All right, own up! | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

All right, own up!

Metal Panda

Metal Panda

One Moe Win
Joined
Dec 24, 2005
Messages
5,842
Reaction score
0
Age
44
Who of you are in the 1% who gave Nick Saban a C this year on the front page poll? Why?

(Seriously, it could make for an interesting conversation.)
 
Yes I would love to hear what the 1% has as their reason why
 
It was prob some ****** who is here for another team.
 
Didn't even see the poll, but just got done listening to Saban's Day After PC, and I must say, aside from the game itself, I'm gonna miss listening to the coach's outstanding Press updates, this offseason.

Watching Saban speak, delivering meaningful, insightful, information,
whether its about players, the draft, our opponents, his philosophy, or the future, never have I had such a clear understanding from a coach's aspect of this team, and the direction its headed.

Aside from our 6-0 finish to this 9-7 season, nothing has been as strikingly clear or profoundly evident than what the mic has conclusively revealed, between this coach, and our last one, every time he spoke through it his season.
 
Alright alright I did, I'll admit it...






I voted him comcastic!
 
A

Took a broken franchise and make 'em winners. I think this year was the closest we'll come to a losing season under Saban.
 
i gave him a B cause he did come i nand we were 3-7 at one point and lost 22-0 to the Browns.

I like wut he did with this team.
 
Easy, it was trolls. Probably pi$$ed jills fans wishing they had what we have... First Herm Edwards in NY, then Biligoat in NE and now we have Lord Saban. Could be a LONG time before Buffalo is in the playoffs again...:D
 
I gave him a B. He did a great job down the stretch but there were a few head-scratching moments early on in the season. I believe he learned from his mistakes and that is why we turned the corner the way we did. I would say an A down the stretch the last 6 games but a C for the first 10 so it averaged out to a B.
 
I voted a B. Mainly because, voting an A says that no improvement was needed. He did an outstanding job, but it's his first year. Super Bowls can't realistically be expected your first year.
 
B. We're not in the post-season. First year coach or not, that's what you have to judge him against.

He did a heck of a job though!!!!
 
I voted A. How can you not with a 5 game improvement? I would have been thrilled with 8-8.
 
apa64che said:
I voted a B. Mainly because, voting an A says that no improvement was needed. He did an outstanding job, but it's his first year. Super Bowls can't realistically be expected your first year.
Click to expand...

Nope.. have to disagree. An A means that the best job was done which could reasonably be expected with the test at hand - specially since this is not a True False or Multiple Guess exam. No Improvement needed would be a Super Bowl - which could not reasonably be expected. I gave him an A because I think he did just about as much as any of us could have reasonably expected at the beginning of the year.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom