Alain Poupart’s hypocritical article about Tua | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Alain Poupart’s hypocritical article about Tua

L

Libermaniac

Active Roster
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Messages
721
Reaction score
1,596
Age
57
Location
Honolulu, HI
He says it’s time to stop the QB comparisons for Tua, and then proceeds to do exactly that. 🤦

www.si.com

Time to Stop the QB Comps for Tua

Instead of worrying about Justin Herbert or Josh Allen, the focus when it comes to Tua Tagovailoa should be that he become the best version of himself
www.si.com www.si.com

He then proceeds to say that you can’t compare Tua’s winning record to Herbert’s (which I do agree with) because football is a team sport, but then neglects to mention that Tua played behind one of the worst lines in football history with no run support and bad WR separation. I’m not intending yet another Tua thread, because I agree, let’s just wait and see what the kid can do this year with a better team around him.

Just wanted to point out how worthless and hypocritical that article was.
 
Poopoo is anti tua. Wins matter more than state. He fails to mention hebert surrounded by pro bowl wrs and rbs and good online but still no playoffs. Hebert is a good qb but judge them evenly after this year. This is first year tua will be 100%physically with good coaches and good player. Tua and hebert player each other this year I think so wait for that game
 
His last name is
Season 9 Nbc GIF by The Office
 
What a shitty article.

First he says you can't compare them. Then all he does is say in the article why Herbert and Allen are better but have limited results because of team deficiencies. No mention of Tuas shitty o-line, rb's or pass catcher's outside of Waddle and Gesicki.

Then he goes on to quickly say in the last couple paragraphs that Tua will succeed because the offense will be more QB friendly as he throws in Goff and Jimmy G as comparisons of limited QBs that can succeed in it. Absolute garbage.

After reading all of that I realized I give "zero ****s" about the author's opinion on the Fins.
 
fishbanger said:
Poopoo is anti tua. Wins matter more than state. He fails to mention hebert surrounded by pro bowl wrs and rbs and good online but still no playoffs. Hebert is a good qb but judge them evenly after this year. This is first year tua will be 100%physically with good coaches and good player. Tua and hebert player each other this year I think so wait for that game
Click to expand...

Sorry but wins really are a bad argument.

Jay Fiedler was 36-16 going into his last year starting.

THIRTY SIX AND SIXTEEN.

Wins are truly a team stat.
 
Last edited:
There are questions i have about Tua, but he hasn't really been set up to succeed here yet from an administrative standpoint.
Flores hiring Chan Gailey out of retirement and then the debacle that was last year didn't do him any favors.
Chan Gailey had been out of the league so long he had thrown away a lot of his notes on defensive coordinators.
Herbert has been able to work with Joe Lombardi and Anthony Lynn.
McDaniel comes from a proficient offensive system, and i'm hopeful his RPO roots will help Tua.
 
teemu7 said:
This guy is not a good writer. He's a horrible post game guest too. Way too into his own opinion bearing out than any sort of objective analysis.
Click to expand...

I agree winning is morew team oriented, that's why I don't get everyone saying Tua has to make the playoffs or win at least in the firt round of the playoffs or it shows he needs to be replaced. The could finish 89 or 9-8 and it might have little to do with Tua. I mean if it's ok for Herbert to go 9-8 and not make the playoffs and still be concisdered alegit stating qb than why shouldn't Tua be granted the same slack. Now if it looks like the rest of the defense and offense is playing good enough to win games but it's obvious Tua is whtat's holding the team back than that's a different story. Think is there are so many qbs in the AFC that are capable of leading their team to wins on any given Sunday that there are going to be weeks thatthe qb and the offense was good enough,however te opposing qb and offense was just as good or better and happened to be on top at the end.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom