All Star Division Team On D?
- Thread starter So Be
- Start date
Pachyderm_Wave
Hartselle Tigers (15-0) 5-A State Champ
- Joined
- Jul 28, 2008
- Messages
- 15,323
- Reaction score
- 13,905
Since 3 of the 4 teams use a 3-4 defense....we'll go that route....
DE - Richard Seymour
NT - Vince Wilfork
DE - Ty Warren
OLB - Aaron Schobel
ILB - Bart Scott
ILB - David Harris
OLB - Joey Porter
CB - Darrelle Revis
CB - Will Allen
FS - Gibril Wilson
SS - Kerry Rhodes
That was tough.....lol
DE - Richard Seymour
NT - Vince Wilfork
DE - Ty Warren
OLB - Aaron Schobel
ILB - Bart Scott
ILB - David Harris
OLB - Joey Porter
CB - Darrelle Revis
CB - Will Allen
FS - Gibril Wilson
SS - Kerry Rhodes
That was tough.....lol
Put Jenkins at NT
Schobel isn't an OLB(I know why you did it since this is 3-4) but there aren't any great OLBs besides Porter. I guess I'd go w/ Pace or Thomas when he's healthy.
take out Allen and put Terrance McGee at Corner
Donte Whitner ahead of Wilson
Schobel isn't an OLB(I know why you did it since this is 3-4) but there aren't any great OLBs besides Porter. I guess I'd go w/ Pace or Thomas when he's healthy.
take out Allen and put Terrance McGee at Corner
Donte Whitner ahead of Wilson
Jetsfan0099
Scout Team
- Joined
- Mar 10, 2007
- Messages
- 814
- Reaction score
- 9
Fixed
ArmyFin7
U cry about the $$$, we do the dirtywork
I'd rather take Wilfolk, if not for the fact of no back issues if nothing else. Though IMO he is a better NT.
Jetsfan0099
Scout Team
- Joined
- Mar 10, 2007
- Messages
- 814
- Reaction score
- 9
Wilfork was never as dominant as Jenkins, he never has taken over a game like Jenkins can and does.
Jenkins>>>>>>Wilfork
Please watch the last years 2nd game against the dolphins. the first game where the wildcat was shutdown all year for the phins. wilfork single handly shut down the offence in that game,
Jenkins was a ghost of himself after game 10 and have never played a 16 game season as NT. Yet you think he is better than vince who has missed 1 game in 5 yrs ? .Also Vince played an extra season in the last 5 year as he went deep into the playoff. so he been avg 19 games a year.
Kerry rhodes - here is the head scratches how come a Safety with more interceptions, more sacks ,more tackles and more forced fumbles is not selected in the division. what did kerry do that is better than this safety.
please explain this
He played 16 games as a NT last year. he was hurt down the stretch and it severely affected our D but when healthy he's up there w/ Haynesworth.
Kerry Rhodes is clearly the best S in the division, not even close. #s don't always tell the story, Kerry had an off year last year but he was excelent the previous 2-3 years.
Kerry Rhodes is clearly the best S in the division, not even close. #s don't always tell the story, Kerry had an off year last year but he was excelent the previous 2-3 years.
Again you are saying he was not healthy to play a 16 game season once as NT but feel that he is what you need to have over a guy who has played in 2 SB and won 1 .Has avged 19 games over the last 5 year ? and has been once on the No 1 defence for a year [04] and anchor of a top 5 defence in 4-5 yrs as a NT.
Rhodes even if numbers do depect anything i am curious the safety i mentioned closed the deal with a game changing interception in the final minute in 1 game, a game winning sack and forced fumble in the final drive where the other team could have won and an ot ending interception and goal. not sure if rhodes had such highlight moments where he won the game on his own.
Again with rhodes i quoted numbers which you said Numbers do not tell the tale so i quoted 3 games where the safety i supported closed the game and caused a sack or FF or Interceptionto close 3 games .I am waiting for you list the non number effect like closing the game out that rhodes made. A play finishing the game.In 2 occasion it was in field goal range thus winning the game.
Deep2Evans
LETS GO BUFFALO!
Since the Bills run a 4-3, I'll do mine that way.
DE - Richard Seymour
DT - Vince Wilfork
DT - Kris Jenkins
DE - Aaron Schobel
OLB - Bart Scott
ILB - Mayo
OLB - Joey Porter
CB - Darrelle Revis
CB - Terrence McGee
FS - Donte Whitner
SS - Kerry Rhodes
DE - Richard Seymour
DT - Vince Wilfork
DT - Kris Jenkins
DE - Aaron Schobel
OLB - Bart Scott
ILB - Mayo
OLB - Joey Porter
CB - Darrelle Revis
CB - Terrence McGee
FS - Donte Whitner
SS - Kerry Rhodes
KlausC
Starter
- Joined
- Aug 11, 2008
- Messages
- 1,349
- Reaction score
- 14
Mayo has to make this team. I'd start him over Harris, even though I'm a huge fan. Harris didn't play great after being injured last year and doesn't have a large body of work to go on.
As for the Wilfork/Jenkins debate, I'd say flip a coin.
As for the Wilfork/Jenkins debate, I'd say flip a coin.
#1dolphinsfan
Perennial All-Pro
I dont think Richard Seymour is a 4-3 DE IMO he is to be a 6'6 guy at 310 pounds as a 4-3 DE i dont think so Just look at guys like Aaron Schobel and Jason Taylor both around 240 pounds and Jared Allen is 270 i honstly think that it would be tough to be a DE at his size i think he would be a better DE in the 4-3 so i dont think he would fit into a Defense like that with our Divison I also think Mayo is better then Harris and i think Wilson is better then Whitner
Deep2Evans
LETS GO BUFFALO!
I agree on Seymour, I just couldn't find any other DEs worthy and he was too good to leave off. I'd never use him there on a real team.
I also agree on Mayo, I forgot about him, I don't know how. He is better than Harris, I'm going to change that.
I disagree on Whitner. He played some FS and is much more effective when there rather than SS where he's played a lot.