

Who should be the starter then?

Jay Fielder, the man who's led this team to a few 10 win seasons. Let A.J. learn from the vet 1st, then draft a QB for the future if AJ isn't coming along by next year.